Pinned Tweet
India’s prospects are a matter of choice, not fate.
Introducing The Indian Prospect: economics, politics and policy, argued with evidence.
Why we exist: theindianprospect.substack.c…
🤖 Made with AI
4
221
Profits up 22%, jobs up 1.5%.
That gap is the PM’s FICCI question, translated into numbers.
At FICCI, PM Modi put a pointed question to India Inc.: You got the tax cuts you asked for. Have you hired more people or paid them better?
After years of urging industry to invest, the government is asking what it has to show for its efforts.
1
34
India’s biggest companies now pay an effective tax rate of 18.85%, below the average company. The reform delivered.
Has industry?
The exchequer gave up ₹1.45 lakh crore in 2019.
India Inc’s cash pile is now seven times that.
We looked at where the money went and why PM Modi is asking for jobs.
At FICCI, PM Modi put a pointed question to India Inc.: You got the tax cuts you asked for. Have you hired more people or paid them better?
After years of urging industry to invest, the government is asking what it has to show for its efforts.
7
142
Jai Jawan Jai Kisan worked because farmers delivered once they had the tools. Industry has had its tools since 2019: lower taxes, PLI, clean banks and a boost to demand. It’s industry’s turn to deliver.
We are all very excited and energised by the Prime Minister's inspiring speech to industry at FICCI. He was so open and straight-forward. Everyone must support the Government wholeheartedly in the quest for Viksit Bharat.
We have many opportunities. There are three ideas which we can all come together and give serious thought to.
1. The Government has some amazing assets and companies which operate across an entire spectrum from natural resources to energy to light manufacturing and heavy industry. It is proven in India and globally, that if the same companies are run by private management, production can increase multifold, even 10 times. In this process, many new industries will also develop, particularly MSMEs and we can create crores of jobs.
Any privatization must be accompanied with two conditions. First, no retrenchment. Second, employment should be increased by 3 times. Also, there are two ways to privatise. Either sell shares to a private corporate or distribute shares in the public, like in the case of British Airways and British Petroleum.
Whenever the private sector has been given a chance, it has delivered. For example, in airports, ports, airlines, telecom, metals and hotels. It has created 3 to 4 times jobs and raised salaries in privatised companies. It is ready to replicate this in gold, copper, power, defence, engineering equipment, shipping and every other sector.
These are all national assets and will always belong to the country. The massive revenue gained by the Government can be used to reduce debt and invest in infrastructure. In democratic countries, government does not run business. The US has followed this with great success. We can do even better.
2. The PM also spoke very strongly about trust. That is the foundation for Viksit Bharat. Since time is of the essence, we should replace lengthy processes and approvals with self-certification and allow new industries to come up rapidly. Again, the Government is there to lay down the rules simply and ensure compliance via audits.
3. The entire below-the-ground sector - minerals, metals and hydrocarbons - is built on one thing: exploration. While mining and processing are highly capital-intensive and difficult to start, exploration is the exact opposite. It can be a way of a life with hundreds, even thousands, of startups. It doesn’t require large capital, Rs 5 crores is enough.
The key to make it a movement is allowing young explorers to freely sell their discoveries to larger companies. So, for example, if an exploration startup discovers oil, it can sell it to ONGC. If another discovers a mineral, it can sell to Hindustan Zinc. These companies have the capacity to make the huge investments for mining and processing.
Right now, this is not permitted. Any discovery becomes the property of Government. This must be modified.
We are living in a very exciting time for India. Our youngsters and women are going to achieve their full potential. We have a positive and progressive government. Let us get together and build a movement.
Sixty years ago, with the slogan of Jai Jawan Jai Kisan we achieved self-sufficiency in food. Now, let us do the same for privatisation, self-certification and exploration. It will create jobs, raise incomes and strengthen the rupee.
@PMOIndia
Our analysis:
xitter.cf/IndianProspect/status/…
At FICCI, PM Modi put a pointed question to India Inc.: You got the tax cuts you asked for. Have you hired more people or paid them better?
After years of urging industry to invest, the government is asking what it has to show for its efforts.
