I'm old enough to remember the Trade Union Studies Information Unit created to support local workers and Trade Unions. Alan Milburn - another one happy to kick away the ladder that helped him rise to the top. Shameful.
5
Rose Milburn retweeted
C4News interviewing Pat McFadden, right after interviewing Milburn…”Alan Milburn has made a very compelling case…”
The combined MSM/UKG propaganda assault to get the public behind this unnecessary cruelty against our most vulnerable citizens is despicable.
Rose Milburn retweeted
#LucyLetby: Can you imagine going to jail on the basis of a coin toss?
Try this for a thought experiment...
Heads: Dr Dewi Evans becomes lead medical expert investigating the deaths and collapses at the Countess of Chester neonatal unit.
Tails: Professor Shoo Lee gets that job.
The babies are the same. The records are the same. The deaths and collapses are the same. Only the reader of the medical notes changes.
In the first world, the records are interpreted as evidence of a series of deliberate attacks. A nurse becomes the subject of a murder inquiry. She is convicted and sentenced to die in prison.
In the second world, a leading neonatologist and an international panel read the same clinical records and find no medical evidence of deliberate harm. They identify poor resuscitation skills, missed diagnoses, inadequate supervision and a unit struggling to care for its sickest babies.
The question becomes how to make the unit safe, not whom to convict.
Professor Lee went further. He said that if this had happened in a Canadian hospital, the unit would have been shut down.
And in July 2016, long before Lee's review, the hospital did downgrade the unit and stop admitting its most premature babies.
So the clinical safety concerns were hardly imaginary.
But the two readers are not interchangeable.
Lord Justice Peter Jackson had previously described a report written by Evans in an unrelated family case as "worthless", criticising its "tendentious and partisan" opinions.
Lee, meanwhile, co-authored the 1989 paper on air embolism in newborns relied upon by the prosecution. He says his research was misinterpreted. His international panel of 14 specialists from six countries reviewed all 17 cases and found no medical evidence of deliberate harm, attributing the deaths and injuries to natural causes or poor medical care.
So the question is not simply which expert we might prefer.
It exposes something significantly more disturbing.
How can substantially the same clinical records support interpretations so far apart that one leads to whole-life prison sentences while the other points towards shutting down the entire neonatal unit?
And if expert analysis can yield conclusions so vastly different, how can we be confident that a jury, without the benefit of the second interpretation, was able to establish beyond reasonable doubt that any crimes had been committed at all?
This counterfactual does not, of course, prove Letby innocent.
It exposes a vastly deeper problem.
It is one thing for experts to disagree about who may have committed a crime. It is quite another for them to disagree completely about whether a crime had been committed in the first place.
If the existence of alleged crimes can depend so heavily on which expert is appointed to interpret the clinical evidence, what does that tell us about the safety of convictions built upon those interpretations?
The foundations of a whole-life prison sentence deserve to rest on something vastly more secure than an interpretation that reflects the choice of the toss of a coin.
Rose Milburn retweeted
I asked some friends of mine to do a few lines of my poem ‘Ode To Square Chapel’ in support of my quest to help #SaveSquareChapelArts in Halifax.
Without hesitation… they all chipped in. 🙌
It’s what friends are for.
Please re-post if you enjoy! x
The new Prime Minister is writing a "10-year plan" for the UK. The arts and culture MUST be part of it. I've signed @_CFTA's petition urging @AndyBurnham to revitalise the arts – to revitalise the whole nation 🌱 Please join me: campaignforthearts.org/petit…
2
56
Rose Milburn retweeted
There have been a steady stream of tide-turnings in the Letby case. All have turned the same way.
—First were the statisticians: glib chat on the courthouse steps about “all the tiny arrows” representing Bayesian posteriors affirming guilt were swamped when it became clear that not only did the crown not perform any statistical analysis, but was actively warned off it by the CPS, but founded their case on unargued probabilities in any case.
—Then the journalists, curious to profile this apparently callous monster and surprised to find she was a diligent, popular, if somewhat mousy nurse, popular with colleagues, not given to antisocial behaviour of any kind, and fitting none of the usual stereotypes of a psychotic murderer;
—Then scientists and neonatologist, at the overt flimsiness of “expert” diagnoses, from limited medical records, of non-specific conditions as definitive evidence of murder, where not one of the ward specialists, pathologists, or coroners who’d had contemporaneous opportunities to examine the infants had noticed;
—Then lawyers, whose usual high-handed & blustery confidence in the integrity of the sainted criminal justice system came apart with the emergence of systematic disclosure failures, adverse rulings, and evidence of overwhelming confirmation bias;
—Then police veterans, whose assumption that Cheshire Police had followed established methods for murder investigations collided with the weird netherworld of Operation Hummingbird’s PR campaigns, press conferences, media training, and bizarre reluctance to do their jobs and pursue all avenues of enquiry (including the plainly obvious possibility that that these might not be murders at all)
—Then nurses, whose apparently telling refusal to speak up turned out to have been required by the NHS trust, but who all, without exception, told Thirlwall they had no concerns about Ms. Letby before her conviction;
—Then parents of children who had been on the COCH ward, with information about how they and their children were treated at the unit at the time in question.
