
AP @UMontreal - former @IMFnews , @CERGE_EI • Views my own • pro-density / yimby • Aut inveniam viam aut faciam.
Montréal, Québec
Joined September 2012
- Tweets1.1K
- Following941
- Followers492
- Likes1.6K
Luca Mazzone retweeted
I shouldn't have to do this, but if you read some historians who claimed the Holocaust was not culturally a big deal until the 1960's, 1970's, or 1980's, and you believed them, you were defrauded by anti-semitic liars.
The Holocaust was HUGE culturally, IMMEDIATELY.
Luca Mazzone retweeted
US voters just rejected data centres everywhere they got the chance.
That investment has to land somewhere.
Clean hydro. Open land. Cold winters.
That's Canada 🇨🇦
This is a massive opportunity for us. Generational.
Luca Mazzone retweeted
I will demonstrate coding agents for academic economists tomorrow. One of my messages is to get out of the OpenAI - Anthropic bubble.
What qualifies me to say this? Having tried all of these below plus maybe some others I don’t remember.
Claude Code
Codex
Cursor
OpenCode
Hermes Agent
pi
Kilo Code
Factory
Kimi Code
T3 Code
Muse Code
Delta (Zed)
Letta Code
omp
prime-agent
fx
I currently work mostly with omp and Hermes.
If you’ve only seen Codex and Claude Code, try OpenCode first.
Luca Mazzone retweeted
🧵1/10 Given the recent reactions of mathematicians over rapid advances in AI, I think it is important to remember that technological change has historically been a very personal event for people.
Over the history of technological progress, looms have fallen silent, switchboards have gone dark, and factory lines have shrunk bringing with them a human crisis of identity and what it means to be a master of one's craft.
Luca Mazzone retweeted
May come as a bit of a surprise to those of us who were following Paul's writings in the 2010s when he was railing against Eurozone "austerity craziness".
With interest rates at the zero lower bound, he argued that fiscal consolidation in a depressed economy was self-defeating: multipliers were large, so cutting deficits deepened the slump and did little for debt ratios. France was one of his recurring examples. It turns out that French policymakers were listening to him. In every big recession, they massively increased spending. But the multipliers were not as big as advertised. Deficits didn't pay for themselves.
Government debt/GDP is a persistent state variable. Bond yields are not. If the only reason you're changing your mind is because yields are up, then your advice wasn't that good to begin with.
Op-eds and blog posts arguing against French austerity (list generated by Claude)
“Franc Thoughts on Long-Run Fiscal Issues,” blog post (Conscience of a Liberal), August 11, 2011. Argues there are limits to deficits but they are not relevant now.
“Those Revolting Europeans,” NYT column, May 2012. Welcomes Hollande’s election as a rejection of austerity. (Title and date from memory; please verify before citing.)
“The Plot Against France,” NYT column, November 11, 2013 (online November 10). Attacks the S&P downgrade; calls French fiscal prospects “distinctly nonalarming.”
“France by the Numbers,” blog post, January 2014. Mocks French elite pessimism after Hollande’s supply-side turn.
“Scandal in France,” NYT column, January 17, 2014. Calls Hollande’s embrace of austerity and supply-side doctrine scandalous.
“The Fall of France,” NYT column, August 29, 2014 (print, p. A23). Says Hollande folded to austerity demands; France “isn’t Greece” and not fragile.
Related: defenses of the French model, not explicitly about austerity
7. “What’s the Matter With Europe?”, NYT column, May 2017. Argues France is a fairly successful economy that gets bad press from welfare-state critics.
8. Twitter thread, November 5, 2019. Argues France gets bad press not borne out by the facts.
Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman warned that France’s deteriorating public finances are on an “unsustainble path” and at risk of unleashing a debt crisis across the euro area bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
Luca Mazzone retweeted
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) has a nice post today explaining how he fixed his dishwasher with the help of ChatGPT. We have all been there over the last couple of years. In my case, from fixing a light fixture in my kitchen to repairing a leak in my irrigation system.
Deutsch and many readers point out something that has been a staple of my talks for a decade. GDP was designed to measure an economy that produced coal and steel, easily measurable quantities. And GDP did its job quite well for decades.
IT, first, and later the internet and AI, changed the landscape. My favorite example is books. Even as late as 2010 or so, getting the most recent books in Spanish on, let’s say, Spanish economic history was hard in the U.S.: expensive and time-consuming. Every time I went to Madrid, I carried two bags, one of them empty because it would come back filled with books. Then Kindle arrived, and now I can buy nearly every single Spanish book I want in seconds and at a lower price than the physical copy. This was an enormous increase in my welfare that never got reflected in GDP.
The literature is divided on how big this effect is. I tend to side with those who think it is a big deal. Therefore, many of the gains in GDP growth announced by the strongest defenders of AI might not materialize: they will go instead into higher welfare.
