Peter Nicholai retweeted
A deal came across my desk this week
Largest revenue-collecting enterprise in America:
> 71M customers
> 185M people funding it
> Mandatory participation
> No competitors
> No churn
On paper it's the best business model I've ever seen, so I ran diligence
It's Social Security
Put my analyst on the financials:
> He came back in 4 hours
> He did not look well
Started with the revenue model:
> 12.4% of every dollar you earn
> 6.2% withheld from your paycheck
> 6.2% paid by your employer, which is your money taking a longer route
> Applied to the first $184,500 of income, then it stops
That's the collection engine
Then I traced where the money goes
First finding:
> Nothing was set aside
> The money comes in from workers and goes out to retirees the same month
> The surplus got spent the moment it arrived
> The "trust fund" everyone talks about is $2.56T of the government holding IOUs from itself
> It has paid out more than it took in every year since 2021
> Last year the shortfall hit $160B
> I asked him where the actual money was
> He said "it already left, sir"
Second finding:
> The model only works if the people paying in can cover the people cashing out
> In 1960 there were more than 5 workers for every person collecting a check
> Today there are fewer than 3
> In 20 years there will be fewer than 2.5
> And 4.1M Americans are turning 65 every year right now
> The largest wave of retirements in the country's history
> My son was at the table
> He looked at the chart
> He said "so fewer and fewer people are paying for more and more people, and at some point it stops working?"
> I said "that's the structure, yes"
> He went back to his cereal
> My analyst looked up from his laptop
> He said "sir, with respect, this looks like a pyramid scheme"
> I corrected him
> A pyramid scheme is illegal
> This one is mandatory
Third finding:
> The headline says the money runs out in 2034
> Then my analyst found the footnote
> It is not one fund
> The old-age and survivors fund and a separate disability fund, kept apart by law
> The 2034 number blends them
> Un-blend them and the retirement side, the one almost everyone is counting on, goes first
> Not someday. Not a generation from now
> The fourth quarter of 2032
> After that the math only allows it to pay 78 cents on every dollar it promised
> A 22% cut. Automatic. No vote required.
What it would take to close the gap:
> Raise the 12.4% payroll tax to roughly 16.8%
> Cut every benefit by more than 20%, immediately and permanently
> Or some combination of the two
A remediation plan that's actually passed: none.
Pulled the cap table:
> The first person ever to collect a monthly check was a woman named Ida May Fuller
> She paid in $24.75
> Her employer paid another $24.75, which was also her money
> She collected $22,888.92
> More than 460 times what went in
The model front-loaded its winners
My wife read it over my shoulder
She did not argue with any of it
She never does
She just looked at me, then looked at the ceiling, and said nothing
She thinks I take things too far
She also thinks I'm right
Here's my diligence conclusion:
> Took your money for 40 years
> Spent it the month it arrived
> Set nothing aside
> Built a model that runs on demographics it no longer has
> Left a 22% cut to trigger in 2032
> Has no fix that ever passed
In any other deal we'd have a word for this
In this one we call it your retirement
I'm not saying anything
The economic model is saying it
Make common sense common again
Plz fix. Thx.
Sent from my iPhone
Peter Nicholai retweeted
Hello Julia, sans aucune ironie, c'est top que tu prennes le temps de te renseigner. Mais le problème quand on lit Marx aujourd'hui, c'est qu'on prend pour acquis sa prémisse de départ, alors qu'elle a été démontée scientifiquement il y a plus de 150 ans.
Toute la pensée de Marx repose sur la théorie de la valeur-travail. L'idée que la valeur d'un bien vient de la quantité de travail nécessaire pour le produire. Si tu acceptes cette prémisse, alors oui, tout son raisonnement tient. Le capitaliste "vole" la plus-value du travailleur, l'exploitation est mathématique, la révolution est inévitable.
Sauf qu'en 1871, trois économistes (Menger en Autriche, Jevons en Angleterre, Walras en Suisse) découvrent indépendamment la même chose : la valeur n'est pas objective, elle est subjective et marginale.
Un verre d'eau dans le désert vaut une fortune. Le même verre à côté d'une rivière ne vaut rien. Le travail incorporé est identique. Donc le travail ne détermine pas la valeur. C'est le consommateur qui valorise un bien selon son utilité marginale dans un contexte donné.
Exemple concret : tu peux passer 1000 heures à tricoter un pull moche que personne ne veut. Selon Marx, ce pull a énormément de valeur (beaucoup de travail incorporé). Selon la réalité, il ne vaut rien. Parce que personne n'en veut.
À l'inverse, Bernard Arnault crée des milliards de valeur non pas parce qu'il "exploite" mais parce qu'il a su anticiper et organiser des désirs humains à grande échelle. La valeur est créée par la coordination, pas extraite par le vol.