—It makes you wonder who will be next: one of the Consultants, perhaps?
It also makes you wonder at what point does this mountain of, well, “tiny arrows” finally break the stubborn camel’s back, so that these convictions are finally referred back to the Court of Appeal for the full re-examination they so badly need.
Must this defendant, like Mr. Malkinson and Mr. Sullivan before her, wait for decades?
Whose decision should that be?
Will they be held accountable for it?
Not that it is a massive deal with all the other revelations regarding the Lucy Letby case, does anyone else think that naming the investigation into the Countess of Chester Hospital: Operation Hummingbird was a bit of a giveaway as to where their focus was?
Rose Milburn retweeted
"The use of statistics by police investigating Lucy Letby has been further called into question," the Sunday Telegraph reports.
"The CPS has now said that it did not instruct police to terminate its agreement with Prof Hutton," the Warwick University statistician Cheshire police had originally engaged with, and who warned the investigation about the shortcomings of their methods.
The Crown Prosecution Service's denial, reported today by the Telegraph, contradicts what Cheshire police officer Adam Bolger wrote to Prof Hutton in 2021, about why the force were ceasing their ongoing communications with her as an expert statistician.
"We have had a further meeting this afternoon where we have informed the prosecutors that we were looking at the validity of statistical evidence again in the case," Bolger emailed Hutton.
"The prosecutor does not agree with our line of enquiry and has instructed us not to pursue this avenue, any further, at present."
"I'm really sorry if you feel I have wasted your time," Bolger wrote.
By then, he had been communicating with Prof Hutton about statistics and the Letby case for over three years.
What a scam this is!! One ticket, 2 chances to win. The scam’s that Lottery has removed the Lucky Dip in exchange for £1 when you match 2 numbers. At least the Lucky Dip gave a chance to win big next time but £1 doesn’t. New Lotto | The National Lottery national-lottery.co.uk/new-l…
Rose Milburn retweeted
Replying to @TNLUK
Lotto under the old format:
£2M > £3.8M > £5M > £7M
Lotto under the new format:
£2M > £3.6M > £4.7M > £6.4M
Tell us again how great these new changes are
Rose Milburn retweeted
Replying to @TNLUK @McEvoyAlan
@TNLUK can you please STOP replying to people that they have more chances to win and over a year they will have a net increase! Its a load of shite now, listen to the people for once, the changes are negative and even if people win more..THEY WIN LESS! A 2 yr old wud understand!
Rose Milburn retweeted
How can the highest winning prizes in a National Lottery, on a Saturday night, be £1000. This is a slap in the face to all those who have played every week for years. The was only 73 winners of the £1000 also 🤔
Rose Milburn retweeted
"This so-called serial killer had saved our child's life twice, like an angel, without our knowledge... - without telling us...
"Now I have my daughter because of that".
Astonishing new testimony - Lucy Letby quietly saved our baby's life twice, say parents.
“I don't believe for one minute that there's an individual out there who's capable of murdering one baby & then passing up on the opportunity to murder another."
In a stunning new episode of DOUBT, @amandaknox meets a couple who credits Lucy Letby with saving their baby's life.
Rose Milburn retweeted
There is so much vitriol directed not just at Lucy Letby, but at anyone who doubts her guilt. Clare and Carl were incredibly brave to come forward with their story. I hope you'll listen.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcas…
Rose Milburn retweeted
Man of the people, my arse… he’s having your pants down!
Wise up… or lose again. 🤷♂️
Rose Milburn retweeted
A new article in the Mail on Sunday from @ClarkeMicah, discussing my forthcoming book on the Lucy Letby case:
dailymail.com/columnists/art…
Rose Milburn retweeted
Replying to @DailyMail
Finally the mainstream media are waking up to the fact that there never was any evidence of Lucy Letby harming babies, just accusations. Accusations that turn out to be inconsistent with medical evidence and the accusers’ own contemporaneous accounts
Rose Milburn retweeted
Replying to @ClarkeMicah
Thank you for finally exposing this @ClarkeMicah 🙏🙏
One small but important comment, however. They were clearly stated evidence based facts rather than fears. This matters as people’s emotions are not relevant when it comes to objective investigations, which this grievance was.
Most grievances within the NHS are of terrible quality but this one was excellent. Well done to the HR professional involved.
Rose Milburn retweeted
The Sun has picked up today's story. Despite Judge Goss best attempts at suppressing this relevant and contextual information from the jury who did not hear these details, the truth is emerging and almost all of the print media know this case is an MOJ.
thesun.co.uk/news/39266488/l…






















