Anand Sahay (@Navik_07) profile picture

Opinion Writer; formerly Diplomatic Correspondent, The Hindu; Coordinating Editor, Asian Age and President, Press Club of India (2013-14 and 2019-20)

New Delhi
Joined December 2013
Photo by Anand Sahay (@Navik_07)Photo by Anand Sahay (@Navik_07)Photo by Anand Sahay (@Navik_07)Photo by Anand Sahay (@Navik_07)Photo by Anand Sahay (@Navik_07)Photo by Anand Sahay (@Navik_07)Photo by Anand Sahay (@Navik_07)Photo by Anand Sahay (@Navik_07)Photo by Anand Sahay (@Navik_07)
Anand Sahay retweeted
🚨“The fear is gone” मोदी सरकार के खिलाफ भारत में युवाओं का बढ़ता विद्रोह🔥 लीक हुए परीक्षाओं के पेपर, घटते रोजगार के अवसर और वोटर अधिकारों को दबाने के आरोपों के बीच देश में युवा नेतृत्व वाले विरोध प्रदर्शनों की लहर तेज़ हो रही है। Al Jazeera English के कार्यक्रम UpFront में मार्क लैमोंट हिल ने लेखक और पत्रकार आतिश तासीर से बातचीत की। चर्चा का अहम सवाल है क्या ये विरोध प्रदर्शन भारत के लोकतंत्र के लिए निर्णायक मोड़ साबित हो सकते हैं? क्या मोदी सरकार की सत्ता पर पकड़ कमजोर पड़ रही है? 🎥 देखिए पूरी बातचीत Al Jazeera English पर। #AatishTaseer #NarendraModi #IndiaProtests #IndianDemocracy
4
1
5
2,560
A rekentless,decades old project to stifle both truth and reality has at last been exposed by Sonia Gandhi's memoir to be a crude and vulgar enterprise.
K A Shaji on Sonia Gandhi’s “Belonging” - There is something profoundly satisfying about the extraordinary public response to Sonia Gandhi’s Belonging: A Journey of Love. I see in this moment something much larger than the success of an autobiography. I see the spectacular failure of one of the most sustained political character-assassination projects undertaken by India’s Hindutva establishment. A woman whom the BJP and the Sangh Parivar spent decades attempting to humiliate, delegitimise and politically destroy has reclaimed the authority to narrate her own life. And the public is listening. For decades, the Sangh Parivar invested enormous political capital in manufacturing an alternative Sonia Gandhi. Not the woman who arrived in India through love, who consciously embraced this country as her home, who endured devastating personal tragedies and eventually entered public life, but an entirely fictional political character assembled through prejudice, insinuation and organised vilification. The bar dancer, the Italian stooge, the foreign conspirator allegedly plotting to appropriate India, the Christian agent supposedly entrusted with converting Indians. These were not isolated insults uttered in the heat of political debate. They constituted an ideological vocabulary deliberately designed to make a woman appear permanently alien to the country she had chosen to belong to. I have always found this politics of exclusion profoundly repugnant. What exactly is the crime of becoming Indian through love, conviction, self-realisation and an intimate understanding of this country’s extraordinary civilisational plurality? Is India merely an inherited geographical possession, or is it a political and moral idea that people can consciously embrace? Must nationality be determined by birthplace, ancestry or religious identity? Sonia Gandhi’s life poses these questions with an uncomfortable clarity to an establishment that has spent years attempting to make her foreignness the defining feature of her existence. The irony is magnificent. The woman they tried to permanently imprison inside a fabricated biography has now written her own. The difference between the two projects is unmistakable. The Sangh Parivar’s Sonia Gandhi was manufactured through repetition, television propaganda, political invective and the relentless circulation of insinuations. The Sonia Gandhi who emerges through Belonging speaks through memory, personal experience, emotional vulnerability and the authority of lived history. One was a political caricature designed to provoke hatred. The other is a human being reclaiming her voice. The extraordinary public response to the book is therefore politically significant. Readers are queuing at bookstores. Copies are disappearing from shelves. The memoir is attracting attention across India and beyond. The curiosity surrounding it is not merely curiosity about a political dynasty. It is an unmistakable appetite to encounter a woman whose life has been narrated, distorted, abused and appropriated by others for far too long. And the BJP’s response has been revealing. Even as the book captures public imagination, the familiar machinery of denunciation attempts to reduce it to another political controversy. This is precisely the predicament of an establishment that has invested so much in a manufactured historical narrative: when the subject begins speaking for herself, the architecture of propaganda becomes vulnerable. I find the symbolism of the title Belonging particularly moving. For decades, Sonia Gandhi was repeatedly told, through insults and political insinuations, that she could never quite belong. Her origins were held against her. Her nationality was questioned. Her family was subjected to relentless vilification. Her identity was converted into a permanent political accusation. And now she has written a book whose very title asserts the dignity of belonging… 1/2
4
The BJP is acting stupid! They and the RSS have whitewashed Indian history and Indian politics by calling Modi greatest PM ever, forgetting their Vajpayee! And now they accuse Sonia Gandhi's memoir "Belonging" of whitewashing the past. Running out of ideas?
