Scott Mace (@scottmace) header
Scott Mace (@scottmace) profile picture

Technology, security & healthcare writer/journalist.

Carmel, California
Joined November 2007
Photo by Scott Mace (@scottmace)Photo by Scott Mace (@scottmace)Photo by Scott Mace (@scottmace)Photo by Scott Mace (@scottmace)Photo by Scott Mace (@scottmace)Photo by Scott Mace (@scottmace)Photo by Scott Mace (@scottmace)Photo by Scott Mace (@scottmace)Photo by Scott Mace (@scottmace)Photo by Scott Mace (@scottmace)
Scott Mace retweeted
Jensen Huang just got pushed out of Nvidia by a board that includes two of the VCs who bankrolled him back when Nvidia was three engineers and a Denny's booth. They did it four days after he admitted the affair. Nvidia's lost more than $550 billion in value since, and the board says he isn't coming back. There's a paragraph in Nvidia's charter that explains both of those decisions. Nvidia is a Delaware company. Like most big Delaware companies, its charter says directors can't be held personally liable for money damages when they make a careless call in good faith. If they fired the best CEO in America too fast, shareholders eat that loss. That covers pretty much everything Ackman is accusing them of, including the single Zoom and the fact that nobody slept on it. The protection has one big hole. It disappears if a director acts in bad faith or ignores an obvious red flag. Delaware judges have been leaning on that hole hard. Boeing's board settled for $237.5 million after the 737 MAX crashes, once a judge found the directors had no real system for watching airplane safety. Now look at what this board had in front of it. The Commerce Department asked Nvidia for its records on Megaspeed back in May 2025, and a month later Nvidia put Megaspeed on its own do-not-sell list. Alice Huang, the woman US intelligence officials reportedly believe is a Chinese asset, is tied to Megaspeed. Then the Times reported a second relationship, this one with an executive who reported to Jensen. Three House committee chairmen want testimony. Keep him, and if the investigation finds anything, every director becomes the person who saw a name on their own company's do-not-sell list and kept the CEO anyway. No charter covers that. So run the numbers from their chair. $550 billion spread across the 10 directors works out to about $55 billion apiece, paid by shareholders, so that none of them has to be the director who kept him. Same logic explains the locked door. Harvey Jones, who has sat on that board since the year Nvidia was founded, told investors Tuesday they don't intend to reinstate Jensen. Bringing him back before the investigation wraps would put all 10 of them right back on the hook. Ackman can be right about every word of his process argument and still lose this fight, because the law he's citing protects the exact move he's mad about.
I believe the @nvidia board is not acting in the best interest of shareholders nor in a manner consistent with their fiduciary duties. What we know is that the board fired Jensen or forced his resignation for violating company policy and/or in response to the accusation of an affair with a spy. They did so without careful consideration of the impact on the company, its customers, its shareholders or other stakeholders. They rushed to judgment without the benefit of careful due diligence or even with a basic understanding of the facts. How do we know this? We know this by how quickly Jensen was fired and how little was known at the time of his firing. It takes time to convene a board meeting. There was time, maybe, for one Zoom. And this is a decision that should have been made by a board sitting in person and carefully deliberating the facts once they are known. And they should have slept on the decision and met again the day after to discuss the facts, the risks and the other implications of their decision. The timing and lack of information did not allow for careful board deliberation. While boards can fire a CEO for an inappropriate relationship with a subordinate, it should not be an automatic decision. That is why we have boards comprised of humans and not agents. A board should consider whether or not such a relationship was consensual or whether it was an abuse of power dynamics. And a board has to consider what the impact of the firing is on all stakeholders. If I were in this board, I would not have rushed to judgment based on articles in the media. I would have made sure the board had all of the facts so it could make a careful and informed decision. Boards of Delaware companies have a duty of care which means they must make informed, prudent and good faith decisions. This clearly did not happen here. What law firm is advising this board? Or is the board even taken good legal advice? It doesn’t look like it. And now the board is compounding its failures by insisting that there is no possibility for Jensen’s return as CEO. Why is it in the best interest of the company to foreclose the possibility of Jensen’s return and to do so before all of the facts are known? This is yet another breach of their duty of care. Furthermore, the board has launched an investigation whose scope is unknown. Investigations can be extremely damaging to a company and should be carefully targeted to address whatever facts need to be known rather than be overly broad in scope. In short, this looks like a series of major governance failures by directors that panicked due to headlines in the media. They likely felt compelled to do something because they were afraid of looking bad in the media, not because it was the right thing for them company. They couldn’t stand the heat. The board’s conduct here is shocking for a company of this scale and importance to our country and the world at large, particularly at this moment in history.
