Pierre Le Fwosty retweeted
Assisted death campaigners, @MDMDmydecision and @Humanists_UK are mocking Baroness Finlay, a leading palliative care expert, talking about a little boy's goldfish in debate. They say this is evidence of a filibuster. What could be more ridiculous than trying to resuscitate a goldfish?
Well if they had actually bothered to listen to the debate they would have heard how this little boy, with advanced cancer, was dealing with the knowledge he was dying, supported to the end by Baroness Finlay.
That little boy told her "I'm going to die when my goldfish dies". "He went on to talk through what he wanted when he was dying and how he would play football in heaven with another boy who had died recently. Not long after, his goldfish was found floating".
Baroness Finlay, caring for that child, describes in a single sentence how she tried to hold back death - not from the goldfish but the child.
"My strenuous attempts to resuscitate his goldfish failed, and he gently died soon"
"He" is the little boy. With advanced cancer.
I cannot imagine the grief that must sit with palliative care experts as they help these young children, but to mock Baroness Finlay for it is terrible.
She shared this experience because she was trying to amend Clause 6 which had been added at Report stage by opponents. It prohibits raising assisted dying with a child.
She wanted the House of Lords to understand why the language needed to be changed. She was explaining, from experience, that children can speak with extraordinary frankness about death, and that they deserve “gentle, honest planning of their care”, and to be able to ask questions about what they may have heard on TV or on the internet about assisted dying, including an explanation of why they are not eligible for assisted suicide.
It's an amendment and a speech that supporters of assisted dying should have supported - they resisted restricting discussion with children. Instead they've mocked it and that little boy's death. Listen to her speech in this thread. Then read again the press release at the end of the thread.
And ask yourselves who has actually demonstrated bad faith.

ALT Extract from Humanists UK press release: Dave Sowry, Board Member of My Death, My Decision, said: ‘I’m equal parts outraged and distraught. Dying people were made to wait while peers talked and talked. We welcomed scrutiny of this Bill and serious debate, even when that debate was difficult, and opinions differed. That is how Parliament should work. ‘When I listened to Baroness Finlay describing her failed attempts to resuscitate a little boy’s goldfish, it became obvious beyond all possible doubt that this was a filibuster. Instead of a good-faith effort to test and improve the Bill, we saw scaremongering and endless delay, while terminally ill people were ignored.’
Pierre Le Fwosty retweeted
The real scrutiny of assisted dying is only just beginning thecritic.co.uk/the-real-scr…
Pierre Le Fwosty retweeted
Shambolic week for proponents of #AssistedDying - on judges, capacity & defining suicide.
Promise to accommodate opposing views has gone. It now looks like every other debate - polarised, defensive, what matters is to win.
Not how such a profound moral issue should be decided.
Pierre Le Fwosty retweeted
West Ham United proudly supports ‘Heirlooms’, a film raising awareness about suicide bereavement and highlighting the incredible work of @suicideandco
Together, we can break the stigma surrounding suicide and provide the support those experiencing loss truly need.
Whether or not you support assisted dying,....the fact that the MP leading the bill cannot stand up and say NO to this question should terrify all of us.
Replying to @danny__kruger
At the end @Rebecca_SPaul and I managed to get Kim Leadbeater to admit that under her Bill a person would be able to get an Assisted Death for the sole reason of saving their relatives money. 3/3
Pierre Le Fwosty retweeted
Frustrated by the assertion: no prior review was needed for the ’Assisted Dying Bill’ due to the experience in other jurisdictions. The result: no consideration of the interaction with the Mental Health Act, compounded by re-framing physician assisted suicide as ’assisted dying’.
Pierre Le Fwosty retweeted
Might as well just go all in at some point, @ steveborthwick…
15. George Furbank
14. George Hendy
13. Tommy Freeman
12. Fraser Dingwall
11. Ollie Sleightholme
10. Fin Smith
9. Alex Mitchell
😇🏴
Pierre Le Fwosty retweeted
Replying to @finsmithh
@finsmithh my guy is HIM 🔥 Seen it first hand during my time at @SaintsRugby . He can do it all 🤷🏽♂️👌🏽
Everyone is showing quite a bit of patience towards Wales' players and fair enough. But at the very least, Rob Howley has to be sacked as attack coach. Wales have no attack strategy. At all. #ITAvWAL #GuinnessM6N
221
Can we please have Dingwall in for Slade for the next match,.... #ENGvFRA #6nations2025
3
374
Pierre Le Fwosty retweeted
WHAT A MOMENT, WHAT A GOAL! 💥
LEYTON ORIENT TAKE THE LEAD AGAINST MANCHESTER CITY!!!!

This media is unavailable
Pierre Le Fwosty retweeted
“There are many people, including those on the bill committee, who are having to deal with over 200 amendments over a weekend. How on earth are they meant to get their heads around that?”
The assisted dying bill is being “rushed”, says @Jess4Lowestoft.
Pierre Le Fwosty retweeted
A blistering piece on the assisted dying bill - and how it's being mishandled by its parliamentary proponents - from @HackneyAbbott
politicshome.com/thehouse/ar…
Whether you support assisted dying or not,...the way this bill is being pushed through Parliament is appalling. Please take a few minutes to read these letters to see just a few of the alarming failures in the bill
This evening me, @Meg_HillierMP, @Jess4Lowestoft and @JamesFrith have written to all Labour MPs about the evidence to the assisted dying bill committee.
Honestly,....Slade at 12??? Put Freeman in there or play Dingwall. Slade didn't have the legs to chase down a hooker last week. Urgh
#EnglandRugby
2
76























