Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney) header
Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney) profile picture

Demystifying the economics of the music industry Former music @ Verizon + commerce @ Rocnation & Co-Founder @ Superphone Subscribe to The Bag

NYC
Joined May 2012
Photo by Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney)Photo by Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney)Photo by Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney)Photo by Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney)Photo by Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney)Photo by Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney)Photo by Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney)Photo by Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney)Photo by Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney)Photo by Nathan McCartney (@NEMcCartney)
In 2001 Virgin gave Mariah Carey $80 million and her own label. EMI had bought Virgin for $1 billion in 1992 and still couldn't crack America, so it outbid everyone. Glitter came out on September 11, 2001. By January, EMI had paid her $28 million to leave. Arista passed on her too. L.A. Reid wanted to sign her there, and his boss said her price was too high for a career that was over. Reid landed at Island Def Jam, signed her, and brought in Jermaine Dupri. In late 2004 they cut "We Belong Together" in Atlanta. On January 24, 2005, Virgin hired Dupri as president of its new urban music division. Seven weeks later, the song he co-wrote and produced came out on Island. It spent 14 weeks at No. 1, and Billboard later named it the song of the decade. When the biggest song of the 2000s hit, the man who made it was running urban music at Virgin, the EMI label that had paid her to leave.
Mariah Carey signed the biggest record deal in history in 2001: $80 million for four albums. Ten months later the label paid her $28 million to leave. In the video below, 17 years later, she talks about the album that ended it. "…having to feel like, oh, I can't do stuff from Glitter because nobody knows it." Virgin, part of EMI, signed her in April 2001 with a $21 million advance. That July she was hospitalized after what her rep called an emotional and physical breakdown. The Glitter soundtrack came out on September 11, 2001. It sold about 500,000 copies in the US. The movie made about $5 million. In January 2002 EMI paid her $28 million to end the contract. She kept the $21 million. $49 million for one album. Months later she signed with Island Def Jam for a reported $20 million. In 2005 she released The Emancipation of Mimi. Billboard named "We Belong Together" the song of the decade. The case for EMI: one flop, a breakdown, and three more albums to pay for. Cutting the loss was the business call. The case for Mariah: they paid $49 million to walk away from the voice behind the biggest song of the 2000s. Did EMI make the smart call, or the most expensive mistake in music history?
1
113
Data from Luminate does not align with this statement at all. According to Luminate: Drake’s If You’re Reading This Its Too Late has 5.5M Album Equivalents in the U.S. and 7.2B streams worldwide. Kendrick Lamar’s To Pimp A Butterfly has 4.3M Album Equivalents in the U.S. and 5.7B streams worldwide.
Kendrick Lamar's To Pimp A Butterfly has now sold the equivalent of 8M units, including streams. It's the first 2015 hip-hop album to reach this milestone, leading Drake's If You're Reading This It's Too Late.
2
106
MTV did not treat it like a world premiere. On Sunday night, September 29, 1991, “Smells Like Teen Spirit” went out on 120 Minutes, the late-night alternative show. Dave Kendall hosted. Hair metal, pop, and rap owned the daytime. This slot was where the channel parked guitar bands it did not expect to move units. The single had gone to radio on August 27 and to stores on September 10. Nevermind landed September 24. DGC shipped about 46,000 copies in the U.S. and set an internal target around 250,000 for the year, using Sonic Youth’s Goo as the model. “Teen Spirit” was supposed to hold the college and modern-rock base. “Come as You Are” was the planned crossover. Samuel Bayer shot the video on August 17 at GMT Studios in Culver City on a $30,000 to $50,000 budget. Cobain picked Bayer because his reel looked like the worst one in the pile. The extras came from flyers handed out at a Roxy show. The last thirty seconds are the kids wrecking the set after a long day. The clip jumped from 120 Minutes into daytime rotation, then into MTV’s Buzz Bin in October. Nevermind had entered the Billboard 200 at No. 144. By January 11, 1992 it was No. 1 and knocked Michael Jackson’s Dangerous off the top. That week it sold about 374,000 copies. The album is 13-times platinum in the U.S. and past 30 million worldwide. Amy Finnerty, who was in MTV programming then, said the video gave the channel a new generation to sell to. The September 29 airing is the date that started.
