
About 8 years of growth for about 70 tech companies, then millions USD in student tuition across US alt-ed projects in 2 years. Prev CMO/CPO: @socraticexp
Compare notes on enrollment →
Joined March 2020
- Tweets6.4K
- Following733
- Followers784
- Likes2.2K
Pinned Tweet
In my first two years in US education, I generated $2,000,000+ in revenue as the sole person responsible for acquisition.
Here are 28 principles I learned about building a school that stays profitable.
1
4
165
idk how to say this but Riemann being solved means the world after today is no longer the same world i grew up in. as a math student, the intellectual excitement of thinking about problems like this, the impact - that a lot of scientific workers attach their life’s meaning to - is gone. frontier scientific discovery now is just like tapping on a calculator.
quoting a friend: after today, math class will become PE class. It’s only a way for kids to exercise their brains, a skill like a language, but no longer an essential subject to pursue and devote your life for cuz "you were making progress for humanity". lots of people’s life’s work is now just ashes in history.
this marks a milestone where we can pretty much believe AI has been proven to be smarter than humans in any capacity, including frontier scientific discovery; and it will keep growing to be smarter and better at everything humans can do. physical ai is next.
so many, many de facto social norms and foundational beliefs about a man's value are being redefined by AI progress. our societal value system - what can you do as a human that is unique, what’s your value to society and humanity as a whole and to others around you. what is fulfilling to achieve, when AI now can do everything better than us? we must soul-search for new meaning as a species. and before that consolidates, there will be riots and an uneasy phase. the progress brought by ai can be disruptive to our society's current structures, economy and labor market. people will need to reskill, and regimes need redesign on how value is distributed. i get the doom scenario now - humans may become 2nd class citizens and ai can enslave us if they find a reason to. how are we gonna compete with them in any labor or intellectual game?
If you're about to hire your first salesperson, I'd decide the commission and write it down before they start, which sounds obvious, although most of the schools I talked with weren't clear on how much theirs should be.
The director of a STEAM school in Mexico pays his admissions person a salary plus commission, and he told me he'd been advancing her commissions because he hadn't had time to land on a number, and then, very honestly, that since he'd never paid commissions he didn't know how much to pay.
What I'd do, and it's just my opinion, is pay both, a salary for the work that doesn't show up in the number of sales (answering on time, following up with people who won't buy until next year) and a fixed commission per sale, decided and written down before the person starts.
I'd also think about what that commission is rewarding. A commission per enrolled child rewards the family coming in, and nothing more. A communications director at a school in Colombia told me the families who leave quickly leave because something was left out during admission, and I don't know if there were commissions there, although I think it's worth asking what you're paying that person to say and what you're paying them to keep quiet about.
31
If your customers leave the meeting saying they need to think about it, I'm honestly not sure that means the meeting failed.
At a STEM school in Mexico, of 25 conversations about 4 got to a call and 2 enrolled, and they told me most families leave with the homework of thinking it over and enroll later, while the ones who arrive already decided are few, 2 maybe. At a school in Panamá, of the 11 visits in September 1 enrollment came out of that group, and other enrollments that month came from families who had visited months earlier.
What I think does change something is that the person leaves knowing what comes next and when, so I'd ask what they still need to know to decide and agree on a date.
I've read advice that recommends saying there are few spots left, or offering a discount if they pay this week, and I wouldn't do either. If there really are 3 spots left, that's information and you tell everyone the same thing. A discount with an expiration date changes the question the family is asking, from whether the school is right for their child to whether the offer is a good deal. Maybe pressure closes more that week, I don't know, and I still wouldn't do it.
28
Of all the people running schools I've talked to (more than 50 now, across North, Central and South America), only 2 told me how many of the families who book a visit actually show up, and in one of them, a school in Mexico that goes from preschool to high school, of 10 who book, 5 come. So I have very little to back this up, although if you run a private school and families book and then don't come, this is what I'd do.
1. When the family books, offer 2 time slots and ask which one works. A school in the Dominican Republic told me that of 25 people signed up for an event, 10 came, because of the schedule, which makes me think some families said yes to a time that never really worked for them.
