Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98) header
Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98) profile picture

Writing at Against Neutrality on Substack Public Theology | Christian Nationalism | America First

Kansas City, MO
Joined January 2014
Photo by Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98)Photo by Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98)Photo by Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98)Photo by Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98)Photo by Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98)Photo by Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98)Photo by Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98)Photo by Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98)Photo by Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98)Photo by Nathaniel Hillmer (@NathanielH98)
One year ago today, Charlie Kirk was murdered mid-thought. "Counting or not counting gang violence?" I was on paternity leave with my fourth child when the text came. Then I watched the left celebrate his death, mock his widow, and shrug at two children growing up without a father. That's when it hit me: if they would rejoice over Charlie's murder, they would rejoice over mine. So I stopped asking, "Am I allowed to say this?" and started asking only, "Is this true?" It cost me. I was asked to resign as a Bible teacher at a Christian school. I was barred from membership at a Southern Baptist church. The preferred posture was silence. I'm done with silence. Charlie wanted to be remembered for courage for his faith. He was killed exercising it. Christ still reigns, and He has called us to be faithful — as Charlie was. By God's grace, we will Make America Christian Again. I wrote about the year since. Link below.
1
5
2
31
4,330
Nathaniel Hillmer retweeted
Replying to @TanneriteCortez
How could Todd not understand that laws legislate morality? This is simple stuff.
1
1
15
141
Nathaniel Hillmer retweeted
It’s not racist to want to go to Costco and hear only English.
5,235
2,912
1,227
60,152
5,439,487
Nathaniel Hillmer retweeted
Swearing on a book that commands him to lie to non-Muslims and kill infidels What are we doing here
Abdul El-Sayed will become the first U.S. senator in history to take the oath of office using the Qur’an.
192
1,091
29
9,847
67,918
The only (ONLY) reason for laws is to enforce morality. These people have the political views of a 14 year old twilight fan.
It is easy to be frustrated by moral decay, but forcing unregenerate people to behave more morally is a solution God never gave us.
6
17
333
2,575
Nathaniel Hillmer retweeted
A LOT of people owe Stephen Wolfe an apology.
Republicans lost ground with every group Trump won in 2024, except white evangelicals.
12
43
2
823
8,598
Christ-less conservatism will never bring righteousness to our country. America First, Christ over all.
11
Thank you for the reminder, @NWBingham
1
22
Nathaniel Hillmer retweeted
Replying to @EqualityCaucus
"They glory in their shame." –– Philippians 3:19
29
225
3
3,936
30,443
Black pilling is off-limits in the Christian faith. I’m not always what people call a “plan truster“, but it’s not an option to black pill. My eschatology is optimistic, but my perspective on the eventual outcome of America is not required to be. Consider what might be the worst possible scenario: Abdul El-Sayed becomes massively popular and runs for president. Born in Michigan, he is an eligible candidate. He wins, installs a totally Muslim cabinet, and works tirelessly to implementary sharia law in our society. He allows the importation of millions of Muslim migrants into America. This would be evil, and I would fight with all available time and energy against these things. This land is for me, and for my posterity, and I will do what I can to uphold that. The America we know and love would fall. Even so, the Lord installs rulers over us. He is sovereign over all. There is nothing that occurs without his permission. We pray, we work, and we see what fruit He allows. The black-pillers forget (or do not know) that Jesus is on the throne. Jesus is still king regardless of your local or state official. We can’t forget that. Keep working. Keep praying. Don’t be discouraged. The next race is coming.
1
1
38
I’m still processing the midterm results and thinking through what led to such a significant blue wave (more on that soon). Seats turning over is common in the midterms, and especially so if one party has unified government, but this seems significant. I have friends and acquaintances who lost the races, so it’s a bit more personal for me than the average American. I knocked on doors for people, had coffee with candidates, and prayed over their campaigns. In the midst of all that, I would be remiss if I didn’t acknowledge that Jesus is still on his throne. Whether or not your state representative, state senator, US senator, or governor is red or blue, Jesus is still on the throne. That would’ve been true, whether we won or lost. This race is over and the eternal one is as well. We don’t need to worry about whether donkeys or elephants will rule heaven because the lamb has already conquered Even so, the next race will be here before you know it. I already have plans to help in city council races next year and support a state representative race in 2028. There will be more races and they all matter, but not eternally. Rest easy, knowing that the final battle has already been won.
20
Dig in. Build up. Keep going.
