Pinned Tweet
1/ 🧵A thread on the complex symbolism of hijab/burqa of muslim women.
The hijab has sparked debates globally, from protests in Iran to restrictions in France.
In this thread lets look at how the burqa's symbolism evolved dramatically during the Algerian War of Independence
Lefty Gooner retweeted
Western media: The "Hamas-run" files.
We read 45,577 passages of British and American news to count how often they say "according to the Hamas-run health ministry", and the reality is that they barely used the phrase until Israel began its genocide in Gaza.
Before 7 October 2023, these outlets put a Hamas label on Gaza's health ministry in 49 of 828 citations, which is 6%. Since then they have done it in 8,568 of 18,370, which is 47%.
Hamas has governed Gaza since 2007, and the same ministry counted the dead in 2014, 2018 and 2021 without anyone feeling the need to mention it. The label only became routine once the death toll became the record of a genocide.
What the figures show:
- The BBC News channel labelled 7 of 168 citations before October 2023, and 2,836 of 4,246 since (67%).
- BBC News online has labelled 1,493 of 1,789 since (83%), and nine in ten BBC articles that cite the ministry carry the label at least once.
- ABC, CBS, NBC and PBS went from 0 of 32 between them to 662 of 969. MSNBC went from 0 of 102 to 214 of 715.
- Broadcasters have said it on air 4,722 times since October 2023.
- The same outlets cited Israel's health ministry 174 times and never once called it Likud-run, Netanyahu-run or government-run.
Notice the double standard. "Hamas-run" is lazy to begin with, because the Palestinian Authority's health minister in Ramallah oversees the ministry, supplies its equipment and pays the staff hired before 2007. But the bigger problem is that the data shows these outlets use it in bad faith:
- The label exists to make you doubt the number. On 25 October 2023 President Biden said: "I have no confidence in the number that the Palestinians are using." The next day the White House called the ministry "just a front for Hamas", and CNN told its staff to describe it as "Hamas-controlled" "whenever we are referring to casualty statistics".
- The media fell into line within a month. The BBC News channel went from labelling 189 of 667 citations in October 2023 (28%) to 354 of 502 in November (71%).
- The numbers they are casting doubt on hold up. In 2014 the ministry reported 2,310 dead and the UN verified 2,251, and a peer-reviewed study in The Lancet found that the ministry had missed about two deaths in every five.
- On the BBC News channel, the only people who say "Labour-run NHS" are Conservative politicians attacking Labour. No presenter or reporter talks about a British institution that way.
- The BBC puts Hamas's name on Gaza's rescue workers too, the crews who dig families out of bombed houses, in 374 of 507 citations. CNN did it in 1 of 61.
- We found 223 passages calling Gaza's police "Hamas police" or similar, and 129 of them were reports that Israeli forces had struck, killed, targeted or detained those officers.
What makes this worse is that several outlets have shown the label is unnecessary, by dropping it and carrying on reporting the same figures:
- CNN labelled 146 of 200 citations in December 2023. In 2026 it has labelled 0 of 41.
- The Guardian went from 90 of 227 at the end of 2023 to 3 of 222 in the second half of 2025.
- The New York Times and Reuters hardly ever used it: 5 of 141 and 2 of 90.
The BBC has carried on regardless, labelling 54 of 85 citations on BBC News online since July 2026. Last week it reported that a sand embankment had collapsed onto tents in Gaza after heavy rain, killing three children and a woman, "the Hamas-run health ministry says".
Three years into a genocide, the BBC cannot report children being crushed by a sand bank without putting Hamas's name on the people who counted their bodies.
A label that is reserved for Palestinians, became routine in the same week the White House attacked the ministry and is never applied to Israel only serves to cast doubt on the Palestinian dead, which is unacceptable from a public broadcaster.
Every outlet's count, on air and in print, is in the full editorial: newscord.org/editorials/hama…
Lefty Gooner retweeted
EXCLUSIVE: After a months-long investigation, Channel 4 News’s FactCheck team has obtained a dossier of new files on UK arms export licences to Israel.
Go give this lecture on philosophical diversity to the hundreds of families who lost their loved ones to mob lynchings in the name of cow protection!
"I don’t know why anyone thought the American left will be better for Hindus this time. They only got Hindu vote because the right was being retardedly racist. But left hates Hindus too"
---
The racist right and the Marxist left are both intolerant dogmas, and very willing to use violence.