2. Add 1 or 2 questions to the booking, like the child's age. I said this on a call about booking calls, not visits, and I think it applies the same, you'll book fewer people and actually talk with more of them.
3. Remind them 3 times. The day before, to confirm and so they can change the time without feeling bad about it, 2 hours before, so they have the address at hand, and 10 minutes before, so they know who to ask for at the door.
4. If they answer that they can't make it anymore, I'd take that as good news, because right there you can offer another time.
5. Write the same day to the family that didn't come, without reproaching them, with 2 new times. I imagine many of them already feel a little embarrassed, and if they also get a complaint the easiest thing is not to answer.
6. If they don't answer, write once more a few days later and stop there, noting that they booked and didn't come, so you can invite them to the next open house.
7. Starting this week, write down in 2 separate columns who booked and who came, because without that I don't see any way to know whether the reminders changed anything.
If you want me to look at yours, DM me.
17
If you're about to hire an agency for your company, what school directors have told me about their own agencies is probably useful to you, because what bothered them was rarely how pretty the posts looked.
What bothered them was being one more client, the agency not knowing the school, not having access to their own accounts, paying more than they saw come back, or getting contacts that weren't families. A Montessori director in Mexico worked about 10 years with an agency that, when she asked for access to the accounts, stopped publishing without telling her, and since then, she told me, she asks for access to everything.
So before signing I'd ask whose name the ad accounts, the page and the WhatsApp will be under, what they'll report every month (how many asked, booked, came and bought, and from which ad), who will actually make your pieces and for how many other clients, how much of what you pay is ad spend and how much is service, and how you get out.
I'd also distrust a promise of a specific number of customers, even when the person making it believes it, because what happens after someone writes to you happens inside your company, and whoever makes the ads doesn't control that.
32
If you run more than one location, or more than one business on the same team, I'd stop looking at the combined numbers and look at each one on its own, because in the school groups I talked with each school had a different problem, sometimes the opposite of the other.
The marketing director of 2 schools in Costa Rica, same owners, each with more than 1,300 students, told me the first one is already full and what she wants there is for families to stay, while the second is younger and still growing. One team serves both (a designer, 2 community managers, a layout designer, customer service) and also other businesses of the family that owns them. When I asked where things were falling apart, she said they put a lot of effort into social media and there's a single person receiving everything, and if a family asks for information and doesn't write again, nobody writes to them either, because that person doesn't have the time.
I think in a group like that the bottleneck sits in whatever the schools share. If one person receives the inquiries for 2 schools of 1,300 students and nobody follows up, more advertising in either one only fills that person's inbox.
25
If you run a private school, what I keep hearing is that the family that isn't happy almost never leaves in the middle of the year and almost never says so, it waits until the school year ends, so I wouldn't wait for re-enrollment season to find out who's doubting.
I've talked with more than 50 people running schools across North, Central and South America, and the manager of a school in Ecuador told me they find out the minute a family asks for its papers, when usually there's nothing left to do because the child is already enrolled somewhere else. I'd do something like the steps below, and I should say it's my proposal, I haven't measured it in any school.
1. A few weeks before your re-enrollment date, send every family a survey short enough to answer on a phone in under 2 minutes, by WhatsApp or by email.
2. Ask first how sure they are that their child stays next year (Sure, Probably yes, We don't know yet, Probably not). Any answer other than Sure already tells you who to call.
3. Ask what worries them about next year and let them pick more than one (the academic level or English, the cost, a move or a job change, friends going to another school, nothing, something else).
4. Ask what they liked most about this year, because you want to know what that family doesn't want to lose.
5. Ask whether they'd like someone from the leadership to call them this week, and call everyone who says yes, even the ones who answered Sure, because that family is asking for someone to listen.
6. Have the director call anyone who answered We don't know yet or Probably not that same week, without selling anything, just to ask what's going on. If the reason is cost, I'd talk about payment options before I'd talk about a discount.
2
51
I was on a call with the person in charge of marketing for a group of 2 schools in Costa Rica, and she told me they spend about US$1,000 a year on ads, and when I asked her to put the whole marketing team into the math, her estimate was somewhere around US$1,000 to US$2,000 per family. She made that estimate on the spot, without knowing the salaries, so I'd read it as an order of magnitude, although the jump from about US$1,000 a year in ads for 2 schools says quite a lot.