Well, it’s the morning after. And if you’re someone who understands progressivism to be the cancer that it is, your head is pounding. Both chambers were flipped. That’s extremely rare. And while we’ve seen losses like this in the House before, the losses in the Senate are truly historic. This is arguably one of the worst midterms ever. It’s certainly the worst in the last 20 years. It’s terrible. But I’m not dooming. Instead, I’m going to keep working on what I’ve been working on for the last seven years and prepare the best I can for whatever’s coming, which might rightly be called preparing for the worst. So what have I been working on? The philosophy behind it I simply call biblical localism, by which I mean giving priority to the people and place God has put right in front of you. I have a sort of 80-20 rule. I try to put 80% of my time, money, effort, and thought into my locality. For me, that means I’m most interested, after my own household, in Batavia Township, Clermont County, and the immediate region around it. As you grow in influence and power, your reach will sometimes extend far beyond that. But for most of us, it rarely goes beyond our county. That’s the place that touches our lives most and where our actions can have the greatest consequences. Hence, that’s why you give it the most attention. I want to add that this doesn’t mean you don’t care about what’s going on elsewhere. You can care. You can be aware. To some degree, you should, simply because communities are connected to other communities, counties to states, and states to other states. But you want to avoid falling into the trap of spending all your time talking about what’s happening elsewhere while taking no action in the world right in front of you. That’s what I mean by biblical localism. And that’s how I organize my life. Even the 20% of my energy I spend elsewhere is usually directly tied to enriching my locality. Now, to the particulars of the project. When I was studying the early Reformation, the development of these city-states during a time of political and religious turmoil really stuck out to me. Places like Geneva and Strasbourg became refuges. I believed something like that would probably be needed again, given the failure of evangelicalism and the growing political instability in America. I originally had these thoughts before 2016. I started calling them sanctuary cities, in the sense that they provided sanctuary for people who were Protestants and looking for a place to build a life while things broke down. The problem is that the term “sanctuary city” is loaded with modern baggage. Sometimes I refer to them as fortress cities. I think they are that, and should be that. But that makes it more of a military idea than I was going for. I’ve heard some people recently refer to them as boroughs. It’s okay, but still odd. Whatever you want to call it, I wanted to find a place that already had some of these features and labor to make it into a sanctuary of sanity, a fortress of peace, a burrow of life. So I started looking for communities in the Ohio Valley that met certain criteria. One was being close to a major economy that could provide diversity in work and amenities that kept commerce possible and strong, things like an airport, major highways, etc. It was pretty simple to settle on Cincinnati because it’s where we’re from, and it met those basic requirements. But I didn’t want to be right in the thick of it. I wanted us to be able to have real influence within five years and growing influence afterward. Sometimes this is called finding a worthwhile, winnable hill. So I looked at all the counties surrounding Hamilton County, where Cincinnati is located. Clermont County stood out. One reason I was drawn there was its very small, undervalued county seat in the village of Batavia. Only about 3,000 people in a county of a quarter million. I noticed that property values were still quite affordable, and it was just an underutilized place. I thought we could come in and really make a difference. We had a plan, and we could stretch our dollar further here than in most places. My goal was to first plant a church, start businesses, and then support Christian education options. Once that was moving, I wanted to start some sort of regional church-planting network that would reproduce those efforts throughout the region. Then, as church communities, we could work together on various ecclesiastical projects, share resources, and hopefully, in time, see regional transformation. So that’s what I’ve been working on. We planted East River Church in 2020. We support the planting of two other churches: Silver City Church in Sterling, Kentucky, and Little Miami Fellowship in Xenia, Ohio. By God’s grace and providence, I was able to bring Maddox Transformer to the township. We opened a shop, bought three buildings on Main Street that we’re rehabbing for our new offices, and now have about 70 employees, with plans to hire more. My associate pastor, John Weis, started Clermont Christian School. While it had a slow start, things are really beginning to pick up. We’ve had members of our church get directly involved in local politics, and people like me who are indirectly involved, mostly through business. We’ve also had a lot of solid people move here from across the states, bringing their gifts to bless our county and seeing the county bless them in return. And I hope, in time, this place will grow into a Christian stronghold where everyone benefits from our salt and light. I said earlier that my work outside my locality is usually tied back to it. What a lot of people didn’t know was that all the travel you saw me doing a couple of years ago was me going to trade shows and applying myself as hard as I could to my work at Maddox. I wanted to see the company do well, but I also wanted to be able to persuade them to invest in Clermont County if the door ever opened. And when it did, by God’s grace and their favor, I was able to help make that happen. Even right now, I’m writing this as I walk the streets of Richmond, Virginia, because I’m here for an intensive at Grimké Seminary. The reason I said yes to this opportunity to serve as a professor here is, first, that I really respect what they’re accomplishing. I think it’s awesome. But I’m also part of the lecturing coming through the Carey Center, which focuses on church planting. And it’s my hope that some of these men will adopt my way of thinking and approach. Perhaps some of them will even want to come to the Ohio Valley and join in what we’re doing. So that’s what I’ve been up to. I’m putting the place in front of me first and trying to build something that will help us weather the storms that appear to be in our future. Will it allow us to weather all storms? Of course not. But it will allow us to weather many, and maybe build something that really turns the tide for Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana. Don’t lose heart. Don’t blackpill. Dig in. Build up. Keep going.
2
54
Nathaniel Hillmer retweeted
Charlie Kirk > Nick Fuentes
Get out and vote Democrat today 🌊🗳️
60
187
6
3,168
46,838
Nathaniel Hillmer retweeted
Congratulations, Democrats, take your victory lap. But don’t take this an affirmation of your worldview. This election was a ticked off Republican base punishing its feckless & weak leadership. It’s like a wife sleeping with the milkman to get revenge on her cheating husband.
16
11
4
180
4,495
Nathaniel Hillmer retweeted
Whoa, look at the shift from 18-29 year olds
The swings tonight among groups that swung right in 2024.
150
145
21
4,700
836,210
Nathaniel Hillmer retweeted
America does not belong to those who hate it. America belongs to those who love it.
8,412
19,982
1,543
114,400
2,105,972
Nathaniel Hillmer retweeted
It is the wrong time for American Protestants to be sectarian.
21
32
4
602
11,099
Have you voted? 🗳️
11
Nick is not a serious person.
Get out and vote Democrat today 🌊🗳️
19
The ballot box is not a mailbox for you to send a message. Nobody is reading that mail. 
13
Don’t hand the country over to crazy people just because you disagree with the administration on a policy issue here or there. Largely, we’re voting on State and local officials today that have little to do with what the administration is doing. Today is not the time to send a message to the administration. No one’s getting that mail. Don’t forget what the country was like under Joe Biden. The Democratic Party shares the same outrageous views about the family, marriage, and transgenderism. Christian, you have significant say in the supposed blue wave that’s coming. Get out to the polls and do something about it.
32