The racist right hating Hindus is well known. On the Marxist side, here is Karl Marx himself: "brought about a brutalizing worship of nature, exhibiting its degradation in the fact that man, the sovereign of nature, fell down on his knees in adoration of Kanuman, the monkey, and Sabbala, the cow.”
We also worship rivers and trees and snakes and birds, I would add.
The shared hatred of the Hindu is not an accident. Sanatana Dharma stands opposed to dogma. Our philosophers disagreed and debated with each other all the time and no one advocated killing the other for disagreeing. Hinduism as pratised today reflects that _philosophical_ diversity which the intolerant cults deem "pagan" or "primitive" or "barbaric".
Only the reverence for nature, which is at the core of Sanatana Dharma, can save the earth today.
The hard right thinks climate change is bogus. The hard left wants to usher in Marxism before anything can be done about climate change.
1
2
37
What a counter! Pure energy and determination!
Well deserved 👏
The referee was trying so hard for the equalizer.
#NFOMCI
2
61
Lefty Gooner retweeted
#Adivasi resistance to Rourkela Steel Plant railway & its destruction of farmland is ongoing from 2024 in face of murderous violence by police & paramilitary (a protester was killed, crushed to death by a #JCB). Resistance & police brutality continues! maktoobmedia.com/share/11684…
Lefty Gooner retweeted
I’m still raising funds for the family of Palestinian football legend Sulaiman Al Obaid, who was killed last year while trying to collect aid in Gaza.
He left behind a wife and five children who now rely entirely on donations to survive.
Please help if you can ❤️ chuffed.org/project/145216-h…
Lefty Gooner retweeted
Jamia Students' Union Elections has been restored ✊
Revolutionary greetings to all students who participated in this historic struggle.
People united shall always be victorious ❤️
Lefty Gooner retweeted
NEW: In a Texas courtroom Monday, 25 migrant children lined the pews — a 9yo rested her head on the table, a 6yo pretended to fly an airplane, and a 3yo played with the mic. Many in attendance didn't have an attorney — and a 13yo was ordered removed. A look inside, thru sketches.
Lefty Gooner retweeted
We need to tell you something we have tried very hard not to say: @MaktoobMedia cannot continue like this.
For the last eight months, we have received only around half of what we actually need to run our newsroom.
Lakhs of rupees in salaries and contributor payments are pending. People who reported, edited, photographed, travelled, filmed and wrote for Maktoob are waiting to be paid for work they have already done.
And tomorrow, another day of journalism has to begin.
We have somehow kept doing this since 2014. Without a single day’s break.
For more than twelve years, we have reported what needed to be reported without first calculating what reporting it might cost us.
We travelled where stories demanded us to be, even when we did not have the budget for those journeys. We reported from places and on issues that were being ignored. We documented violence, discrimination, hate, state excesses and injustice when looking away would have been easier and safer.
Our opinion pages carried some of the most critical voices and arguments of our time, not as a favour to anyone, but because those arguments needed to exist in the public record. We published them knowing very well that some of them could invite attacks, cases, pressure and consequences for Maktoob.
We were equally uncompromising with language.
When words demonised people, we refused those words. When commonly used terminology reproduced prejudice or turned victims into suspects, we challenged it. When violence had to be named, we named it. When Islamophobia had to be called Islamophobia, we did not hide it behind softer language.
We did all this because journalism does not merely report the world. Journalism can determine whose suffering is believed, whose voice is heard, who is treated with dignity and who is turned into an object of suspicion.
And we are doing this in a media environment where, day in and day out, sections of the media manufacture suspicion, legitimise hatred, amplify prejudice and create conditions in which violence against vulnerable communities becomes imaginable and normal.
In such a time, you are the beneficiary of Maktoob's existence.
Not because you agree with every story or every opinion we publish. But because a society needs journalism that refuses to join the machinery of hatred.
We have always been proud that when institutions failed people, we tried to act not merely as journalism’s so-called fourth pillar, but sometimes as the first pillar people could turn to: to document, to question, to amplify and to make sure something did not disappear without a record.
And Maktoob itself is still a miracle to us.
It began in 2014 with college friends from non-privileged backgrounds. There was no capital behind us. No wealthy family. No media empire. No large investor waiting to build us.
Students and friends carried Maktoob in its early years without any monetary benefit. Later, journalists, editors, photographers, video journalists, contributors and staff built it into what it is today because they believed journalism could be a justice-delivering process.
They made Maktoob possible.