But the issue goes beyond getting GDP wrong. What Deutsch perhaps did not notice is that he did not pay VAT on the service of the repair person he did not hire, and that such a repair person did not pay income taxes on the service he did not render.
Taxing AI-based economies might thus become much harder, from a purely technical perspective. One solution would be to tax the profits of OpenAI (or Deutsch’s subscription), but I am among those who think those profits are not going to be nearly as large as anticipated. Competition among labs will drive the subscription prices of models down (unless labs can cartelize, for example, by appealing to “AI security”). Over 95%, and perhaps as much as 99%, of the gains from AI will pass to the final user, whether another business or an individual.
Now, we could tax the final user, for instance, at a fixed rate per token used. But that implies we are taxing the high-return activity (how to fix the dishwasher) at the same rate as the low-return activity (Claude: “tell me a joke about my cat jumping”). And taxing per token might hurt those final users who use more tokens because they are more productive, something we might not want to do (yes, there is something called the uniform commodity taxation theorem, but it often breaks down).
Let me give you an extreme example: imagine that tomorrow the new OpenAI model cures all cancers, forever. Just a vaccine, $10, once in your life, and you never get cancer again. The increase in human welfare from such an invention would be staggering. But how do you measure it in GDP? Yes, people will live longer, perhaps work longer. A second-order effect on GDP. And more importantly: how do you tax the vaccine? Do you even want to tax the vaccine? I would argue we want to subsidize it, and generously.
When I was still an undergrad, my first RA job was helping to construct GDP and other national aggregate statistics in Spain. It was a most valuable experience, because it made me aware of what GDP means, its strengths (and it has many more than its critics concede), and its limitations. But it also taught me that what you can tax out of GDP is far more limited than you would think at first sight.
There are real upper bounds on taxation, and I am afraid the bound is tighter now than it used to be.
I just fixed my dishwasher with the help of ChatGPT. A trivial task. I had been about to order a new one. So this software has increased the country's real wealth yet decreased the measured GDP. The main economic indicator is structurally incapable of registering the thing that actually makes people better off, namely the growth of knowledge
Luca Mazzone retweeted
Pour tous les Québécois qui ne savent pas, Ilya Somin est l'avocat qui est derrière la plus grande défaite en cour de l'administration Trump sur le sujet des tariffs. C'est aussi mon collègue à GMU et maintenant mon collègue à l'IEDM.
Et je me permet un commentaire cruel ici: les médias québécois manquent la chance de parler à cet avocat qui connait le droit américain, qui parle français et qui a littéralement été en cour suprême des États-Unis sur le sujet.
Votre expert, il est là! Vous attendez quoi au juste?
Luca Mazzone retweeted
Re-upping a simple but old solution to keep your in-text numbers in sync (i.e. correct) between replication package output and what is printed in your paper
jpedataeditor.github.io/post…
Taxes on wealth or unrealized capital gains are a bad idea. Not just because of all the well-known implementation issues. But also in theory.
Our paper, now forthcoming in Econometrica:
When Jeff Bezos's Amazon stock doubles, should his tax bill? No, say Mark Aguiar, @ben_moll and @Florian_Scheuer: optimal taxes target realized net trades plus cash flows—not wealth or unrealized gains—while avoiding lock-in, whatever moves asset prices.
econometricsociety.org/publi…
Luca Mazzone retweeted
What critics keep getting wrong about capitalism: The Stanford Encyclopedia's new entry on capitalism doesn't pass an ideological Turing test capx.co/what-critics-keep-ge… via @CapX
Are there any ideas from the "softer" social sciences, which is actually interesting and useful for economists? Broadly, the quality of work in these fields is weak and fluffy, but there are definitely bright spots. First, here's a beautiful book on the sociology of finance
Luca Mazzone retweeted
Replying to @dan24601
Oh, I don't know. So many!!!!!!
A few favorite of mines that any student can read and get 95% out of them:
George Akerlof (1970), "The Market for 'Lemons': Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanism," QJE
Michael Spence (1973), "Job Market Signaling," QJE
Gary Becker (1973), "A Theory of Marriage: Part I," JPE
Robert Lucas (1978), "On the Size Distribution of Business Firms," Bell Journal of Economics
Sherwin Rosen (1981), "The Economics of Superstars," AER
Douglas Diamond and Philip Dybvig (1983), "Bank Runs, Deposit Insurance, and Liquidity," JPE
Thomas Schelling (1971), "Dynamic Models of Segregation," Journal of Mathematical Sociology
Martin Weitzman (1974), "Prices vs. Quantities," Review of Economic Studies
William Baumol (1967), "Macroeconomics of Unbalanced Growth: The Anatomy of Urban Crisis," AER
Kevin Murphy, Andrei Shleifer and Robert Vishny (1989), "Industrialization and the Big Push," JPE
Michael Kremer (1993), "Population Growth and Technological Change: One Million B.C. to 1990," QJE
Luca Mazzone retweeted
This shows that the people who criticize the plethora of terms like "neoliberalism", "capitalism", "free markets", "market capitalism" have a bare bones understanding (if none at all) of what they criticize.
