Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6) header
Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6) profile picture

Writer, ex-Editor and Publishing Director, self-appt. analyst on sports, politics and TV. I was not on Twitter, but June 14, 2020 changed that.

Joined September 2020
Photo by Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6)Photo by Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6)Photo by Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6)Photo by Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6)Photo by Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6)Photo by Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6)Photo by Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6)Photo by Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6)Photo by Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6)Photo by Murli Menon (@MurliMenon6)
Cowardice is a negative state of mind. Not a policy.
There is a certain genre of writing that substitutes accusation for argument. It begins by assigning motive, then arranges facts,real, distorted, or imagined, to fit that conclusion. The recent commentary on my views on India-Pakistan relations follows that familiar script. Let me state the essentials clearly. To argue that India must combine deterrence with engagement is NOT to diminish the reality of terrorism, nor to excuse it. It is to recognise how serious nations manage adversaries. India has, across governments and decades, done precisely this, responding firmly to terror while retaining channels of communication where necessary to prevent escalation and miscalculation. This is not sentimentality. It is statecraft. The suggestion that engagement grants “impunity” rests on a false binary, that one must either talk or act. In practice, states do both. To collapse that complexity into a moral accusation may make for forceful prose, but it does not make for sound policy. The caricature of a women’s caucus is equally misplaced. It is not proposed as a substitute for national policy, nor as a solution to entrenched conflict. It is a modest Track II initiative, one of many possible avenues, to widen dialogue, reduce hostility, and explore areas where cooperation may still be possible. Such efforts do not require approval from those who see every form of engagement as capitulation. Invoking the suffering of victims of terrorism to argue against any form of dialogue is particularly troubling. Their loss demands seriousness, not rhetorical deployment. Accountability is not strengthened by narrowing the space for thought. The claim that an idea is discredited because it is welcomed by a Pakistani voice is also a curious standard. If the merit of an argument is to be judged by who agrees with it, then independent judgment itself is surrendered. Ideas must stand or fall on their own logic. Beyond the rhetoric lies a more fundamental question: what is India’s end game with Pakistan? If it is to reduce Pakistan to rubble, that is fantasy dressed up as toughness. It is not going to happen, and any attempt to move in that direction would risk catastrophe for the entire region, not least for India. Nuclear geography is a stern schoolmaster. It does not indulge chest-thumping. The real end game has to be containment, deterrence, internal strengthening, and selective engagement. In plain words: India’s objective should be to make Pakistan’s use of terror too costly to sustain, while preventing the relationship from sliding into permanent uncontrolled escalation. That means four things. First, raise the cost of terrorism. Through intelligence, border management, diplomatic isolation where warranted, calibrated military response when necessary, and relentless exposure of the infrastructure of proxy violence. No illusions there. Second, deny Pakistan veto power over India’s future. We should not let our growth, our diplomacy, our regional ambitions, or our internal confidence be held hostage by a single hostile neighbour. The greatest strategic answer to Pakistan is a stronger, more cohesive, more prosperous India. Third, manage the conflict, not romanticise it. There will be no grand reconciliation in the near term. But neither can every interaction be reduced to rage. Ceasefire mechanisms, back channels, water safeguards, crisis hotlines, and limited functional engagement are not signs of softness. They are instruments of control. Fourth, keep open the possibility of a different future without betting on it. That is where dialogue belongs. Not as wishful thinking, not as “aman ki asha” balloon releases, but as disciplined statecraft. You talk not because you trust, but because you must understand, signal, warn, probe, and occasionally de-escalate. So the end game is not rubble. It is a Pakistan that is deterred, constrained, denied easy success, and unable to derail India’s future. Fury is a mood. It is not a policy.
1
1
3
130
Murli Menon retweeted
When a group of girls from Meghalaya sang "Maa Tujhe Salaam" together inside a packed stadium, the moment turned deeply emotional and unforgettable. Their voices rose in perfect unity, echoing pride, gratitude, and love for the nation, proving that patriotism speaks every language and lives in every corner of India. Dressed simply yet confidently, they transformed the stadium into a symbol of unity, reminding everyone that India's strength lies in its diversity and shared respect for the motherland. The performance wasn't just a song -it was a powerful message of harmony, belonging, and national pride that left the audience moved and inspired.
5
76
10
290
7,485
One gave @priyankac19 all credit for our diplomatic victories in countries across the globe post #OperationSindoor . But to hear her on @IndiaToday 's show with Dalladeep, was most disappointing. The Islamo-left works in unison.