23
20
3
197
42,407
Scott Mace retweeted
$TSLA "robotaxis" failing so hard, it's no wonder Musk wants to merge it into $SPCX: 1) 7 crashes in Sep (+17% MoM vs Waymo's +8%) 2) 2nd Cybercab "at-fault" crash 3) 3rd injury crash (1st in a Cybercab) On a miles/crash basis, Tesla robotaxis are 2x more dangerous than humans.
New NHTSA report just dropped and I did some analysis. If we filter for the state of Texas, and incidents with no driver in the vehicle...compare all incidents Tesla vs Waymo and line this up with fleet expansion, we see that there is no statistical difference between Waymo and Tesla in terms of incidence % vs fleet size, over time. Limitation of this: we don't know miles driven, or utilization of each service. Incidents per mile would be a much better measure.
12
36
1
193
7,904
Scott Mace retweeted
I do not think Silicon Valley understands how unpopular it is, how unpopular Trump is and how these two things tend to reinforce one another.
315
1,281
105
17,691
1,089,757
Death machines.
Tesla hit a new record number of reported Autopilot and 'Full Self-Driving Supervised' crashes in September, according to Tesla's own reported data to NHTSA. This includes 3 new fatal accidents reported, and 7 people died while using the features or as bystanders to someone else using Autopilot/FSD.
100
174
8
646
12,410
Scott Mace retweeted
The NY Times has the receipts today. Here's how the Nvidia Blackwell chip laundering worked. 1. Nvidia was blocked from selling Blackwell chips to China. So Jensen Huang sold them to Alice Huang at Megaspeed which installed them in data centers in Singapore, Malaysia, and Indonesia. 2. Howard Lutnick's family and company (Cantor Fitzgerald) were also heavily invested in these southeast Asian data centers and Lutnick blocked regulatory enforcement against Nvidia. 3. The data centers then either sold compute to China or hollowed out the servers and shipped the Blackwell chips directly to China. (Reports of hollowed out servers are from others on X, not in the articles.) 4. Nvidia could claim correctly that they had not shipped Blackwell chips to China. But the Megaspeed middlewoman (Alice Huang) was clearly facilitating Chinese access. 5. The Trump administration has known this for a year. Jensen Huang and President Trump were eager to sell Blackwells to China so they opposed the restrictions and didn't seem to mind the circumventions of the embargo. Secretary Rubio seems to be the main character within the administration trying to enforce the law. It is also true that no one can run Nvidia other than Jensen Huang. So we are left in the unfortunate position where the CEO of the most important tech company in the world messed up and now the stock is going to crater and lots of people won't be able to retire because their stock portfolio just got nuked. nytimes.com/2026/11/14/techn… nytimes.com/2026/11/15/us/po…
1,065
4,007
453
12,940
2,546,373
These stupid fucking cybercabs are "for personal use." Ten years of promising FSD buyers could rent out their cars for profit, *YOU CAN'T EVEN DO THAT WITH THE LITERAL FUCKING TAXI.* Elon Musk is embarrassingly full of shit. His investors are rubes. finance.yahoo.com/technology…
63
92
8
785
336,343
What a waste of a weekend for the @JensenHuang fan boys. Instead of banding together to demand much needed corportae governance reforms at one of the country's and market's most important companies, they are petitioning the company to bring back the CEO who trampled all over basic rules of corporate governance. That's while ignoring various smoking guns about his behavior that goes well beyond sex. I know why theyre doing it: Their vaunted AI trade is in jeopardy for a much needed correction to bring some reality to valuations. The fact that any reporter would take these guys seriously is astounding
234
194
24
1,404
98,741
Just terrible. A huge, disgraceful public policy failure thanks to anti-vaxxers
130
796
13
4,671
127,095
Scott Mace retweeted
Outlook has been broken for most of a workday, and Microsoft can't just switch it back on. Every phone and laptop that's been retrying email since this morning would hit the servers in the same second and knock them right back over. That's pretty much how it broke in the first place. Every Exchange server gets watched by an automated health check, and if it fails, it gets yanked out of rotation so nobody's email lands on a broken machine. With one bad server, that's great design. Today a core process on a whole bunch of them started choking at once (Tom Warren reports a rollout spiked CPU and pushed racks into maintenance mode), and Microsoft's own update says servers were failing those health checks and dropping out. So follow one person's inbox. Their server gets pulled, but their Outlook app doesn't know or care. It just keeps retrying, and those retries land on the next server