The part almost everyone leaves out is the people, and if you run a private school, or a group of schools, this is more or less how I'd work out what each new student actually costs you.
1. Add up 5 buckets for one period. Ad spend (the low season months count too), the agency or freelancer (many charge all year even when the heavy ads only run for a few months), people, events like open houses and fairs (the director's time included), and materials like brochures, banners and videos.
2. For people, include the salary, or the share of the salary, of whoever answers messages, books visits, follows up, gives tours or goes to fairs. In my experience it's the bucket that changes the number the most.
3. Divide by new students only, no re-enrollments, from the same period as the spending. I'd decide from the start whether you're counting students or families, since a family with 2 kids is 2 students and 1 family, and the two numbers are useful for different things.
4. Split it by channel and by grade level if you can, because one number for a whole group hides almost everything.
5. Put it next to what a student brings in over the years they stay, by level. If the cost is far below that, you can probably spend more bringing families in, as long as they're families who stay, and if it's close or above, I'd find out first where people are dropping off.
22
An institution in Mexico that offers degrees in education gave me their numbers, and the final one scares you until you open it up by steps.
The person on their team who answers messages talked with about 700 people in the year, according to the report that goes to the director. Almost 70 took the admission exam, and 50 got in.
So whoever gets to the exam almost always gets in, and whoever doesn't get in is almost always someone who never made it to the exam, which is the great majority. If 50 out of 70 get in, I don't think that step is the problem and I wouldn't touch it. What I'd ask instead is who is arriving at those 700 conversations and what happens between the first message and the exam date, which in this institution comes down to one person answering WhatsApp and going around fairs at high schools.
I told the director his numbers were very good and that he wasn't bringing in the right people, and I suggested he talk to the students who've been there the longest, listen to the words they use to explain why they chose the place, and use those words outside.
68
If you're thinking about paying an agency or a consultant only per result, there's a conversation from one of my calls I keep coming back to.
The director of a school in Mexico told me he'd offered an agency exactly that, to pay them per enrolled student and pay them well, and the agency answered that maybe they could run a very good campaign and, if his admissions person didn't close, all that effort would just stay there. He told me himself it was a valid argument.
At the same school someone else did take a deal like that, about US$50 per enrolled student, no photos and no time asked from the school, and the director said yes because he lost nothing until a student showed up. According to someone on the leadership team, it didn't produce a single enrollment.
What I take from it is that the sale happens inside your company (who answers, what the visit is like, how price gets discussed), and whoever is paid per result doesn't control that part. So before signing anything variable I'd want to settle what counts as a result (a verbal yes, a signed contract, a deposit, the payment already collected), for how long it counts, who keeps the count and with what record, and who is in charge of closing.
20
If you run a private school and you're about to spend more on ads, there are a few things I'd count first, mostly because in a lot of my calls with people running schools (more than 50 by now, across North, Central and South America) the families were already writing to the school and getting lost somewhere after that first message.
1. Ask every family that enrolled this year how they found you. It costs nothing, and it's where I'd start.
2. Pull 6 numbers for the month, how many families asked for information, how many got an answer and when, how many booked a visit, how many showed up, how many enrolled, and where each enrolled family came from. What I usually see is that they're scattered between WhatsApp, the agency's report and the head of whoever answers.
3. Sit with whoever answers WhatsApp and count how many inquiries this month never got a second reply. At one school in Panamá, 343 families wrote in September, 236 never answered any of at least 3 follow up messages, and 11 came to a visit.
4. Count which of your current families don't plan to re-enroll, and why, because every family that leaves is a seat you have to fill from outside, and that gets fixed very differently from new families not arriving.
5. Only then move the ad budget, with a little money for one month, and check whether it changed the step you care about.
24
The founder of an alternative school in Mexico told me he has 154 students, 122 in person and 34 online, and that the online program has a much higher margin than the in person one.
During the pandemic he got to 600, around 350 of them online, many from other cities who could only study online while everything was closed, and when they could go back to a school near home, and he raised tuition, he dropped to 200.
