For full content of the sarcastic interview @mehdirhasan @reda_getachew @AJEnglish @hawelti #Eritrea #Ethiopia
facebook.com/share/p/1FFYXVm…
221
Talking to the Tenant, Not the Landlord
In his recent speech to Parliament, Ethiopia’s Prime Minister Dr Abby Ahmed, once again raised the issue of Red Sea. He claimed that the demand for Assab is not new, that since 2018, when he embraced Eritrea’s President Isaias Afwerki under his Medemer philosophy, he has been talking about it “from day one.” He even boasted that he and Isaias discussed sharing Assab, that he shared his book Medemer with many Eritrean officials, and that road-building toward Assab had already begun with the help of a “sisterly” third country.
But Abiy’s speech, and the claim that institutions were never involved in Eritrea’s independence, is more revealing than he intended. In trying to question the legitimacy of Eritrea’s exit, he stumbles into questioning the very foundations of the Ethiopian state he governs.
93 vs 39: The Mirror of Liberation
Eritrea’s independence was decided in 1993 through a United Nations supervised referendum, endorsed by Ethiopia and accepted by the world. That year, 1993, sealed the sovereignty of Eritrea through the will of its people.
Ethiopia’s federal system, meanwhile, was sealed just two years later with Article 39 of its new constitution, which granted nation-nationalities the right to secession. That provision was not a gift; it was the product of the same liberation war that gave Eritrea its freedom.
It was not by accident that these two milestones (93 and 39) are the mirrors of one another. 93 was Eritrea’s number, the year of its referendum and rightful exit. The number 39 was Ethiopia’s reflection, a constitutional promise to its so-called “peripheral” peoples that they too could step out from the shadow of empire if it tries to go back to its old habits.
It was a win-win moment in history: Eritrea secured sovereignty, and Ethiopia’s marginalized nation and nationalities secured at least the principle of equality and self-determination. So to now delegitimize 1993 is to delegitimize the Ethiopian constitution.
Dealing with the Tenant for Assab
Abiy insists that Assab was discussed and even agreed upon with Eritrea’s president Isayas Afeworki. If true, that is even more alarming. Because Isaias Afwerki is not the landlord of Eritrea. He is a tenant, a squatter in a house owned by the Eritrean people. He governs without constitution, without election, without mandate. He is a graduate of the very empire that treated nation nationalities of Ethiopia as second class citizens. To negotiate Eritrea’s coast with Isaias is to sign a contract with a tenant while ignoring the family that holds the deed.
Eritrea is not for lease. It is not a bargaining chip between two rulers. It belongs to the people who fought, bled, and voted for it. Until Eritreans themselves govern through institutions, no deal made with a tenant will stand.
The Constitutional Boomerang
And here lies Abiy’s greatest contradiction. If he delegitimizes the referendum of 1993, he also delegitimizes the Ethiopian constitution. But it was precisely that constitution and the federal order born from it that allowed Abiy, an Oromo from what the old empire treated as the periphery, to rise to the premiership.
To erase 1993 is to erase the constitution. And to erase the constitution is to erase the very foundation of Abiy’s government. It would mean that his own power, his own state order, and everything he is doing are equally illegitimate.
Finally,
Abiy’s language of “shared prosperity” and “mutual progress” sounds calm and thoughtful. But beneath it lies an attempt to reopen a settled question by dealing with a dictator who does not own the keys to the house he occupies. Eritrea’s independence is not a bargaining chip. And if Abiy insists on questioning the foundations of Eritrean sovereignty, he will find that he is also questioning the very constitutional ground beneath his own feet.
#Ethiopia #Eritrea #Oromo #Tigray #Afar #Somalia #Djibouti
234
Eritrea’s Red Sea Diplomacy: Silence Abroad, irredentist ximdo (ጽምዶ) Campaign at Home!