over, which was already running hot from everybody else's retries, so it fails its check too and dumps its users onto the next one. Now multiply that by a product sold to 450 million paid seats. The system that removes sick servers kept making the healthy ones sick. Microsoft's first big move was spreading connection traffic across its worldwide infrastructure. A few hours later it posted that nothing so far had "provided the anticipated relief," which makes sense once you see the chain, because spreading the load in a cascade also spreads whatever's killing the servers. That's why tonight's plan looks so slow. They're walling off a slice of servers, restarting them, letting traffic back in a trickle at a time, and only expanding once it holds. Skip that step and you get what engineers call a thundering herd, where the fresh servers get trampled before they finish warming up. Earlier this evening Microsoft finally said it's seeing positive results. This has happened to them before, by the way. In November 2024, Outlook and Teams went down after a change caused "an influx of retry requests routed through servers." A whole workday later, the hardest part of fixing Outlook is that millions of inboxes are all trying to help.
Replying to @MSFT365Status
We’re opening all available pathways to restore service, as our actions taken thus far have not provided the anticipated relief. We found a core process on affected servers is becoming overwhelmed, causing capacity loss. To validate a potential recovery, we're isolating a portion of infrastructure, restarting affected components, and reintroducing traffic to confirm the services remain stable before applying the change more broadly. More info under EX1550543 and MO1550821 in the Microsoft 365 admin center, as well as status.cloud.microsoft if the admin center is not available to you.
78
221
24
2,152
724,518
Scott Mace retweeted
Why Jensen was fired.
I have a major result to share. I’ve found conclusive forensic evidence that the top 4 Chinese AI labs—DeepSeek, Moonshot, MiniMax and Ant Group—have built their newest models on NVIDIA’s most advanced Blackwell chips, which are barred from export to China. This sounds insane, but I discovered that almost every AI model carries a hidden signature of the GPU that trained it. When a model is first set up, the starting values of its weights are laid out in a pattern that depends on the exact GPU. Each combination of GPU and seed number produces a unique pattern—a sort of fingerprint of the hardware used to create the model. Traces of that pattern survive training into the published model. Again, this evidence isn’t based on any insider information or leaking. It’s based on a forensic analysis of the model weights released by the companies themselves. I searched more than six trillion combinations of chip layout and seed number and matched them to open-weights models. In doing so, I found conclusive evidence that six Chinese AI models—including DeepSeek-V4-Pro, Kimi K3, and MiniMax-M3—were initialized on NVIDIA Blackwell systems. Four of the models match Grace Blackwell, the GB200 and GB300 parts in NVIDIA’s flagship liquid-cooled rack-scale systems. I then verified these results on real hardware. Running unmodified PyTorch with the seeds I’d recovered, a Blackwell B300 reproduced DeepSeek-V4-Flash’s untouched starting weights bit for bit, and a rented GB200 reproduced Kimi K3’s to a correlation of 0.999995. A Hopper H100 reproduced none of DeepSeek-V4-Flash’s, and changing the seed by one broke the match. (DeepSeek’s seed is 953049583 by the way.) The method also was verified to match 24 known open-weights models to the hardware that developers said they used. It is exceedingly unlikely that these results are a coincidence. Across six trillion combinations, the best accidental match should reach only about 8 sigma (i.e., eight standard deviations above what random chance would produce). The real matches range from 49 to 1,385 sigma, and even the weakest single test hits 20. These were data-center-scale training runs. With some analysis of release schedules and model details, I estimate that the largest, Kimi K3 and DeepSeek-V4-Pro, used 2,000 to 3,000 Blackwell GPUs each. Clusters of this size cost on the order of $150 to $200 million each to buy, and across these labs alone would add up to more than half a billion dollars of export-controlled GPUs, not counting experimental compute or otherwise. It’s quite likely that we see multi-billion dollar expenditure on export-controlled GPUs. I am highly confident in this result, and it has been independently verified by senior researchers at OpenAI and Anthropic. You can read the full report at unemploymentlabs.com/checkpo…. There is much more I’ve identified about these models through other forms of checkpoint forensics like this, and will have more to share soon.