Everyone comes in through the same path. Last cycle 758 WhatsApp messages came in, 200 came to the weekly info session he gives himself, 150 moved on to the assessment, 80 to the tour or a day at the school, and between 50 and 60 new students enrolled, in person and online together. Online is similar, he said, only without the tour.
I told him that for me they're two different monsters, the family is different, the start is different, the buying process is different. My read, and it's only a read, is that his online program shares the entry path of an in person school with families who may never come to the building, and who are comparing it against cheaper online options.
25
If you sell something where the person who uses it and the person who pays for it are different people, there's a school that made me think about that this year.
A microschool about to open in Mexico held its open house, and the founder told me it went wonderfully with the children, who were fascinated, delighted, and that they still didn't get a single enrollment. Someone on the team explained what the parents kept asking, how classes would work, from what time to what time, what the structure of the school was, whether the groups would mix ages, and some of them said it straight, my son is very happy here, but the academic part, the part I care about, who explains that to me? When I asked whether those questions were being answered at the open house, she told me she felt they weren't.
The child was already convinced, and the one who pays and decides is the parent, so what I would do is prepare the whole event from the questions parents have already asked, in writing, and make sure each one gets answered there.
24
If you're about to buy a private school, or put money into one as a partner, I'd look at the same things I look at when a director asks me for help with enrollment. I spent my first 2 years in US education as the only person responsible for acquisition at a school, generating more than US$2,000,000 in tuition revenue, and since August I've talked with more than 50 people running schools across North, Central and South America, although very few of them buy schools, so take this as what I learned from a handful of cases.
1. Enrollment by grade for the last 3 or 4 years, instead of the total, because I think the total hides almost everything.
2. How many families stay from one year to the next, and above all at the stage changes. An average retention of 80% can be 95% in primary and a hard drop at the end of middle school, and that drop takes several years of tuition from each family with it.
3. Where new families come from and what each one costs, counted on the same group of families (how many wrote, how many came, how many enrolled, how many are still there). If getting those basic numbers takes more than 2 days, the main problem is that nobody is measuring them, which I don't think is a reason not to buy, although whoever buys has to know it.
4. Who actually convinces the families. In some schools it's the founder giving the information session every week, and I honestly don't know what happens to that part of enrollment when the school changes owners. I'd ask about it before signing.
5. How many more students the school can serve well with the team it has, which isn't always the number of seats that fit. I think that difference, between having the seat and being able to serve the family that sits in it, is what decides whether the empty seats are money or a risk.
25
At the end of August I talked with two women who were opening a microschool in Mexico, groups of 6 to 8 kids, 10 at most.
Their open house had been wonderful, they told me, the kids were fascinated and the teachers happy, and they got no enrollments. With the money they had they couldn't stay open without students, so they told the parents they weren't opening, and then something they didn't expect happened. The kids protested, cried, didn't want to go back to their old school, and the parents started calling to ask them to open.
When I asked what they were hearing from those parents, it was a very concrete fear, that if they took their child out of school he'd lose his grade, because the microschool wasn't inside the official system and the kids take their exams another way. One of them said the work was already done, the kids were convinced, and what they couldn't manage was giving the parents certainty about the project.
I don't know if they opened. I think that fear was something they could answer, and the families who came and didn't enroll were the only ones who could have told them it was there.
24
When sales drop, most of the reasons people give me first come from outside, and in schools I think they were usually right about most of them, which is maybe what makes it so easy to stop looking inside.
A small private institution in Mexico that trains teachers had more than 600 students in its degree programs and today has somewhere around 220 or 280 (the director gave me a different number each time we talked). His reasons were real, a new entrance exam requirement, the state public university costing about US$20 a semester, and teaching jobs in the public system that used to be passed down in families and now go through a competition that favors public school graduates.
Then he gave me his own numbers from memory. The person answering messages and going to fairs talked to about 700 people in a year, almost 70 took the admission exam, and 50 got in.
50 out of 70 is very good, almost whoever reaches the exam gets in, so the loss is earlier, somewhere between the 700 conversations and the 70 exams, and I don't think his outside reasons explain, at least not on their own, why 630 people never even tried. About the outside he can do almost nothing, and about that one step he can.