I am going to RT multiple pieces of Ben's thread separately with a comment on each item.
The author cited by Ben below said she took three years to write her SEP entry on capitalism. Three years and she coudn't be bother to read the dozen articles on the Hayek-Friedman hypothesis. Take the most cited paper on the topic, its abstract makes it clear that the author did not bother to read.
And this goes to my first point: often, in non-econ fields, people just repeat tired talking points. I encounter it all the time in Quebec where I know exactly where they emanate (generally from two-dozens philosophers and social scientists in France and Quebec). But they never bothered to read what they criticized.
They use weaker strawman recycled from previous strawmen. The arguments become increasingly poor as a result.
Replying to @ben_golub
The Hayek-Friedman section says capitalism requires every market to be complete and unregulated.
Hayek did not say this. His contrast was between coordination under general rules and centralized direction, not between zero regulation and any regulation.
2/
Luca Mazzone retweeted
I strongly believe that knowledge is fundamental to running a society. We need economists who understand monetary policy in central banks. We need researchers who have studied history, strategy, and military affairs to help steer national defense. We need doctors and public health experts to design effective responses to epidemics.
But the public needs sound reasons to let these experts shape their future. Once that trust evaporates, we are all worse off. Unfortunately, the Jason Arday scandal is the perfect example of how these experts, and the institutions they run, are destroying that trust.
I do not find Arday’s tales extraordinary. Throughout history, there are thousands of examples of people spinning fantastic tales about their lives. He is just one more name on a long list of confidence men.
What is extraordinary is the massive institutional failure at every level. Liverpool John Moores University granting a degree for a Ph.D. dissertation that did not survive even basic scrutiny (including a grammatical mistake in its title). Cambridge University appointing him (full) professor at an unusually early academic age (eight years after his dissertation; in academia, this is what matters, not your biological age) and with a scholarly record that was rather thin. Hilary Cremin (@hilarycremin), head of the Faculty of Education, telling the world on television that Arday was “the best in the world in terms of the research that you do.” The BBC broadcasting segments about Arday, a most unusual decision for an academic appointment. Simon & Schuster paying him a large advance for his memoirs on the basis of a book proposal that defied common sense. And Amazon promoting his book, still this very morning, as an editor’s pick.
If I were a regular person, say someone driving a truck in the Midlands or working at a small shop in Sussex, how could I trust the universities any longer? How could I trust the BBC and the media? How could I trust the publishing industry? How could I trust Amazon’s editor’s picks?
Then, should we be surprised if the farmer or the shop owner votes for someone selling snake oil? Or if they refuse to listen to the case for policies that cost them in the short run but benefit them in the long run, such as the transition to net zero emissions? Or if they read books written by charlatans? Or if they deny basic scientific findings?
The universities, the media, the publishing industry, Amazon, and many of our other core knowledge institutions have a serious problem. Their response is to close ranks and avoid a serious discussion. No, sorry, this will not do.
The Jason Arday scandal should be a moment of reckoning. Unfortunately, I am afraid it will not be.
Luca Mazzone retweeted
Replying to @HanmingF
Yes, I fully agree.
I am 100% sure this would have NEVER happened at the Faculty of Economics at Cambridge.
But that highlights an important point: there are serious externalities across departments and schools.
You can be as serious as you can be, but if the person in the building in front of yours does something like this, you pay a lot of the reputational cost.
This probably deserves a post on its own!
Luca Mazzone retweeted
Evidently, Arday is not the main villain here. He’s either a sick person or a great con man.
The real issue is the charlatans who are capturing institutions and diluting a reputation hard-earned by real scholars over several centuries.
I strongly believe that knowledge is fundamental to running a society. We need economists who understand monetary policy in central banks. We need researchers who have studied history, strategy, and military affairs to help steer national defense. We need doctors and public health experts to design effective responses to epidemics.
But the public needs sound reasons to let these experts shape their future. Once that trust evaporates, we are all worse off. Unfortunately, the Jason Arday scandal is the perfect example of how these experts, and the institutions they run, are destroying that trust.
I do not find Arday’s tales extraordinary. Throughout history, there are thousands of examples of people spinning fantastic tales about their lives. He is just one more name on a long list of confidence men.
