Laurie Penny (@PennyRed) header
Laurie Penny (@PennyRed) profile picture

Author, journalist, narrative designer, screenwriter. Geek, gender goblin, feminist killjoy, force of culture. Writer for hire, weirdo for free. They/them.

London, England
Joined January 2009
Photo by Laurie Penny (@PennyRed)Photo by Laurie Penny (@PennyRed)Photo by Laurie Penny (@PennyRed)Photo by Laurie Penny (@PennyRed)Photo by Laurie Penny (@PennyRed)Photo by Laurie Penny (@PennyRed)Photo by Laurie Penny (@PennyRed)Photo by Laurie Penny (@PennyRed)Photo by Laurie Penny (@PennyRed)Photo by Laurie Penny (@PennyRed)
PSA: Sex workers and sluts are not why men treat women poorly. Blaming women who are simply living our lives, not hurting you, for misogyny broadly out there in the world is, itself, misogynistic behavior.
7
71
4
360
11,839
Laurie Penny retweeted
'The Voynich manuscript is untranslatable! It's a mystery!' 'Actually it turns out to be about female sexual health.' ... 'IT'S A MYSTERY.'
7
133
14
504
Laurie Penny retweeted
Ngl I appreciate the strategy of hallucinating back at the AI interviewer
176
1,476
221
24,532
2,780,595
Laurie Penny retweeted
‼️ @PennyRed on Britain’s failure to confront its imperial history in 2017: “If you ask British people who voted for Brexit what their major fear is, their fear is that people will come to our country and take our things.” After describing Britain’s own history of colonial conquest: “It just doesn’t compute.” Nearly ten years after the referendum, one of Brexit’s least examined ingredients remains Britain’s dysfunctional relationship with its own history.
38
36
4
125
27,148
Laurie Penny retweeted
Give this girl an Oscar for best actress, best supporting actor, best screenplay, best supporting actress, best actor and best film editing.
this is what everything in the world has been like since 2018
28
2,555
2
33,719
1,438,477
Ayoung man who has lived with different kinds of disadvantage all his life is elevated to a position of  influence and privilege. In this position he is exposed to consistent, merciless attack, until there is no way back. It ends in death. Summarised like this, it has an almost archetypal quality. The proverbial Martian observer would very likely catalogue it with the rituals of sacrificial scapegoating chronicled in many pre-modern societies – the outsider selected for both sacred dignity and ritual humiliation so that some existing order can be consolidated by an act of collective violence. One of the many things we ought to be reflecting on in the wake of the shocking and tragic events leading to the death of Jason Arday is the nature of the shaming rituals of modern culture, the careful gradation of verbal violence from judicious headshaking through to unbridled, annihilating, joyous venom. The philosopher Bruno Latour wrote that “we have never been modern”; it is sometimes alarmingly clear that we have never been “secular”. We still repeat the ceremonies of public humiliation and cathartic sacrificial violence. A debased media culture and the fever-ridden jungle of online comment are just another iteration of habits deeply rooted in human society-building. We should not deceive ourselves into thinking that we have outgrown any of this. On the contrary. The mechanisms of scapegoating are all around us – and are not confined to the political right. Well-meaning efforts to offset the myth of the scapegoat can easily end up colluding with the process. As has so often been pointed out, tokenism sets people up to fail. Unless change is systemic, thought through, and unless it is intelligent about risk, emotional cost and the specific vulnerabilities of individuals, it is simply sucked into the magnetic field of the sacrificial drama: exalt or highlight the victim, then punish and expel. Rowan Williams: The shaming of Jason Arday newstatesman.com/politics/so…
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Arday was not a young man. He was 41 with two children. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jason_Ard…
283
61
87
207
426,130
Laurie Penny retweeted
Wealthy white men with neurodivergent traits still struggle- but they tend to find the neurotypical world safer than autists with less social privilege. The reason for stereotype of autism as a middle class white male thing is that *those are the people most likely to make it*
6
2
1
58
5,660
Laurie Penny retweeted
The backlash against autistic and ADHD visibility is about class, and gender, and race. Especially in the UK. It’s about who gets to be different. I wrote about this last week: lauriepenny.substack.com/p/a…
7
24
4
94
5,579
I wasn't aware that Professor James Orr, Restore Britain's head of policy, hosted Charles Murray, author of The Bell Curve, which argues that 'black people are less intelligent than white people partly for genetic reasons ' at Cambridge University in 2021. bylinetimes.com/2026/08/18/t…
18
84
4
183
13,020
Laurie Penny retweeted
‘Maybe the issue is that people with autism and ADHD should not be allowed in academia’ If this is the cope you’ve chosen, I’ve got bad news for you about academia. In better news, you’re ready to be the villain in an Oscar-winning movie.