On this day 35 years ago, in 1991, MTV aired the music video for Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit" for the first time. The rest is history.
127
The Spirit Tunnel started as a hallway cheer for Jennifer Hudson. Season 1 the staff lined up and sang her onto the set. She told them to put a camera on it and do the same walk for guests. In January 2024, producer Angie Green, associate producer Alexis Powell, and talent booker Paige Matthews started writing a new song the day a booking lands. Their group chat is called Tunnel Vision. Singers get a rewritten record. Everybody else gets the one line people already shout. Aaron Pierre voiced Mufasa in Disney’s Lion King prequel, so his tunnel was “Aaron Pierre, that’s Mufasa.” That clip took six million likes on TikTok. Tom Cruise got Bob Seger’s “Old Time Rock and Roll.” That is the living-room dance from Risky Business. The tunnels have passed six billion views. The show is the No. 1 daytime talk show on TikTok. Last season followers went to 17.5 million and impressions hit 7.5 billion. Fox renewed it for a fifth season on the back of that.
Tom Cruise doing the Spirit Tunnel at The Jennifer Hudson Show.
1
4
448
Warner Bros. had Training Day dated for September 21, 2001. After the attacks, the studio pushed it two weeks to October 5. October 5 had belonged to Collateral Damage. Arnold Schwarzenegger plays a Los Angeles firefighter whose family is killed in a bombing, then goes after the men who did it. The movie cost $85 million. The trailer showed an attack inside the United States. Warner pulled the trailer, the posters, and the date. Studio president Alan Horn said they did not want a fictional terrorist attack in theaters that month. Collateral Damage sat until February 8, 2002, opened at number one with $15.2 million, and finished at $40 million domestic and $78.4 million worldwide. Training Day took that open weekend and did $22.6 million, the biggest opening of Denzel Washington’s career at the time. The film cost $45 million and finished at $76.6 million domestic and $104.9 million worldwide. Washington was paid a reported $12 million to play Alonzo Harris and won Best Actor. Antoine Fuqua directed it. This summer Fuqua’s Michael Jackson film Michael crossed $1 billion worldwide, the first Lionsgate title and the first biopic to get there. On October 14, Warner is putting the Fuqua and Washington movie back in theaters for its 25th anniversary.
Denzel Washington’s 'Training Day' is returning to theaters for the film’s 25th anniversary 🍿🔥 October 14th!
94
Billboard and Nielsen SoundScan started counting streams on the Billboard 200 with the chart dated December 13, 2014. At launch, 10 track sales or 1,500 on-demand streams from an album equaled one album unit. Billboard said the point was to make the chart reflect how people were actually listening, not just what they bought. The RIAA, which issues Gold and Platinum plaques, added streams to album certifications on February 1, 2016. Its rule was 1,500 on-demand streams from an album = one certification unit. That 1,500-to-one ratio is still the plaque math. The RIAA also counts 150 streams of a single track as one track sale. The weekly chart left the flat 1,500 number in 2018. Nielsen split it: 1,250 paid streams or 3,750 ad-supported streams equaled one album unit. On the charts dated January 17, 2026, Billboard and Luminate moved it again to 1,000 paid or 2,500 ad-supported. Eligible audio and video both count. A paid stream is now worth 25 percent more toward an album unit than it was last year. An ad-supported stream is worth 50 percent more. Same eligible listening produces a bigger album-equivalent total. Listening itself did not have to go up.
Whoever made up 1500 streams a sale is insane and whatever music artist or black person that was in the room when that decision was made help set the the music eco system back 10 years for the artist and consumer! How did that come about?
97
September 29, 1998 was a ridiculous Tuesday. Aquemini, Jay-Z’s Vol. 2, Tribe’s last album, Black Star, and Brand Nubian all came out that morning. Aquemini debuted at No. 2 with 227,000 copies and went platinum by November. “Rosa Parks” stalled at No. 55. Nothing off the album made the Top 40. Three years earlier they’d won at the Source Awards and the room booed them. André said the South got something to say. The Source gave this one five mics. Chonkyfire ends with the clip. They named the radio song after Rosa Parks. André later said they never meant it to be about her — “we comin’ back out, so all you other MCs move to the back of the bus.” Her name isn’t even in the lyrics. She sued in 1999. The labels settled in 2005.