What is extraordinary is the massive institutional failure at every level. Liverpool John Moores University granting a degree for a Ph.D. dissertation that did not survive even basic scrutiny (including a grammatical mistake in its title). Cambridge University appointing him (full) professor at an unusually early academic age (eight years after his dissertation; in academia, this is what matters, not your biological age) and with a scholarly record that was rather thin. Hilary Cremin (@hilarycremin), head of the Faculty of Education, telling the world on television that Arday was “the best in the world in terms of the research that you do.” The BBC broadcasting segments about Arday, a most unusual decision for an academic appointment. Simon & Schuster paying him a large advance for his memoirs on the basis of a book proposal that defied common sense. And Amazon promoting his book, still this very morning, as an editor’s pick.
If I were a regular person, say someone driving a truck in the Midlands or working at a small shop in Sussex, how could I trust the universities any longer? How could I trust the BBC and the media? How could I trust the publishing industry? How could I trust Amazon’s editor’s picks?
Then, should we be surprised if the farmer or the shop owner votes for someone selling snake oil? Or if they refuse to listen to the case for policies that cost them in the short run but benefit them in the long run, such as the transition to net zero emissions? Or if they read books written by charlatans? Or if they deny basic scientific findings?
The universities, the media, the publishing industry, Amazon, and many of our other core knowledge institutions have a serious problem. Their response is to close ranks and avoid a serious discussion. No, sorry, this will not do.
The Jason Arday scandal should be a moment of reckoning. Unfortunately, I am afraid it will not be.
Luca Mazzone retweeted
Finding NBER Summer Institute talks on YouTube is surprisingly frustrating.
I asked Claude to build a searchable webpage that finds any talk by paper, author, or session, and jumps straight to where it starts in the video.
Link in the first reply.
Luca Mazzone retweeted
My experience when I see AI writing: about 1% of the time it's “person has good ideas and isn’t efficient at writing them out on their own.” 99% of the time it's: person has bad ideas and bad writing, or else is using AI to cover up a lazy effort.
This creates a lemons problem for people in the 1% case. You are using AI writing in a pro-social manner, but if your writing has that distinctive AI style, your good thoughts and ideas will get missed bc we all inevitably develop AI writing filters. The lemons problem is non-trivial.
Within my team, we have high trust and there is no lemons problem. Here, AI or AI-assisted writing is often the most efficient way to communicate and should be used in those cases. But even here, we signpost clearly when things are heavily AI, so the reader knows how seriously to take it.
If you send someone a page of AI writing that is purported to be human, they will spend more time and attention on it than they would if they knew it was AI. You are stealing their time and destroying their trust in the value of what you send them.
One of the challenges with AI writing is that the norms are unclear and heterogeneous across teams. You can do something that is totally kosher within your team, but will destroy trust and harm your reputation outside of it. This is a reason to be cautious with using AI for writing — it's only safe to do so among recipients where you have already established the appropriate norms.
Luca Mazzone retweeted
I am extremely happy to circulate a new paper, “Structural Estimation with Unstructured Data,” joint with Sara Casella (@SaraCasella9), Stephen Hansen, Ryohei Oishi, and Minchul Shin:
sas.upenn.edu/~jesusfv/Text_…
This has been a long time in the making: I presented a first set of slides (no draft!) at the ASSA meetings in San Diego in 2020. But COVID and life in general slowed down progress. Fortunately, we finally pushed the paper across the (working paper) finish line over the last few weeks.
The idea, I believe, is very cool, and I am proud of how we implemented it.
Can we use unstructured data (e.g., text, images, sound, ...) to estimate dynamic equilibrium models and their structural parameters? The answer is yes.
More concretely, we augment the standard state-space representation of a dynamic equilibrium model with a noncore measurement block that links structural shocks to time series derived from unstructured data, and then use standard filtering and McMc to draw from the posterior. We rely on a spike-and-slab prior to let the data select which series are informative.
To illustrate how well this works, we take a medium-scale New Keynesian model for the U.S. and estimate it using conventional data (i.e., output, inflation) together with FOMC transcripts (text).
We document how incorporating text improves predictive performance and materially alters structural inference: the new model estimates a lower response of the policy rate to inflation, higher price stickiness, and lower price indexation, implying a flatter and less backward-looking price Phillips curve.
The intuition is simple: the FOMC transcripts tell us a great deal about the Fed’s true policy function because they reflect the expectations and preferences of policymakers, even if only in verbal terms. The likelihood function appreciates such information.
The idea generalizes to all sorts of dynamic equilibrium models. For example, one could use Amazon reviews alongside standard data on prices and quantities to estimate structural models in IO. Or one could use images to expand the information set of DSGE models. The possibilities of the methodology are endless.
As always, comments are much appreciated.
New CEPR Discussion Paper - DP21393
Sorting into Entrepreneurial Teams
Edoardo Acabbi @EconUniMannheim, Andrea Alati @bankofengland, Luca Mazzone @UMontreal, Marta Morazzoni @ucl @TheIFS
ow.ly/EKlj50YOVz8
#CEPR_MG #EconTwitter





