169
611
36
7,013
690,688
Scott Mace retweeted
The guy who compared a Trump rally to Jonestown on live Fox News was invited by the Trump campaign. They called his work phone on Monday and asked him to come. His name is Tom Hoyle. He's 57 and runs a small custom printing shop in Charlotte called MadPark Designs with his business partner. He's hated Trump since 1989, back when he was a sophomore in college. And he really, really doesn't like getting sales calls on the shop line, from anybody. So when the rally people called, he said yes. He even signed up with his real name and contact info, because he wanted it on the record that they invited him. Then he had to get through the door. A private security guy asked him straight up if he was a Trump supporter. Tom told him he supports the Constitution, then started talking about his shirt, which was for an old death metal band called Death. He kept going about the history of Florida death metal until the guard gave up and let him in. His plan going in was honestly pretty juvenile. He and a buddy he grew up with figured he'd wait a few minutes into the speech and yell something filthy. Then a Fox News reporter, Lucas Tomlinson, found him standing off by himself and asked if he could interview him live. Tom thinks a white guy with a big beard and a ball cap was pretty much exactly what they were looking for. He told himself he wasn't going to cuss on national TV, so he made it up on the spot. He says the first line and then just waits. The reporter goes "Wait, the Jonestown Massacre?" and that's when he finishes it. He told The Handbasket he picked that up from Billy Crystal, who said on Letterman back in the '80s that you always let the other guy set up your punchline. Tomlinson set it up for him perfectly. A few minutes later some men who said they were Secret Service pulled him aside. He asked if this was about the concession stand, because it closed early and he was starving. They didn't love that and walked him out. On his way out he passed the guard from the front door and told him, hey man, you didn't vet me too well. Think about how many people had a shot at stopping this. The campaign's call list found him. The signup form had his name. A guard questioned him to his face. A Fox crew put him on live TV. Every one of them took one look at the beard and the hat and filled in the rest. That's how almost all of this screening works. Asking somebody what they actually believe takes time, and looking at them takes a second, so everybody just looks. The one check that actually caught him came after he'd already said it on national TV.
Fox: Why are you here this morning? Trump rally attendee: Well, in the late 70s, I was a little too young to go to South America for the Jonestown Massacre. But this is as close as I'll ever get, so that's why I'm here. There's nothing like seeing a cult right up front.
810
6,104
350
47,532
3,281,372
Maureen Dowd on the new three hour Elizabeth Holmes documentary, You Can See Everything, where Holmes still insists she committed no crime. Every health tech founder should watch it. Theranos made life harder for the legit diagnostics startups that came after. Validated data, peer review and FDA clearance before the TED talk is the only playbook that works in healthcare. nytimes.com/2026/10/24/opini…
3
2
4
1,174
There is something really concerning (and disappointing) going on in the US right now. A dangerous and preventable situation. Let me explain. nextstrain.org/avian-flu/h5n… 1/
53
670
87
1,935
362,586
A biological attack is planned for Saturday 600 million pounds of sugar laced with synthetic chemicals will enter the bodies of our children. Wreaking metabolic havoc, injuring vascular architecture, acidifying oral lining, releasing bacterial toxins, and blunting neural reward pathways. Instructing that gluttonous consumption of poison is celebratory.
514
419
152
7,554
1,653,559
Scott Mace retweeted
SORRY IF THIS OFFENDS GROCERY EXECUTIVES, BUT I’M DONE. I just pulled a $4.99 box of cereal off the shelf, brought it to the register, and watched the scanner ring it up as $7.49. When I told the cashier, she said: "Oh, that’s the digital coupon price. You have to download our store app, create an account, search for the item, and clip the digital coupon before scanning." ABSOLUTELY NOT. You inflated the shelf price by 50%, locked the normal price behind an app, and forced me to hand over my personal phone data and email just to pay the actual retail value of a box of food? Stop hiding basic shelf pricing behind data-harvesting apps.