In #Eritrea, the government drums up ximdo campaign as if the future of Eritrea depends on #Tigray and #Amhara forces joining Eritrean armed forces. Campaign after campaign pour into the domestic space, urging Eritreans to embrace the myth. But when the world gathers in New York, at the United Nations General Assembly, Eritrea’s leaders lower their voices.
Compare the two governments’ speeches at the #UNGA . Ethiopia’s president stood before the UNGA and, with polished confidence, declared the #RedSea a matter of international law and Ethiopia’s “legitimate policy objective.” It was framed in the language of cooperation, diplomacy, and “the common heritage of mankind.” Behind those words, #Ethiopia was making its claim plain: Addis Ababa will not be locked out of the Red Sea, and it will pursue access in the open corridors of international diplomacy.
Eritrea, by contrast, chose a different script. Its foreign minister went on the offensive, not about the Red Sea, but about global injustice, domination, and plunder. He spoke as if the Red Sea ximdo campaign was a side issue, not the central existential matter the government has made it at home. To the international ears at the UNGA, the absence of any substantive counter to Ethiopia’s maritime claim was deafening.
This is not new. During the 1998–2000 border war, one independent newsletter in Asmara captured the government’s contradictions with a cutting headline: “Either be the mountain to depend on, or be with the mountains that can shield you (ወይ ጎቦ ኹን ወይ ኣብ ጎቦ ተጸጋዕ).” Then, as now, Eritrea’s foreign policy oscillated between grand declarations of self-reliance, workd hagemony and quiet searches for cover in other people’s shade.
President Isaias Afeworki, in his latest domestic interview, underlined that the Red Sea is not just an Eritrean issue but one that concerns the entire Horn of Africa, the Nile Basin, those bordering Redsea and the Gulf States. If so, why is the regime not seeking regional coalition, diplomatic offensive, or international narrative that matches the noise of ximdo campaign at home? Why is the government’s loudest message delivered to the Eritrean highlanders, Tigryan and Amhara audiences only, while the halls of international diplomacy hear only vague sermons on global injustices?
The truth is simple: the Eritrean government is playing defense with rhetoric, not offense with strategy. Ethiopia frames its Red Sea demand in cooperative language, placing its claim within international law. The Eritrean government hides its anxieties behind moralistic condemnations of global powers, without naming or challenging its immediate neighbor.
And beneath all this lies the most troubling reality: ximdo is not really about Eritrean sovereignty for the Eritrean people at all. It is another level of identity politics, an attempt to forge a Semitic bloc of Amhara, Tigray, and Eritrean Tigrinya, with Eritrea as their hub. Ethiopia’s claim to the Red Sea becomes the excuse, while the real project is to recast Eritrea’s sovereign state into the capital of an ethnic-religious alliance.
This is the gap between ximdo the irredentist mobilization and Eritrea’s silence abroad. In the end, it’s the Eritrean people who paid their blood that risk being neither the mountain others can depend on, nor sheltered by mountains it can lean against. Eritrea risks becoming the lonely plateau, loud at home, muted abroad, and exposed in between.
1
348
The Wisdom of an Ethiopian Civic Citizen in Times of Animosity!
In our region, where governments thrive on propaganda and war drums, truth often comes not from leaders or generals but from civic citizens who dare to speak with clarity.
Recently, an Ethiopian woman delivered a message that deserves to echo from Addis to Asmara. Her words cut through decades of accusations, ethnic mantras, and historical revisionism, offering a civic compass for both Ethiopians and Eritreans.
Her first wisdom is simple and direct. Bygone is bygone. Please do not live in the past. For generations, Ethiopians have blamed their miseries on yesterday’s rulers. Menelik is accused of selling land. Meles Zenawi is accused of helping Eritreans separate from Ethiopia.
These accusations have become recycled weapons in today’s political battles. But no amount of pointing fingers at the dead will feed the living. Civic citizens must refuse to be chained to the past. Their loyalty must be to solving present injustices and securing tomorrow’s opportunities.