1
1
297
Graceful, courageous, and fearless, all in a day’s work for Officer Roshni. 🫡
Forest Beat Officer Roshni of Paruthipalli Range did not flinch even after seeing this 18-foot long #KingCobra! It was was caught by her from the residential area of ​​Anchumaruthumoot, Peppara, Thiruvananthapuram, #Kerala, after locals bathing in the stream spotted it today.
175
1,407
17
19,208
554,199
Murli Menon retweeted
#PAKISTAN Radar & C2 Losses – #OperationSindoor 📍 1. Nur Khan Airbase (Rawalpindi Region) System Lost: Long-range radar + C2 node (possibly HT-233 / HQ-9 support) Type: Command & Control + radar suite Estimated Cost: $30–40 million 📍 2. Chunian Airbase (Punjab) System Lost: YLC-8E anti-stealth radar Type: UHF-band, counter-stealth radar Estimated Cost: $50–60 million 📍 3. Lahore Region (HQ-9 Deployment Zone) Systems Lost: 2 x HQ-9 radar components Type: Search/tracking radars for SAM batteries Estimated Cost: $30–40 million 📍 4. Sargodha Airbase Systems Lost: 2 x AN/TPQ-36 Firefinder radars Type: U.S.-origin counter-artillery/mortar radar, used in dual role Estimated Cost: $20–24 million 📍 5. Murid Airbase (Punjab) Systems Lost: 1 x AN/TPQ-36 Firefinder radar 2 x AN/TPS-43 surveillance radars Estimated Cost: Firefinder: $10–12 million TPS-43 (x2): $14–18 million 📍 6. Undisclosed/Frontline Areas near LoC Systems Lost: 2 x GCI / Legacy radar systems (possibly old H-200 or low-tier systems) Estimated Cost: $10–16 million 📍Walton Airbase – Radar/C2 Assets A mobile or medium-range tracking radar, Type 120 or older H-200 series unit Cost estimate: Mobile radar: ~$8–12 million C2 containerized node or station: ~$5–7 million Total: ~$13–19 million USD Grand Total (Only Radar Losses) : $177–229 million USD
2
420
18
2,120
125,833
Hoping this is implemented sooner than later. The only criteria that should be considered in scrapping any vehicle should be whether it pollutes the atmosphere or not. All PUC-certified vehicles should be exempt.
BIG NEWS 🚨 10-year ban on diesel and 15-year ban on petrol vehicles in Delhi-NCR is likely to be put on hold.
144
Murli Menon retweeted
Why have Pakistani accounts been unblocked ? @narendramodi @AmitShah @rajnathsingh @MEAIndia @SpokespersonMoD @MIB_India
100
738
26
1,764
34,714
Has the GOI policy changed @AshwiniVaishnaw or is your ministry a super government which can decide on its own that it will open the flood gates to Pakistani propaganda? Did you decide this on your own? Or are the babus in your ministry such potentates that they make their own decisions even if these go against GOI policy? Please tell us where you stand on this?
Pakistani commentator Qamar Cheema spread fake news during Operation Sindoor. Govt of India’s “PIB Fact Check” did a Fact Check on him. Then his X was banned in India. Today his X is back visible in India. Ban has been lifted. He can do more propaganda and fake New’s for ISI!
235
1,578
43
4,234
108,830
To @BJP4India Just a note on your latest policies. - Scrapping of perfectly road-worthy, non-polluting vehicles, is draconian. - Unbanning Pakistani YouTube channels that abuse us on a daily basis, is cruel. Why are you becoming more and more like the UPA governments of the past?
81
Slap on our Govt. Well Done @MIB_India !!!
172
2,581
98
8,777
161,777
Now the trolls don’t even have @Grok ka Sahara. 😂
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
14
305
3
887
18,594
Time's Up for fake Aadhar Cards in Assam! In a few days from now, we will make Aadhar issuance stricter for adults so that no infiltrator can illegally obtain the card and disturb India's harmony. Infiltrator Mukt Assam is our goal and we will NOT STOP till it is attained.