15
37
2
327
23,153
Laurie Penny retweeted
Parts of Jason Arday’s life were ridiculed in the press but now a Byline Times investigation says it has found records, analysis and evidence supporting Jason’s accounts. This is devastating🧵 bylinetimes.com/2026/08/18/t…
40
1,796
241
5,138
390,657
Laurie Penny retweeted
.@jk_rowling, who is smeared for sex realism, calls me a bad word for applying the same logic to race
More than one thing can be true. Nathan Cofnas is a racist. No argument there. Also true: Arday claimed to have been non-verbal until the age of eleven. He span a false narrative about being autistic and mute, then learning to speak and write so well he gained a PhD. What harm did he do to parents with children who're genuinely non-verbal, by selling them false hope?
590
495
133
9,366
764,632
Prominant "Gender critical" activist and pundit Kathleen Stock appears to suggest that it's a bad thing that people with autism and ADHD are allowed to become academics.
118
459
114
3,254
107,444
So here’s a modest proposal. Jason Arday is dead. The circus has lost its main attraction. The tent is still up, the popcorn machine is still warm, and several of the ringmasters are wandering around pretending they were merely checking the fire exits. Perhaps The Telegraph, The Spectator, Kathleen Stock, Julia Hartley-Brewer, Julie Bindel, Andrew Neil, Brendan O’Neill and the rest of Britain’s newly discovered Society for Relentless Academic Due Diligence could turn their tremendous investigative appetite towards Nathan fucking Cofnas. You know Nathan. The self-described race realist whose intervention helped detonate the Arday story. The bloke who already believed DEI was corrupting academia. The bloke who has argued that genuine meritocracy would leave vanishingly few Black professors at elite institutions. The bloke who talks about a “hereditarian revolution”. The bloke who, while discussing what comes next for his own career, joked that after “the revolution” he might become head of the department of eugenics and race science at Harvard. That Nathan Cofnas. Come on, lads. You have just spent weeks demonstrating that no biographical pebble is too small to overturn in the sacred pursuit of Truth. So get the fucking tweezers out. Go through his history. Interview the old classmates. Find the former supervisors. Call the ex-colleagues. Dust off the teenage writings. Read Reptiles with a Conscience from cover to fucking cover. Check every citation. Check every footnote. Find out what he believed before he acquired the qualifications he now uses to defend those beliefs. Ask when exactly the fascination with hereditarianism began. Ask what evidence changed his mind. Ask what evidence could change his mind. Ask whether race realism emerged reluctantly at the end of an exhausting empirical journey, or whether the destination appeared on the map first and the intellectual road-building project came afterwards. You wanted to know whether Jason Arday really ran every marathon he claimed. Excellent. I would quite like to know whether Nathan Cofnas has actually demonstrated that Black people are genetically less suited to elite intellectual life, or whether he has spent years developing increasingly elaborate reasons for believing something he found compelling in the first place. Seems at least as fucking interesting as somebody’s 10K split time. And while we are at it, perhaps ask why the alleged misconduct of one Black academic became so magnificently useful to a man whose existing political project already concerned Black representation, DEI and declining standards. Was Arday merely a plagiarism case? Or did Cofnas look at him and see Christmas morning? Because once you have spent years arguing that progressive universities are artificially elevating Black academics, discovering a celebrated Black Cambridge professor with serious questions hanging over his work must feel less like stumbling across evidence and more like finding a fucking golden ticket inside your ideological Wonka bar. And apparently that angle is not worth the same excavation? Really? Jason Arday tells a tall tale about running and Fleet Street behaves like somebody has discovered the Pentagon Papers. Nathan Cofnas spends years developing a political programme around hereditarianism and race, then helps frame a national scandal involving a Black professor, and suddenly everyone develops a tremendous respect for intellectual privacy. How curious. I am not asking for another pile-on. I am asking for the same thing you all claimed to worship while Arday was alive: scrutiny. Context. Provenance. Motivation. Evidence. Standards. Those lovely grown-up words everybody suddenly remembers when they are about to put somebody else under the microscope. 1/2
Replying to @LoinDuTribu
Please don't forget the man who orchestrated the whole attack on Arday is Nathan Cofnas, an academic with extremely concerning views on race.