She also reminded her listeners of a principle that governments love to twist. Djibouti is for the Djiboutian people. Eritrea is for the Eritrean people. Sovereignty is not a bargaining chip for elites seeking ports or resources. It belongs to people, to their dignity, their self determination, and their right to build and protect their future.
Here she exposed the folly of Ethiopia’s current prime minister, whom she called infantile. Instead of creating jobs, schools, or industries, he dreams aloud about Eritrean seas and Djiboutian ports. Such posturing is not strategy. It is a dangerous diversion that sacrifices youth not for opportunity but for death.
Her words carry equal weight for Eritreans. Today the regime in Asmara pushes the ximdo (ጽምዶ) mantra that a Semitic bloc of Amhara and Tigrinya speakers must confront an Oromo led Cushitic bloc. This is a fantasy created by warmongers. It is an ethnic costume stitched to disguise the failure of governance. It is designed to trick people into believing that destiny demands war. But sovereignty is about people, not ethnic blocs. Eritreans should not be seduced into thinking that their future lies in choosing sides between Semitic and Cushitic. That road leads only to more graves, not to justice or prosperity.
And let us be clear, if Awel Seid or others try to wave this woman’s message as a weapon against Abiy Ahmed, Eritreans should not be swayed. Her wisdom is not partisan ammunition. It is civic truth. The warning applies just as much to Awel’s own boss in Asmara, who thrives on the same divisive myths and sends youth to die in wars that solve nothing.
Her warning is a shared one. Do not let leaders use you as cannon fodder. Do not fall into the trap of fighting invented enemies while your real problems, poverty, repression, and exile, remain unsolved. Civic maturity means rejecting ethnic fantasies and external scapegoats. It means asking the harder question of why our young people are leaving us. Neither Ethiopia nor Eritrea can build a future by resurrecting ghosts of past rulers or weaving myths of ethnic destiny. They can only build by raising civic citizens loyal not to propaganda but to truth, not to blocs but to people, not to yesterday’s quarrels but to tomorrow’s dignity.
Please do not waste your time, she said. Do not get yourself into unnecessary confrontation. It is impossible. In these words lies the distilled wisdom of a mother and a civic citizen. If Ethiopians and Eritreans listen, really listen, they may find the courage to silence the drums of war and instead raise a generation of civic citizens. That is the wisdom of the woman I chose to highlight today. That is the message both governments fear most, but our people need most. #Ethiopia #Eritrea @PMEthiopia @EritreanPress
GERD: Achievement to Celebrate & a Reminder of Contradictions!
The day has finally arrived. #Ethiopia has inaugurated the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam, a project so massive that it can light up towns that never knew electricity, irrigate fields that once relied only on seasonal rains, and feed millions who lived under the shadow of hunger. Built with local resources and determination, it is a historic achievement and a genuine symbol of progress.
Electricity will now reach areas long kept in darkness. Farmers who once harvested only once a year can irrigate their land, increase production, and aspire to food self sufficiency. For ordinary Ethiopians, this is a monumental step forward.
But with this progress comes contradiction. Ethiopia insists on its sovereign right to development. That principle is legitimate. Yet the same Ethiopia has refused to respect the sovereignty of its neighbors. It has demanded ownership rights to Eritrea’s Assab port and to the Red Sea itself after deliberately refusing for decades to use that same port. This contradiction raises serious questions about Ethiopia’s understanding of sovereignty and prosperity.
Somali President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud summarized the regional dilemma with clarity: “Water resources are managed differently in each country. For some, it is a matter of survival and security; for others, it is about energy and growth. Our challenge is to balance these needs with fairness and respect. Ethiopia has the right to pursue prosperity.” The essential part of this message is balance, fairness, and respect, not prosperity alone.