1
26
Chinese imports accounted for 77% of India’s Penicillin G imports in FY24.
For 6-APA, a critical antibiotic intermediate, the figure was 94.1%.
Penicillin was discovered almost a century ago, and India still can’t make enough of its key ingredient at home. That isn’t a technology gap. It’s a choice to import cheaply rather than invest patiently.
Meanwhile, Indian companies fund only 36% of the country’s R&D, against over 70% in China and the US.
That’s the self-reliance gap PM Modi was pointing at when he told FICCI the industry always asks for more.
Huawei had 195,000 employees in 2021, of which 107,000 “worked in R&D.”
Now look at India’s biggest companies. Average R&D expenditure as a percentage of net turnover of Nifty50 companies stood at 0.79%.
One company built its own technology under sanctions. India’s largest companies, with lower taxes and record profits, still prefer to license, import and white-label.
PM Modi asked FICCI whether companies had hired more. The better question might be whom they’re hiring, and whether any of them are building anything new.
Read more: xitter.cf/IndianProspect/status/…
In 1912, Tata Steel introduced an eight-hour working day when most workers in the rest of the world were working 10 to 12 hours per day. Indian law caught up only in 1948.
Tata Steel also gave workers free medical care, provident fund and paid leave before any law required them. Indian industry once led the world on how to treat its people.
Today, corporate profits rose 22.3% in FY24 while employment rose 1.5%, and the Prime Minister is publicly asking industry to hire and pay more. Somewhere between 1912 and 2026, India Inc stopped leading and started waiting to be asked.
Our analysis below.
PM Modi at FICCI: “Did you hire more? Did you raise salaries?”
What the numbers show:
- Corporate tax: 30% → 22%
- Profits: ₹2.5L cr → ₹7.1L cr (FY21–25)
- Cash pile: ₹10.35T, 2x FY19
- FY24: profits +22.3%, jobs +1.5%
The state delivered. India Inc hasn’t.
Our analysis in the below tweet👇
At FICCI, PM Modi put a pointed question to India Inc.: You got the tax cuts you asked for. Have you hired more people or paid them better?
After years of urging industry to invest, the government is asking what it has to show for its efforts.
In 2019, the government cut the base corporate tax rate from 30% to 22%. Public capital spending then rose from 1.67% of GDP in FY20 to 3.2% in FY25.
Alongside lower corporate taxes, the government invested in infrastructure and cut personal taxes to give consumers more spending power.
1
7
175
In FY24, corporate profits rose 22.3%, and by FY25, companies held ₹10.35 lakh crore in cash, more than twice the FY19 amount. Yet, employment grew just 1.5%.
Has India Inc kept its side of the bargain? We take a closer look in our latest piece.
substackfwd.xyz/?url=https:/…
4
108
Every time a video of a dirty street goes viral, the familiar cycle of outrage begins. The blame is laid at the feet of India's lack of civic sense or, more broadly, 'our culture'.
But what if the explanation is far more mundane?
Even Japan, now renowned for its cleanliness, faced waste problems seen in Indian cities today. It tackled them through investment in waste infrastructure and stricter enforcement.
Closer to home, Indore has shown what similar efforts can achieve
A lecture on civic sense cannot collect garbage or build a waste-processing plant. For that, cities need money and functioning municipal services.
Our latest essay examines why Indian streets look the way they do & what it would take to change them.
substackfwd.xyz/?url=https:/…
In 1971, India had just 9 cities with populations exceeding one million. By 2011, that number had reached 53.
But does India's electoral map reflect the scale of this remarkable transformation?
Indian cities have become major centres of commerce, industry and employment and, today, attract millions in search of opportunity.
Yet their political representation has not kept pace.
With cities generating an estimated 63% of national GDP, this raises questions about how political representation will shape investment and government priorities, especially when growing infrastructure and public services demands are creating considerable strain.
With parliamentary delimitation approaching, our article examines the widening urban representation gap, its consequences, and the case for giving urban India its due political representation.
substackfwd.xyz/?url=https:/…