And this is the part that hurts us most: today, we are unable to do justice to them.
People who have given their labour to Maktoob are waiting for their money.
Lakhs of rupees are pending.
We are unable to pay salaries and contributors on time.
Every month, we try again. We raise what we can. We somehow keep the newsroom moving. But what is coming in is simply too little.
For the last eight months, we have received only around 50% of our actual budget requirement.
A newsroom cannot survive indefinitely on half of what it needs.
We cannot run another month like this. At this point, even running the newsroom day to day is becoming difficult.
Maktoob is a private limited media company. Our revenue comes from subscriptions and advertisements. But the nature of the journalism we do means advertising opportunities are extremely limited.
That leaves us with the people who read us.
You.
Subscriptions are now our most important source of survival.
A Maktoob subscription starts at ₹600 for six months and ₹1,200 for one year. If you have the means, premium subscriptions are available up to ₹1 lakh.
For readers outside India, subscriptions are available in USD and EUR, from $50/€50 up to $1,500/€1,500.
Please subscribe to Maktoob for one year.
If ₹1,200 is possible for you, please take the annual subscription.
If you can afford more, please take a premium subscription. We urgently need people who can do that now.
And if you cannot subscribe, please send this message to someone who can.
Our journalism remains outside a paywall. Even at a moment when we are struggling to survive, we cannot convince ourselves that these stories should be inaccessible to someone simply because they cannot pay. We believe the journalism we publish is too important for that.
Subscribers receive our curated newsletters and invitations to live conversations with experts. But we do not want to sell you a subscription by pretending this is primarily a transaction for benefits.
We are asking you to subscribe because Maktoob needs to survive.
We need to pay the people who make this journalism.
We need to send reporters where stories are happening.
We need to keep publishing voices that cannot afford to disappear.
We need to continue naming what others soften, documenting what others ignore and reporting what powerful people would rather not see reported.
For twelve years, we found a way.
We worked without money. We travelled without budgets. We took risks. Our journalists and friends carried burdens they should never have had to carry. Again and again, we somehow found enough to make the next day happen.
But we cannot keep asking our journalists and contributors to pay the price for keeping Maktoob alive.
This time, we need our readers to carry us.
Please don't read this appeal and leave it for someone else.
Subscribe. Take a premium subscription if you can. Send this message personally to people who can support us. Ask them to subscribe.
We have reached a point where your response to this appeal will materially decide how we keep this newsroom running.
Maktoob has reported for twelve years without looking away.
Please don't look away from Maktoob now.
Visit maktoobmedia.com/support to subscribe, or pay via UPI at maktoobmedia@icici
Look at that run and look at the chance missed!
I have no doubt. Kevin Schade is the Martinelli replacement!
Get him to the Emirates now!
🚨🏴 IGOR THIAGO DOUBLES THE LEAD FOR BRENTFORD!
Brentford 2-0 Chelsea.
xitter.cf/canadaislands/status/2…
77
Lefty Gooner retweeted
Story of Abdul Jabbar and his family.
Indian authorities have sent Jabbar and his two minor sons to detention centre.
For weeks now, Jabbar's wife has no information about her two kids and husband.
Our report from Murshidabad @scroll_in
scroll.in/article/1095707/di…
Over 100000+ dead. Countless lives completely destroyed.
Yet, three years into this ongoing genocide, simply calling for their right to live is still being deemed unacceptable!
An utter shame for humanity!
#FreePalestine #Macklemore
Why does the Premier League Match Center have their comments off?
Why do they fear fans having an opinion on their shitty interpretation of rules?
#MUNMCI – 59’ VAR OVERTURN
VAR checked the referee’s call of no goal for offside – and determined that Haaland was in an onside position and recommended that the goal was awarded.
The VAR also deemed that while in an offside position, Fernandez didn’t play the ball.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Rule 2 of the offside law includes the wording "A player in an offside position ... by clearly attempting to play a ball which is close when this action impacts on an opponent", suggesting Enzo Fernández should have been ruled offiside.
thefa.com/football-rules…
1
174
Lefty Gooner retweeted
Jyotinagar Colony in Kolkata, a slum with 95% Muslims, has gone without water supply for over six weeks now. Right after assuming office, local BJP MLA Ritesh Tiwari had pledged he won't do anything for Muslims. #GroundReport by @onkeyta_ & @anindyahazra96
altnews.in/forty-six-days-on…





