#Sudan and #Egypt offer another example. Both countries are directly affected by the GERD and have serious concerns about their level of access to the Nile. Yet they did not resort to territorial claims or irredentist agendas. Instead, they raised their concerns at the United Nations Security Council and emphasized their determination to protect their interests, including Egypt’s strong deterrence capability. This shows a path of diplomacy backed by clear national resolve.
#Djibouti, #Somalia and other countries of the region also chose diplomacy. They attended the inauguration and offered constructive views on how GERD could serve as a source of cooperation and improved regional relations. Eritrea, by contrast, stood aside. Instead of engaging with governments through professional channels, it focused on the so called ximdo (ጽምዶ) campaign, working not with states but with regional activists and factions whose history includes conspiring against Eritrea’s very nationhood.
This is Eritrea’s contradiction. The government has demonized the #GERD while presenting its own small reservoirs (ዲጋታት) as symbols of genius. Ethiopia, for all its faults, mobilized its people and completed a mega project. Eritrea, with the unmatched strategic gift of the Red Sea, has failed to use it as an engine of prosperity. The Red Sea should work for Eritrea and, through #Eritrea, for all who seek access. That does not mean surrendering sovereignty. It means applying vision and strategy to turn geography into opportunity.
The lesson is clear. Ethiopia must learn to treat the Nile as a shared river rather than a private source. Eritrea must learn to make the Red Sea work for the betterment of its people and potential customers rather than leaving it hostage to political grudges. Both governments need to transform natural blessings into sources of growth, not weapons of politics.
Yes GERD is Ethiopia’s huge achievement to celebrate. But it is also a reminder of the nation’s own contradictions and the urgent need for fairness, cooperation, and genuine diplomacy.
1
1
221
When Two Elephants Fight, the Grass Suffers (ሓራምዝ እንክብኣሱ: ዝጉዳእ እቲ ሳዕሪ ኢዩ - عندما يتصارع فيلان، العشب هو الضحية)!
There is a saying: when two elephants fight, the victim is the grass beneath their feet.
Thirty five years after Eritrea’s independence, the fight between #Eritrea and #Ethiopia still rages on in different forms and as always the innocent people are the grass.
In medicine there is a condition called the phantom limb (الطرف الوهمي). A person who loses a hand or leg may still feel it, and may still try to move it as if it were never gone.
Ethiopia lost Eritrea decades ago but the reflex remains. Its political body keeps reaching for a missing hand, pretending it can still command what it lost. The rhetoric the constitutional ambiguities, the yearning for #RedSea .. etc all of it is a phantom movement of an amputated limb. Ethiopia has not accepted the amputation. It keeps stretching for something no longer attached and in doing so it prolongs the pain for both itself and its neighbor.
But Eritrea too lives with a phantom limb. To be a Unionist in Eritrea never meant loving Ethiopia or desiring unity for its own sake. It meant guaranteeing dominance over Eritrea. When dominance required Ethiopia’s help the Unionist reached for it, even when it meant colonization. When dominance could be achieved alone, Ethiopia was discarded. Today Eritrea’s rulers who were raised in Unionist households already hold supreme power inside Eritrea. They do not need Ethiopia unless it is to extend their reach into ruling bigger Eritrea. But phantom limb remains the reflex, that domination is the only way to govern. Independence could have freed Eritrea to imagine democracy, pluralism and coexistence. Instead it merely transferred Unionist dominance from Addis Ababa to Asmara.
Ethiopia cannot stop moving its missing hand. Eritrean unionists cannot stop flexing their hand of domination that they don’t not need anymore. Both are trapped in phantom limbs and both crush the ordinary citizen in their struggle.
But the people of Eritrea and Ethiopia are not asking for phantom limbs. They are asking for real lives, for coexistence for sovereign nations living side by side for governments that rule with justice instead of obsession.
For three and a half decades the people have been trampled while leaders chase their phantom hands that will never return. Unless both nations amputate the ghosts, Ethiopia by accepting Eritrea’s independence as final and Eritrea by abandoning the Unionist reflex of domination, the grass will never grow in peace.