17
Anand Sahay retweeted
"The BJP needs to get its history right. Tipu Sultan fought four Anglo-Mysore Wars. The RSS did not even participate in the freedom struggle. They did not participate in the Civil Disobedience Movement, Quit India Movement, any of the Round Table Conferences, the Dandi March or the Non-Cooperation Movement... And they are the ones dictating terms..." - @PriyankKharge
328
2,381
40
7,922
101,995
The only solid review of Sonia Gandhi's memoir is by Vir Sanghvi in The Print, though the Guardian did a sit-down interview and the Hindu with written questions sent in advance. They asked pretty set-piece political questions.
1
21
In 25 years, there's been no better writer than Vir on Food, Wine or Politics. The review places the subject in sharp relief. Glad he didn't waste his breath on dilating on the time-worn Emergency, especially when India is up against something far worse.
13
If Pranab Mukherjee in 2010 spoke to Sonia Gandhi about "a change at the top", as Mrs Gandhi notes in her memoir, was he probing if she was ready to conspire with him to engineer a coup against Dr Manmohan Singh? If so, was he losing touch with reality?
1
54
Sad to hear of the passing of Bunker Roy. It's a deep regret I didn't know him. But his work for the poor communities, and creation of a wholly new Gandhian-style experiment at Tilonia in Rajasthan, is a message of faith and valour.
39
Amusing that Bombay High Court quoted the law to say the actor Imran Khan, a US citizen, was an OCI and had no right to join a protest in India. Fine! But the court made his apologies for protesting against SIR. The court made him apogise for obeying his conscience!
1
34
Mahatma Gandhi might have had something to say about this. Gandhi, incidentally, was a foreigner in South Africa. Not an OC . But he developed all his practices and techniques of peaceful protest there, although only a foreigner. Judges take note.Look within.
9
Terfific piece suggesting that RSS chief Bhagwat has no choice but to fall in line with Modi. A lot of detail recalled. Some BJP and RSS watchers cite inner RSS sources as saying RSS is keeping its distance. But is that true? mainstreamweekly.net/article…
16
Anand Sahay retweeted
🔴 How would you rate the INDIA alliance's Ramlila Maidan rally against CEC Gyanesh Kumar on a scale of 0-10 ? 🤔🤔
468
131
25
487
7,830
Anand Sahay retweeted
INDIA गठबंधन की रामलीला रैली में नितिश कुमार भी पहुंचे हुए हैं... यकिन न हो तो इस महिला कोई सुन लीजिए 😂👇
35
860
12
3,400
127,466
Anand Sahay retweeted
Such a Powerful Speech by this lady. 🔥 A single mom just asked the question Modi and Gyanesh Kumar CAN'T answer 🔥😢 Anita Jaiswal. Daily wage worker in Delhi. Voter since 2012. She held up her voter ID and spoke: > "From 2012 to 2025 I voted in every election. My vote made MPs and ministers." > "One day at a cyber cafe I found out my voter ID was DELETED." > "Who gave you the right to delete it?" > "You can't give me a job, can't give me a house. Then who gave you the right to take?" > "Now you prove which country I'm a citizen of." Think about it for a second. > Her court case, her bank account, her daughter's scholarship, all built on that voter ID > 13 years of voting, wiped off in silence > And now they want her to stand in line and fill Form 6 like a stranger Her answer: "I will NOT fill Form 6. Restore my 2012 voter ID." Then she ended with Bismil: "Sarfaroshi ki tamanna ab hamare dil mein hai." The hall stood with her. So should the whole country. Anita ji ka vote chhina, hausla nahi 🗿🔥
5
254
9
632
32,924
Such a responsive political gathering on the move. Delhi has not seen anything like this in at least half a century. I have seen practically all of them. It is in fact hard to imagine a rally so mammoth.
कोई बड़े घमंड और अकड़ में पूछ रहा “कौन राहुल?” उम्मीद है, आज रामलीला मार्च का जनसैलाब देखकर ठीक से समझ आ गया होगा !
1
3
136
Here Neha Bora presents the case for CEC Gyanesh Kumar's impeachment brilliantly- short, succinct, punchy!
BREAKING 🚨 This is full 3-mint speech by Neha Bora She has taken Gyanesh Kumar to cleaners in her speech at mock parliament One of the finest ever speeches with argument on SIR issue 🔥🔥
31