296
1,480
75
4,911
352,400
I think this has probably shocked me more than anything else. The Times ran multiple ads trashing Jason Arday. This one reached 195,746 people & ran until Aug 16 - today. There’s a rearguard action to defend journalism. But this isn’t journalism. It’s monetised racebait.
815
3,257
153
11,279
637,384
I repeat. Cofnas was NOT fired from university employment. He hed a fellowship and saw it through. He was released from an unpaid, voluntary association with a college.
Nathan Cofnas who "broke" the story about Jason Arday. He says Arday gave him the chance for a story to retaliate for being fired & start a "revolution" against Black people in academia. "After the revolution, I'll be the head of the dept of eugenics & race science at Harvard'.
2
314
7
1,476
74,461
Laurie Penny retweeted
No, it’s not unclear. It’s not complicated. A vulnerable person was bullied to death by people with an obvious, cynical agenda- not because of the mistakes he made, but because he was Black and autistic. Anti-woke ghouls decided to make an example of him. And they enjoyed it.
This quoted post is unavailable.
314
140
35
798
202,574
Laurie Penny retweeted
Nathan Cofnas who "broke" the story about Jason Arday. He says Arday gave him the chance for a story to retaliate for being fired & start a "revolution" against Black people in academia. "After the revolution, I'll be the head of the dept of eugenics & race science at Harvard'.
715
3,058
984
10,757
3,415,008
Laurie Penny retweeted
The Spectator writing 12 pieces about Jason Arday in 10 days sounds exaggerated, but it isn't. If you audit it, you'll find 11 articles plus a podcast in that window. & that's barely scratching the surface. In 22 days it's been roughly: Times/Sunday Times — 44 Telegraph — 43 Mail — 38 Independent — 24 Spectator — 21 Guardian — 19 Express — 12 249 articles across 15 UK outlets over the span of 3 weeks about a professor who was a fabulist & was being investigated for plagiarism. And this is only in the UK. We have not even included the Intl right wing/US media. Cofnas & his ilk recruited others to join them in this public lynching. Actual serial killers, corrupt politicians, & systemic abusers routinely get fewer column inches or media time. Actual white academics who have fabricated research that has killed people don't even get this level of scrutiny. William O'Reilly, the Cambridge Prof who's actually been investigated and found guilty, still has his job. This wasn't about media/social media's need to stand for academic integrity. It transformed into a modern-day public lynching using that as a shell. A blood sport where Black academia was treated like public enemy number one. ​ We cannot ignore the root of this. The fire was lit by Nathan Cofnas(a self-described "race realist"), whose stated views suggest Black people wouldn't hold high-profile roles in a true meritocracy. He blew the dog whistle, and the media eagerly joined the pack & released the attack dogs. ​ They completely weaponised Arday’s mental health. By August 14th, the Mail paraded out a psychiatrist who had never even met him to diagnose him with "pseudologia fantastica" from afar. Hours later, the Telegraph was interrogating whether he was actually non-verbal as a child. ​ The cruelty was the point. The far-right ecosystem & its mainstream media had all their racist genes firing, using every anti-DEI rant to throw in a KKK/NeoNazi pamphlet. Now that the worst has happened, those exact same outlets have smoothly pivoted to offering their "thought & prayers". ​ You don’t get to actively participate in a crucifixion & then send flowers to the grave. The whiplash is sickening. They hounded a man to the edge under the guise of "standards," but we all know exactly what this was.
14
390
21
708
39,027
Laurie Penny retweeted
Replying to @jessesingal
I think it’s worth asking why, of the hundreds of cases of potential academic fraud in a year, his case was the only one to attract headlines and gleeful pileons on social media
Replying to @MPaarlberg
Just one data point, but Retraction Watch - which does important work - posted 300 times about dubious academic research last year, and 180 this year so far. Their database has over 60,000 entries. I don't know how many are fraud, but most don't get in the news to this degree.
105
8
6
62
82,933