1
1
208
August 27th, August 28th & September 1st: Triad of Divergent Memories, One Lesson
Three dates, three memories, one lesson for #Eritrea|’s future:
■ Aug 27, 1975: King Haile Selassie of #Ethiopia dies, the ruler who strangled Eritrea’s federation and erased its flag. Yet revisionists still glorify him while belittling our struggle.
■ Aug 28, 1980: #EPLF & #TPLF assault #ELF. Eritrea’s first front exiled. Division and fratricide normalized.
■ Sep 1, 1961: Hamid Idris Awate fires the first shots of the armed struggle. Birth of modern sovereignty, without which there’d be no Independence Day or Martyrs Day.
These memories converge in one truth: #Eritrea must raise revivalists who can defend its nationhood, sovereignty, and justice. It cannot survive by tolerating revisionists who erase history or irredentists who dissolve sovereignty into someone else’s project.
Petros Solomon once warned of #PFDJ’s rigidity. A decade later, Wedi Ali demanded prisoners freed, constitution implemented, and rule of law restored. Both were silenced. Their vision lives on.
Ximdo (ጽምዶ) today repeats old betrayals by irredentists, dressed as reconciliation but echoing betrayal. It is irredentism, not revivalism. Some of the opposition’s mask has slipped too: they have switched camps, others signed a quiet ceasefire.
Eritrea’s choice is clear: stand with revivalists or lose the very sovereignty it fought for.
Long Live September 1, 1961.
4
1
572
Eritrea and Ethiopia’s Dangerous Turn Toward Irredentism!
There is a local proverb that says, “A cow scratches with its foot when its hands are closer than the legs (ላም ብኢዳ ዝቀርባ: ብእግራ ትሓክኽ).” A cow has no hands to start with. To scratch itself, it awkwardly reaches with its back legs, because using its front legs would throw it off balance. Our elders use this only as a warning: when you have the right tools but insist on using the dangerous ones, you risk harming yourself.
Nothing illustrates this better than the ongoing campaigns in Eritrea and Ethiopia. Rather than reaching for the tools of sovereign states such as diplomacy, mediation, regional and international organizations intervention, both governments are resorting to the blunt weapon of irredentism.
Irredentism seeks to unite peoples of sovereign states through claims of shared ethnicity, language, religion, culture, or history.
President Isayas Afwerki, who once denounced TPLF expansionism, is now engaged in crafting his own version of it in the name of people-to-people diplomacy. By turning Eritrean nationalism away from civic unity and toward ethnic, religious or linguistic bonds, he is cultivating irredentist identities among Eritreans, Tigryans, Amharas and even the Afars.
• He is encouraging Eritreans to look across the borders for kinship-based alliances rather than focusing on fixing their broken state.
• He appears to be preparing to replace his old guard proxy, Demhit, with a new, more obedient bigger and better organised faction of the TPLF under Debretsion’s leadership.
• This is not about sovereignty or security; it is about turning Eritrean nationalism into a tool of regional identity politics.
In the process, Eritreans are being primed to see their destiny not in their own nation, but in a shared ethnic or historical project across borders.
On the Ethiopian side, Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed has turned the language of demographics into a weapon. He presents Ethiopia’s “population explosion” as a reason to demand expansion outward, a modern echo of Asfaha Welde Michael’s old irredentist fantasies that Eritrea was Ethiopia’s.
• Instead of governance reforms that match the needs of his young population, Abiy offers imperial nostalgia.
• Instead of solving Ethiopia’s internal crises, he offers the mirage of expansion.
• His government has allowed irredentist claims to become mainstream media talking points, normalizing what was once the rhetoric of fringe zealots.
This is not leadership, it is escapism at the expense of peace.
What is alarming is not just that these ideas exist. They always have, but that they are now officially state-sponsored narratives.