1,918
8,570
379
38,339
1,451,943
Scott Mace retweeted
Your doctor cuts you off about 11 seconds after you start talking. Researchers literally timed it in a 2018 study. That number is why Google's new Lancet result is bigger than it looks. In the study, 98 real urgent care patients texted with Google's AI days before their appointment. No scans, no exam, no bloodwork, just an unhurried conversation about what was wrong. That alone put the correct final diagnosis on the AI's list 90% of the time. Sounds like magic until you learn what medicine has known for 50 years. Back in 1975, a British team published a study in the BMJ tracking which part of a visit actually produced the right diagnosis. The physical exam? The labs? Nope. In 82% of cases, the patient's story alone got the doctor there. Everything else mostly confirmed what listening had already found. So the playbook for accurate diagnosis has existed since 1975. Let the patient talk. Medicine just built a system where nobody has time to run it, and an 18-minute appointment with 11 seconds of uninterrupted patient talk was the result. Google didn't build a superhuman doctor. It built the first clinician in 50 years with enough time to use the method we already proved works. And my favorite detail buried in the study... physicians who read the AI's pre-visit summary said it changed how they treated the patient in over half of cases. Hand a doctor the full story before you walk in the room and you get different medicine. Turns out the most advanced medical instrument Google ever shipped is a conversation that doesn't get interrupted.
Today @TheLancet published our AMIE study with @BIDMC_Medicine, the first prospective study of patient-facing conversational diagnostics in a real clinic. AMIE is a research system people can chat with before doctors appointments. Testing AMIE outside the lab with real urgent care patients showed how technology can help gather medical histories safely. Clinicians reported that the summaries helped them prepare for visits in 75% of cases and influenced their approach to care in more than half. AMIE’s differential diagnoses also matched the doctors’ final diagnoses 90% of the time giving clinicians more time to focus on patient care. It’s Google’s first-ever paper in The Lancet’s main journal!
64
395
60
2,112
161,523
Scott Mace retweeted
Mentions of the word "Fauci" on X have fallen off a cliff since the data centres in Russia were hit Makes you wonder...
335
4,028
141
25,509
385,292
Scott Mace retweeted
I respectfully disagree with the framing of the Amish as the problem. I’ve worked with Amish communities (they are not monolithic btw) and few if any are “strictly religiously opposed” to vaccinations. In fact, when there are outbreaks, Amish religious leaders often work with health departments to facilitate vaccination drives. What we are seeing now is that the longtime protection afforded to undervaccinated Amish communities via broader herd immunity has eroded, under constant misinformation and policy attacks. The Amish are being disproportionately hard hit, but: a) the behavior change isn’t in the Amish, but the non Amish, and b) When faced with an outbreak, the Amish are in many cases MORE likely to accept vaccines, than non Amish who are vaccine resistant.
The majority of the measles cases in PA and SC are among those who don’t vaccinate due to strict religious beliefs (Amish, Slavic etc). That fact isn’t mentioned often but the data is public and very easy to find. The measles vaccine works .. but since some communities observe strict religious exemptions it brings up a good question: what to do about it? Thoughts?
37
184
8
824
27,409
Scott Mace retweeted
🦔SpaceX is in early talks to borrow about $40 billion, mostly through bonds, to buy Nvidia chips for its AI business. The cost to insure SpaceX's debt against default jumped Wednesday to the highest level since that insurance started trading in June. My Take The rating agencies call SpaceX investment grade, which puts its bonds in the safe bucket that pension funds and bond index funds buy. Bond traders disagree. The extra yield on its 30-year bond over Treasuries has climbed to 2.38 percentage points, up from 1.75 when it sold in June, and an S&P analyst said the market prices SpaceX closer to junk than to its actual rating. SpaceX lost $4.28 billion in the first quarter on $4.69 billion of revenue, and much of that came from the xAI business it folded in this year. Rockets and Starlink bring in the revenue. The AI side burns the cash, and the plan now is to borrow another $40 billion at rising rates to grow the business that loses money. If the agencies ever cut SpaceX to junk, lots of funds that can only own investment-grade bonds would have to sell at the same time, and anyone in a bond index fund would feel it. I don't see that happening this year, however, I do think there's a decent chance of a downgrade warning before this $40 billion closes. Hedgie🤗
21
76
13
291
11,400