28 years ago today, OutKast released their third studio album, ‘Aquemini’ ♒️♊️
1
56
LimeWire didn’t get sued for $72 trillion. The labels argued statutory damages should attach to every download, not every song. $150k times hundreds of millions of files produces a number larger than the world economy in 2011. Judge Kimba Wood called it absurd. She wrote that they were asking for more money than the recording industry had made since Edison invented the phonograph in 1877. She capped it at one award per work. Ceiling: $1.5B. They settled for $105M on May 12, 2011, while a jury was already sitting, in the middle of cross-examining Edgar Bronfman Jr. That is less than Kazaa paid five years earlier, even though LimeWire accounted for roughly 80% of illegal U.S. music downloads at its peak. Mark Gorton could write the check because LimeWire was a side project of a high-frequency trading firm. The labels alleged he moved assets into a family partnership after Grokster. They sued him personally anyway. The $72 trillion was never a bill. It was a statute written for vinyl bootlegs, pointed at a network with 50M monthly users, and the number stopped being money. The account posting “still not paying” bought the logo in 2022. BabyDoge took it over two weeks ago. The original company already paid. UMG filed against DistroKid on September 15 using the same $150k-per-work statute, this time on 1,000 recordings. Ceiling: $150M. The meme is the number. The business is that statutory damages were never designed to price a network, and the labels still open with the same number fifteen years later.
just a reminder the music industry tried to sue us for $72 trillion back in the day. like lol does that number even exist? still not paying
46
Mariah needed 7 Christmas seasons to accumulate 22 weeks at #1. Ella Langley reached 23 before “Choosin’ Texas” turned a year old. “All I Want for Christmas Is You” came out in 1994 and first reached No. 1 in 2019. Streaming gave all those repeat holiday listens a way to count toward the chart. Mariah kept adding weeks each Christmas. “Choosin’ Texas” arrived in October 2025 and first topped the Hot 100 in February. By its 21st week at No. 1, Billboard estimated it had generated $13.9 million in label and publishing revenue, including $10.5 million in the U.S. That covers streams, video, downloads and U.S. radio. Radio deserves a closer look. More than 977,000 spins accounted for an estimated $2.4 million. That airplay helped push the songwriting side to nearly $6 million, roughly 43% of the total. Langley shares writing credit with Miranda Lambert, Luke Dick and Joybeth Taylor. For a singer who also helped write the song, staying on the radio changes how much of a hit’s money she can participate in.
Ella Langley surpasses Mariah Carey for the longest-running #1 single in Billboard Hot 100 history: #1. Choosin' Texas - 23 weeks #2. All I Want For Christmas Is You - 22 weeks
1
92
The Firm’s original 4 members never released a group album together. Nas, AZ, Foxy Brown and Cormega introduced the group on “Affirmative Action” in 1996. The album it appeared on, It Was Written, sold 270,000 copies its first week and spent four weeks at #1. There was already an audience before The Firm had an album. Then came their deal. Cormega says Steve Stoute wanted $50,000 to executive-produce his solo album, with beats charged separately. His Def Jam deal was $250,000. That fee alone would take 20% before paying for a single beat. Cormega says refusing the production deal cost him his spot. Stoute disputed his account and pointed to friction within the group. Nature replaced him and says he came in on a 10-day contract. The Firm album arrived in October 1997 through Aftermath/Interscope, with Dre and Trackmasters producing. It debuted at #1 with 147,000 copies, about 46% below the opening week of Nas’s album. The group people met on “Affirmative Action” had already changed by the time there was a Firm album to buy.
Nas, AZ, Cormega & Foxy Brown performing “Affirmative Action” live, 30 years ago today 🔥 (1996)
108
Bad Bunny’s 36 billion-stream songs have generated more than 57 billion Spotify streams between them. Six have passed 2 billion. LA CANCIÓN leads at 2.72 billion, followed by DÁKITI at 2.57 billion. Across all platforms, Luminate puts his total at ~198 billion streams. The depth within individual albums is even more striking. Un Verano Sin Ti has eight billion-stream songs. Debí Tirar Más Fotos already has six, including DtMF at 2.16 billion and BAILE INoLVIDABLE at 1.76 billion. Two albums account for nearly 40% of his billion-stream songs. His 36 puts him ahead of The Weeknd’s 31 and Drake’s 30. And two more are approaching: A Tu Merced at roughly 996 million and CÓMO SE SIENTE – Remix at 995 million. A billion streams is becoming a recurring outcome across his tracklists.