• In Eritrea, irredentist discourse is smuggled into “people-to-people” campaigns, dressing ethnic alliances as diplomacy.
• In Ethiopia, it is broadcast from the prime minister’s own podium, where population numbers are treated as a license for territorial ambition.
People-to-people engagement is good only as a complementary tool to diplomacy, particularly for confidence-building and exploring innovative ideas, but it cannot replace the formal, state-led processes necessary for the authoritative resolution and implementation of agreements. Resolving disputes requires the full weight of state authority and commitment, and the enforceability of international law and agreements achieved through official channels.
By indulging in this rhetoric, both governments are pushing their peoples toward another conflict because the leaders find it easier to gamble with than to govern responsibly.
Irredentism is not strategy. It is a confession of failure. A failure to build nations on justice, equality, and law. If they continue down this path, they will once again drag millions into a war by trying to scratch with the wrong legs.
#Eritrea #Ethiopia #Afar #Tigray #Amhara
From Agazian to Ximdo: Eritrea’s Slide into Identity Bloc Politics
Over the past decade, four currents: Agazian, Brigade Nhâmêdu, Moa Tewahedo, and now Ximdo (ጽምዶ) have pulled Eritrea away from civic nationalism toward cross-border ethnic bloc politics.
■ Agazian began in the diaspora, claiming Nhnan Elamanan (ንሕናን ዕላማናን) as its main manifesto and using the Eritrean embassy in UK as an organizing hub. Its first recruits were YPFDJ youth, pulled into a narrower frame of Tigryna Orthodox supremacy, with Eritrean Muslims cast as enemies.
■ Brigade Nhâmêdu (ብርጌድ ንሓመዱ) emerged after the Tigray War as a TPLF-aligned mobilization seeking revenge against both the Eritrean and Ethiopian armed forces, as well as their diaspora supporters, for the war they waged on Tigray. Though its allegiance differed from that of Agazian or Moa Tewahedo’s camp, it too relied on Tigryna identity politics, framing its struggle in ethnic and cultural terms. Today, the group is split: one faction is quietly waiting for HGDEF to carry out the “dirty work” it once envisioned, while the other has aligned itself with Abiy Ahmed.
■ Moa Tewahedo (ሞኣ ተዋህዶ), the ideological brain behind the Amhara nationalist militia movement often referred to as Fano (ፋኖ) pushed a supremacist vision rooted in Amhara Orthodox identity, amplified through social media and armed mobilization. Their message framed the struggle as identity politics, making it a natural kin-force for the Eritrean government elites who shared the same view about Ethiopia.
■ Now ximdo makes identity logic into a geopolitical doctrine, a Semitic–Orthodox bloc linking Eritrea, Tigray, and Amhara to counter Oromo-led Cushitic-bloc.
Once kinship replaces strategic interest as the compass, sovereignty is the first casualty. Eritrea’s liberation promised civic nationalism free from sectarian order. Ximdo risks binding us to that order permanently.
#Eritrea #Ethiopia #Tigray #Fano
Parade of the Past: Gerontocracy Hardened into a One-Man State
Eritrea Festival 2025 opened in Asmara with a familiar scene: President Isaias Afwerki leading a small entourage of ageing loyalists, flanked by senior PFDJ officials and long-time ministers.
The image, meant to project confidence and unity, instead reveals a deeper truth. Eritrea’s political life is trapped in a gerontocracy that has calcified into a one-man state.
In a country where half the population was born after independence, the absence of visible young leaders was striking.
The festival’s theme was progress, but the leadership on display was a living archive of the past.
The message was unmistakable: power remains in the hands of the liberation-era generation, and the stage is closed to those who will one day inherit the nation.
History shows that when generational change is delayed by a gerontocracy hardened into a one-man state, it rarely comes peacefully, it comes all at once.
Eritreans are running out of time to demand the former before it’s too late.
#ኤንብኤ #Eritrea For #Eritreans By #Eritreans