165
1,056
31
4,267
55,403
The greatest threat to world peace today? Not jihad. Not terrorist tunnels. Not genocidal textbooks. No — it’s Hindus and Jews refusing to die quietly. Two civilisations; one that chanted Om, the other that wrestled with Yahweh. Both scorched by centuries of fire, inquisitions, forced conversions, jihads, and the Hakenkreuz (Nazi crooked cross) . They crawled out of crematoriums and desecrated temples, only to be told now that self-respect is fascism. When a Jew builds a border, it’s apartheid. When a Hindu defends a temple, it’s hate. But when Islamists blow up cafes or stab sleeping children, it’s called “context.” The champagne Marxists in academia, people who’ve never met a terrorist they couldn’t excuse — lecture from Ivy League pulpits about “Zionist aggression” and “Hindu majoritarianism,” while retweeting Hamas propaganda over soy lattes. What really haunts them? That Jews and Hindus, once museum exhibits of martyrdom, now stand, not as footnotes, but as headlines. This isn’t an alliance of convenience. It’s an alliance of the exiled. Of those who remember Babylon and Kashi, Masada and Nalanda. They’ve committed the ultimate postmodern sin: Choosing dignity over victimhood. Victory over virtue-signalling. The Islamists hate it. The NGO-dollar industry hates it. The ‘human rights’ cartel that’s blind to Jewish graves and Hindu genocide hates it. Because Jews and Hindus have chosen to remember — And memory, my friend, is the deadliest weapon against propaganda. Let them brand us fascists. Let them cry “supremacy” while defending terrorists. Let them foam and faint. We are not here to seek approval. We are here to exist, and that, to them, is the greatest crime.
43
445
22
959
21,258
We now have to explain to the leftist-liberals in our country on where the attacks by the US on Iran's nuclear facilities, emanated from. Well done PIB because most of these specimens do not have a basic knowledge of geography.
Several social media accounts have claimed that Indian Airspace was used by the United States to launch aircrafts against Iran during Operation #MidnightHammer #PIBFactCheck ❌ This claim is FAKE ❌Indian Airspace was NOT used by the United States during Operation #MidnightHammer ✅ During the Press Briefing Joint Chiefs of Staff Chair Gen. Dan Caine (@thejointstaff) explained the route used by US aircrafts Watch here - xitter.cf/cspan/status/193676364…
124
Well @khanumarfa, the civilisation you eulogise isn’t the one that breathes in today’s Iran — it’s the ghost of a murdered soul by one you defend. A) No, it wasn’t 7,000 years old. That’s not history — that’s civilisational cosplay. The Elamite and Avestan roots were ancient, yes, but let’s not fictionalise timelines to win Twitter debates. B) It was the cousin of Vedic civilisation (that you abuse) — children of the same linguistic and spiritual womb. Two fires lit from the same cosmic spark: one became the Rigveda, the other the Zend Avesta. C) That civilisation died — not a natural death, but was stabbed in the 7th–8th century, when the sword of Islamic conquest carved through it, mosque by fire temple, minbar by manuscript. D) The survivors? They fled. To where? Hindu Bharat. The Zoroastrians, once rulers of a mighty empire, found shelter in the land of dharma, not in Mecca or Medina. E) And irony of ironies — even the Sunnis of Iran weren’t spared. In the 16th century, the Safavid dynasty converted them at gunpoint into Shias. The “majority” religion of Iran today was installed, not inherited. So no, today’s Iranian “culture” isn’t a torchbearer of Cyrus or Darius or Ferdowsi. It’s a mausoleum built atop the ruins of a murdered civilisation — One that gave us the ethics of Zoroaster, the genius of Avicenna, the poetry of Hafez, and the urbanity of Persepolis. All wiped clean in the name of one Book, one God, one Prophet. And what couldn’t be killed, was rewritten.
101
969
35
2,343
54,370
Rishabh’s celebration is as entertaining as his batting! 🤩 🏏 Well done Rishabh.
453
7,196
92
145,345
1,957,589
Here is the President of the US of A literally begging to be awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for stopping wars all over the globe. He's taken credit for the cessation of hostilities between India-Pak; Rwanda-Congo; Serbia-Kosovo, and Egypt-Ethiopia. Forget Israel-Iran or Ukraine-Russia, he doesn't have the State of California under control!
1
100
Folks - happy to announce that my experiments with AI are finally blossoming. Get ready for ancient Hindu legends to come alive in my upcoming animated graphic novels which will bring epic tales to life. Here is a short trailer. Let me know what you think.
405
609
26
2,970
63,535