Bad Bunny (@sanbenito) extends his record as the artist with the most songs with 1 billion streams in Spotify history (36).
69
Taylor Swift’s record-breaking 31st VMA comes from an award MTV announced six days before the show. The new Artist Director Honors moves her ahead of Beyoncé’s 30 wins. That tie already needed an explanation: Beyoncé’s total includes four awards with Destiny’s Child and The Carters. Counting solo wins, Taylor was already ahead, 30 to 26. There’s a clear case for honoring her directing. She has four Best Direction wins, more than David Fincher’s three. But creating a separate honor also gives MTV something useful: a record it can promote before the competitive awards are decided. Taylor isn’t announced as a performer. Last year, she skipped the ceremony and the move to CBS helped draw 5.5 million viewers, up 42%. This year’s two-hour broadcast overlaps with Sunday Night Football. “Taylor Swift becomes the most awarded artist in VMA history” gives people a reason to pay attention before the show starts. The new award guarantees MTV a Taylor Swift headline, even if it never gets a Taylor Swift appearance.
Taylor Swift will receive the first-ever MTV Artist Director award at this year’s VMAs. Described as the “first-ever award to recognize artists whose directorial work has advanced the art of music video and storytelling.”
211
Def Jam went platinum selling a fighting game. By April 2004, Def Jam Vendetta had sold more than 1 million copies worldwide. Five months later, on September 20, EA released Def Jam: Fight for NY. Kevin Liles and the Def Jam team understood how much fans cared about the people making the music. Their voices, clothes, personalities and rivalries could carry an entirely different product. Gaming gave fans another reason to spend money on artists they already followed. Fight for NY brought together more than 40 hip-hop artists and celebrities, including Snoop Dogg, Method Man, Ludacris and Lil’ Kim. Players could dress their fighters in Rocawear and Phat Farm, then buy jewelry from Jacob the Jeweler. The same names selling records, clothing and jewelry became things you could play with, wear and earn inside the game. That also gave Def Jam room to reach beyond its own roster. Artists from other labels appeared under the Def Jam name because the brand could credibly represent the wider culture. EA supplied the game-making expertise and distribution; Def Jam helped make the world worth entering. A record label had spent years making fans care about its artists, then gave those fans something else to buy.
61
Drake is on pace for his biggest consumption year ever. According to Luminate, through the first 8 months of the year he moved 10M units in just the U.S. At that current pace he’ll achieve 15M units in 2026. 17 years after releasing So Far Gone, Drizzy still hasn’t peaked.
Drake's 'Iceman' is the only 2026 rap album to spend every week in the top 10 of the Billboard 200 since its release‼️👀
3
100
More than 10,000 people showed up for the opening of a 500-seat Planet Hollywood in Las Vegas in 1994. This 1991 clip helps explain why. Stallone, Schwarzenegger and Willis are talking about action movies during an interview promoting Planet Hollywood. Founders Robert Earl and Keith Barish gave stars equity for appearances and endorsements. A conversation about their films became publicity for a restaurant they had a financial stake in. Early locations were generating nearly $15 million each in their first year. Customers bought the food, the drinks and the T-shirts. Planet Hollywood went public in 1996 at $18 a share, with Earl targeting annual growth of 30–40% in revenue and restaurant count. Celebrity attention helped sell an ambitious expansion story to customers and investors alike. Then the bills caught up. Expansion costs mounted while high prices, disappointing food and poor service gave customers fewer reasons to return. The company lost $244 million in 1998. By August 1999, the stock was trading at 75 cents, down almost 96% from its IPO price. It filed for bankruptcy that October, then again in 2001. Now 50 Cent is helping Earl try again. Their March 2026 partnership, announced as a $100 million deal, centers on PH Live in Times Square, with performances, premieres, sports screenings and private events. The idea is to give people something different to come back for. The financial results still have to follow. Thirty-five years after this interview, Planet Hollywood is still working on turning a celebrity’s audience into repeat customers.