Cette découverte (la révolution marginaliste) a invalidé tout l'édifice marxiste. Pas pour des raisons idéologiques, pour des raisons scientifiques. C'est pour ça que plus aucun département d'économie sérieux au monde n'enseigne Marx comme un cadre d'analyse valide. On l'enseigne en histoire de la pensée.
Maintenant, le truc important. Si ton intention en lisant Marx c'est d'aider les pauvres (c'est une intention noble), alors tu vas être surprise par ce qui suit.
Regarde les chiffres de la Banque mondiale. En 1820, 90% de l'humanité vivait dans l'extrême pauvreté. Aujourd'hui, moins de 9%. Cette chute historique ne s'est PAS produite dans les pays qui ont appliqué Marx. Elle s'est produite dans les pays qui ont libéralisé leur économie.
Chine post-1978, Vietnam post-1986, Inde post-1991, Pologne post-1989. À chaque fois qu'un pays libéralise, des centaines de millions de gens sortent de la pauvreté en une génération. À chaque fois qu'un pays applique Marx (URSS, Cambodge, Corée du Nord, Venezuela), c'est la famine et les goulags.
Ce n'est pas une opinion, c'est l'expérience la plus massive jamais menée en sciences sociales. Plusieurs milliards de cobayes humains, sur un siècle.
Donc paradoxalement, si tu aimes vraiment les pauvres, la position la plus cohérente n'est pas d'être marxiste. C'est d'être pour la liberté économique. Parce que c'est empiriquement la seule chose qui a jamais sorti massivement les gens de la misère.
Pour creuser, je te recommande trois lectures qui vont changer ta vision :
"La Loi" de Frédéric Bastiat (court, lumineux, gratuit en ligne)
"La Route de la Servitude" de Hayek
"Économie en une leçon" de Henry Hazlitt
Bonne lecture, et vraiment chapeau de chercher à comprendre plutôt que de rester dans tes certitudes. C'est rare.
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
Peter Nicholai retweeted
Be like Mormon - Declare yourself to be a disciple of Jesus Christ and then like those he makes a record of, become one of the holy ones:
"Behold, I am a disciple of Jesus Christ, the Son of God. I have been called of him to declare his word among his people, that they might have everlasting life." (3 Nephi 5:13)
"... that the prayers of those who have gone hence, who were the holy ones, should be fulfilled according to their faith" -Mormon (3 Nephi 5:14)
May your prayers be fulfilled according to your faith. And may your faith be ever increasing on this Sabbath
Peter Nicholai retweeted
Replying to @EricCMeadows
I'm starting a new brand where I focus on the who, and why of Mormon the man, the prophet, the legend.
Hope John appreciates it.
Peter Nicholai retweeted
Jimmy Carr drops brutal parenting truth:
“If you’re kind in the moment, you end up with fat, stupid kids. That’s no good.”
He says real love isn’t giving kids what they want right now (TV, junk food, no books, no effort).
Real love is being “a little bit mean in the moment” so they become who they’re capable of being.
“Hard choices now, easy life later.”
“You’ve got to love who they could be—not just who they are when they’re screaming for screen time.”
Short-term kindness = long-term cruelty.
Short-term toughness = long-term gift.
Which “mean in the moment” rule do you enforce that your kids will thank you for later?
Peter Nicholai retweeted
Hey @RealMattFradd I think you might owe it to me to be able to come on and address the claim that Mormons are atheists.
That’s a bold thing to assert on a major platform like the @realDailyWire without allowing us to give our side of the story.
Reach out to me. I’d be happy to come on.
Retweet if you agree.
Peter Nicholai retweeted
Take the poll.
Vote for Charlie.
kutv.com/news/local/utah-law…
Peter Nicholai retweeted
The memes from the latest competition of September Madness, now downloadable for all.
Peter Nicholai retweeted
Dear Christians who say Latter-day Saints are not Christians.
This is sincere. We have no envy or desire to be counted as acceptable to your mainstream Christianity, any more than Christ wanted to be mainstream.
The Pharisees and Sadducees were the prominent theologians of their day and slandered Christ with all manner of accusations. They made up false charges and rallied sentiment against Him. I just realized that's a type and shadow of our day. The same repeating pattern.
18 If the world hate you, ye know that it hated me before it hated you.
19 If ye were of the world, the world would love his own: but because ye are not of the world, but I have chosen you out of the world, therefore the world hateth you. (John 15:18-19)
We treasure our God-authored theology with all its heavenly power. We are valiant in our testimony of the Savior, Jesus Christ. He is the only name under heaven by which anyone is saved. He was raised on the cross to draw all men unto Him. He atoned for our sins, and for that, we cannot give enough thanks or gratitude.
He deeply loves you and he deeply loves me.
We worship and revere God the Father as well. We are deeply thankful for the ministrations of the Holy Ghost.