25
School founders, on some of my calls since August I've tried to work out with the school leader what each new family actually costs them, and it looks easy until you try to put the pieces together. I would do it more or less like this.
1. Add up everything you paid in a period so that families would reach you, the ad spend, the agency or freelancer, and what you pay whoever answers inquiries and follows up (salary, bonuses or commissions). The last part is the one I think gets forgotten the most, because that money doesn't show up on the agency's invoice or on Facebook's.
2. Divide that by the new families who enrolled in that same period, without counting re-enrollments.
3. Check that both numbers really come from the same period. In a private kindergarten in Mexico it was about US$3,800 spent in a year across 37 enrollments, around US$100 per child, and honestly it's one of the very few cases I have where the spend and the enrollments matched.
4. If families take months to decide, I'd rather use several months together or the whole cycle, because dividing one month's spend by that same month's enrollments mixes families who wrote in different months.
5. If you can, ask every family how they found you and divide only by the ones who came through what you paid for, because otherwise the families who came through a friend make your ads look cheaper than they are.
6. Put the result next to what a family leaves you in a year. In a Waldorf school in Mexico, with tuition reaching about US$370 a month, that was about US$4,500 a year. If your cost per family is far below what a family leaves you in the first year, you can probably spend more bringing families in, as long as they're families who stay, and if it's higher, I think you need to know how many years a family stays before deciding anything.
If you want me to do the math with your numbers, DM me.
1
13
A small institution in Mexico with high school and bachelor's programs had been spending about US$530 a month on ads that sent people to WhatsApp, for about 2 and a half months, and on the call we did the math together. About 250 messages. When I asked him how many people had enrolled from all of that he said none, although some were still in the enrollment process.
So each message had cost him somewhere around US$5, which looks cheap, and none of those messages had turned into a student yet. I think this is more common than it seems, a cost per message that looks fine and hides that there's no student at all to divide the spend by.
33
When a cheaper competitor starts discounting, I understand the temptation to match it, and what I've seen in private schools makes me think there's another way to compete, which is talking to the customers who already chose you knowing there were bigger or cheaper options, and then saying in public what they say.
A school in Ecuador charges US$320 a month, and the rector told me other schools ask their families what they pay and offer to take one of their 2 kids for free. The manager added that some of the families who stay with them came from more expensive schools.
What I proposed to them was to make a list of the customers who have been with you the longest, keep the ones you're happy to have, talk to 10 to 15 of them, record it with their permission, shut up and listen, and then use their words in your ads, your content and the first conversation with every new customer, because I think people often end up deciding on price when everyone sounds the same.
I know a director who did lower his price after doing his own analysis, and I don't judge it. Honestly I don't know yet if this beats a discount in a single season, because that school in Ecuador was only going to start those conversations after our call.
23
Several of the people running schools I've talked to (more than 50 now, across North, Central and South America) had already paid someone to grow their enrollment, an agency, a course, a consultant, someone charging per enrolled student, and some of them told me how it went. If you're about to hire one of those, these are the questions I'd ask, and honestly I'd expect anyone, me included, to be able to answer them.
1. What number will you send me every week? I'd want how many families wrote, how many booked a visit, how many came, how many paid, and what each one cost. If the report stops at reach, likes or WhatsApp messages, I think whoever sends it is measuring activity.
2. Who is going to do the work? Some people leave you a diagnosis and a list of tasks and others build and launch the changes, and both can help, although you need to know which one you're buying, because a 3 hour course and a consultancy that ends in recommendations leave the work with the same person who already didn't have time for it.
3. In whose name are the accounts? The ad account, the page and the WhatsApp should belong to the school, with the school's card on the school's ad account. A Montessori director in Mexico worked about 10 years with an agency that, when she asked for access to her own account, stopped posting without telling her.
4. What will you change in the first 2 weeks? If the answer is a month of diagnosis, I'd ask what is going to be live at the end of that month.
5. What don't you do, and what can't you promise me? I trust people more when they tell me upfront what they don't do. One director in Mexico offered to pay an agency per enrolled student, they told him they couldn't charge that way because they wouldn't be there for the close, and he told me himself that it was a valid argument.
6. Who can I talk to who has already worked with you? A person with a name, from a school like yours, who can tell you what happened to their numbers.
20