In an interview from 1991 to promote Planet Hollywood, Stallone, Schwarzenegger and Willis talk about their action movie roles.
89
“Die With A Smile” reached 4 billion Spotify streams faster than any song in history. More than two years after release, it’s still #11 on the platform’s global chart. Each billion took longer: First billion: 96 days Second billion: 104 days Third billion: 210 days Fourth billion: 355 days The first 200 days averaged roughly 10 million streams a day. The latest billion averaged 2.8 million. That’s a substantial slowdown, but still enough to generate another billion streams in under a year. That’s what makes the song’s run so impressive. Even as listening falls, it keeps adding streams at a pace most songs never reach. Gaga included it on Mayhem. ROSÉ put “APT.” on Rosie. Both gave their albums an established hit whose ongoing streams could contribute to album consumption. Bruno left both off The Romantic, his first solo album in a decade. Nine songs. No features. Neither of his two enormous duets. Including them could have helped the album’s streaming numbers and given listeners another reason to visit the tracklist. He passed on that advantage, and the album still debuted at #1. A hit this big can keep supporting an album for years. Bruno had two available and released nine new songs instead.
Lady Gaga and Bruno Mars' "Die With A Smile" officially becomes the fastest song to surpass 4 billion streams in Spotify history.
1
1
4
304
This is the long tail of streaming. When you have a great body of work, people keep going back to it. Songs keep showing up in the algorithm and on your playlists, and new fans keep discovering them. ASTROWORLD has added at least a gold record’s worth of U.S. consumption every full calendar year since its release. If that pace holds, the album could be eligible for Diamond status in the next few years. 2018: 2.1M 2019: 1.4M 2020: 867K 2021: 719K 2022: 573K 2023: 636K 2024: 677K 2025: 532K 2026: 366K YTD 8.1M album-equivalent units in the U.S. and counting.
‘ASTROWORLD’ remains Travis Scott’s most daily-streamed album on Spotify‼️ The album is still receiving over 6.1M daily streams, 8 years after its release.
64
People love to talk about first week sales. First weeks never defined Future. In 2024 he put out three #1 albums in six months. The first two were We Don’t Trust You and We Still Don’t Trust You. Both with Metro Boomin. They hit the road and wrapped their tour September 9. Eleven days later Future dropped Mixtape Pluto by himself. No features. Southside and Wheezy on the beats. All 17 songs on the Hot 100. It opened at 129,000. Two years later it’s at 938,000 in the U.S. and still moving. The same way his whole catalog is moving. Future is at 3.9M units YTD and on pace for one of his best years yet.
2 years ago today, Future dropped 'MIXTAPE PLUTO' 🦅 Favorite tracks on the project?
1
150
Usher has good reason to put the crown on himself. Thirty years of hits, and his live business is still getting bigger. Eighty nights at Park MGM did $96 million. Super Bowl halftime in 2024. Then Past Present Future: $187 million, 1.1 million tickets, $2.3 million a night. Now he and Chris Brown are selling out football stadiums. Through the first 16 dates reported, the tour generated $116 million. Every night sold out. $177 a ticket. $7.2 million a night. Three nights in Detroit did $22.3 million. Three nights in Landover did $21.9 million. Two nights in Charlotte did $21.3 million. That’s $2.3 million a night on his last tour and $7.2 million a night on this one. He and Chris are showing what R&B can do in stadiums when the catalog is this deep and the show holds up.
Usher Is DONE Being Humble About This R&B Crown! 👑😭
154
Ola Hudson designed for John Lennon, Ringo Starr, and Diana Ross. She made the black trousers and waistcoat Bowie wore as the Thin White Duke in 1976. She sold her own line into Neiman Marcus and Henri Bendel. Her work is in the Met. When her son Saul was 10, Seymour Cassel, an actor whose kid was friends with him, started calling him Slash because he never sat still. The name stuck. He joined Guns N’ Roses. Appetite for Destruction became one of the best-selling debuts ever. The 2016 reunion tour did $584 million. The catalog is at 9.4 billion streams in the U.S. Last night GNR played Truist Park for over 40k people.
David Bowie photographed with his girlfriend in 1976. She had a 10-year-old son named Saul. A few years later, the young boy changed his name to Slash and started playing in a rock band called Guns N' Roses. The rest is history.
292