We are not walking in your shadow. We are not chasing you to be counted in your club.
We have our own path - lit by fire of the Spirit and the glow of Heaven's errands to guide our way. We accomplish great things in our Lord Jesus Christ, who strengthens us.
For the year 2022, our tithes and offerings covered many, many lovely works. Here is a partial list as reported by Elder Andersen (an apostle) in October:
"From the generous tithes and offerings you have consecrated to the Lord, last year more than a billion US dollars were used to bless those in need.
"In our momentous responsibility to take the restored gospel across the world, we have more than 71,000 missionaries serving in 414 missions. Because of your tithes and offerings, missionaries, regardless of their family financial situation, are able to serve.
"Temples are being built across the world in unprecedented numbers. Currently, 177 temples are in operation, 59 are currently under construction or renovation, and 79 more are in planning and design. Your tithes are allowing the blessings of the temple to be in places only the Lord could foresee.
"There are more than 30,000 congregations housed in thousands of chapels and other facilities in 195 countries and territories. Because of your faithful tithes, the Church is being established in faraway places you may never visit among righteous Saints you may never know.
"The Church currently sponsors five institutions of higher learning. These serve more than 145,000 students. One hundred and ten thousand classes are being taught each week in our seminaries and institutes.
"These blessings and so many more come in large measure from the young and old of every economic circumstance who pay an honest tithe."
As for anyone's hateful heretic hunting, accusations, and slander - I have just one answer: "We respect your right to an opinion but unless you have a direct line to Jesus Christ, it is your opinion. We wish you well in your Christlike endeavors."
May you find peace and joy in your path. Christ loves all.
******
(keywords: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, The Book of Mormon, Joseph Smith, mormonism)
Peter Nicholai retweeted
Seven teachers at Oak Street Elementary School in Kansas were pregnant at the same time.
They posed for a photo to highlight the humanity of their unborn children.
Culture is shifting.
America is becoming pro-baby again.
Peter Nicholai retweeted
“Who should give me feedback on my first novel?”
You don't want just any reader. Also, you are inexperienced in understanding feedback.
Most of the time, for instance, when a reader says “It felt long” or “it was too slow” you will think that means you need to cut.
The opposite is true. 🧵
Peter Nicholai retweeted
Replying to @gXrubicon
IDK the back story. I just know she ate that bat like a snack with a Southern accent thicker than molasses
Peter Nicholai retweeted
How can a good God let you suffer and die?
Tolkien said a 600 year old poem had the answer to this question
He spent over 25 years reading, studying and teaching it to students
Here’s the poem, and what it taught him about God, grief, and finding hope in the face of death…🧵
Peter Nicholai retweeted
Ahahahaha, the James Webb Space Telescope continues to deliver massive L’s for astrophysics.
A new paper shows that the “Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation” can be explained entirely by the energy of recently discovered Early Mature Galaxies — massive galaxies that the JWST discovered which crushed the existing models of galaxy formation because they formed much earlier than astrophysicists thought possible.
But now these EMGs turn out to account for the entire energy density of the CMB radiation, which was believed to be a “snapshot” of the first light emitted after the Big Bang, when the universe was ~379,000 years old. The variations in the CMB were believed to be relics of quantum fluctuations in the dense plasma of the Big Bang.
If these new findings are accepted (and there’s no reason not to accept them), then all of the following flagship findings of cosmology are thrown into question:
— Big Bang theory: foundational cosmological model undermined
— Cosmic inflation: loses observational justification
— ΛCDM model: key parameters become unreliable
— CMB power spectrum: loses predictive relevance
— Dark energy: inferred from CMB; may be mischaracterized
— Dark matter density: current estimates may be invalid
— Age of the universe: must be recalculated
— Primordial nucleosynthesis: needs alternative explanation
— Hubble constant (H₀): no longer reliably constrained by CMB
— Large-scale structure formation: initial conditions unclear
— Reionization epoch: timing and cause questioned
— Cosmic distance ladder: calibration may be flawed
— ISW (Integrated Sachs–Wolfe) effect: interpretation invalidated
— Acoustic peaks in CMB: no longer evidence of primordial sound waves
— Polarization of the CMB: origin needs reassessment
— Baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO): decoupled from CMB
— Cosmic curvature: flatness inference challenged
— Matter–radiation equality timing: re-evaluated
— Gravitational lensing of CMB: loses standard interpretation
— Planck and WMAP findings: foundational assumptions invalidated
My friends, do not listen to scientists when they act like they have everything figured out and you’re a retard for questioning them. They have abandoned the humility needed for scientific discovery long ago, and it’s only when new findings arrive with shock and awe that their hubris is exposed.







































