The Bench (@ReadTheBench) header
The Bench (@ReadTheBench) profile picture

🏈 #Football & #FantasyFootball No filters. 🔥 Hot takes ❄️ Cold facts 📊 Unapologetic analytics, news, and opinions straight from The Bench.

Joined February 2025
The coach matters. Eric Morris coached Mahomes at Texas Tech, helped land Mayfield as a walk-on, and found Cam Ward at Incarnate Word. Under Morris, Mahomes rose from the 32nd to the 94th percentile. Mestemaker went from 93rd to 75th after moving up to the Power 4.
1
385
His style isn’t Allen’s or Murray’s. He throws shorter than every QB in this group, and only Lawrence scrambled less. He’s a rhythm passer in a QB-friendly Air Raid. The 75-yard run vs. Oregon was a flash, not his identity.
1
383
The arm is real. On throws 20+ yards downfield: 9 TD, 1 INT, 83rd-percentile accuracy, 89th-percentile yards per attempt. But he only throws deep at a 39th-percentile rate. The arm shows up when he lets it loose.
1
397
Against history, it gets louder. His final-season PFF percentile score: 54. Every 1.01 QB since 2018 scored 76 or higher. Burrow scored 97. Only Josh Allen (38) was lower. And Allen became an MVP.
1
442
The tape says something different. PFF graded 4 of his games under 56: Tulsa, Houston, Iowa State and Texas Tech. Iowa State: 5 TD in the box score. 5 turnover-worthy plays on tape. Grade: 51.9.
1
557
Adam Schefter expects an “auction” for the No. 1 pick so a team can draft Oklahoma State QB Drew Mestemaker. So I compared him to every 1.01 QB since 2018, plus Brady, Rodgers, Mahomes and Allen. The box score vs. the tape vs. history. 🧵 #NFL
2
1
17
11,298