Jacob Berman | History Valley (@HistoryValley) header
Jacob Berman | History Valley (@HistoryValley) profile picture
Joined April 2019
Photo by Jacob Berman | History Valley (@HistoryValley)Photo by Jacob Berman | History Valley (@HistoryValley)Photo by Jacob Berman | History Valley (@HistoryValley)Photo by Jacob Berman | History Valley (@HistoryValley)
Jacob Berman | History Valley retweeted
This. This nails the Wes Huff situation exactly.
Some ppl think Wes did the ac. equivalent of using ChatGPT when he got too busy, so it's pedantic to care. But plagiarism means that he actively avoided training core skills that distinguish the PhD and give it the very cache that Wes was leveraging in his public work.
2
5
56
5,755
Jacob Berman | History Valley retweeted
-there might be some plagiarism -there is plagiarism, but not much -there is way more than we thought -it was old, though -you are just haters -what even is plagiarism? -plagiarism doesn't exist
14
12
128
2,019
Jacob Berman | History Valley retweeted
I’ve been hearing a lot nonsense about how the allegations against Wes Huff concern isolated, decade old instances that have no bearing on who he is today or diminish his contributions or knowledge. How about less than a year ago from an article only published 3 years before from publicly accessible article by David Armitage of @Tyndale_House, titled “Was Luke Wrong About the Census?” Presumably, attention that an article author and publisher could’ve benefit from that Huff diverted to himself instead. 79.1% of Huff’s 187-word caption consists of exact word-sequence matches of five or more words. Another 16.6% consists of unattributed paraphrasing and source-derived edits. In totally, only EIGHT words, or approximately 4.3%, classified as independently worded. One of which was #manuscriptmonday. Since “character” and “competence” are at the heart of this, 2 details are worth singling out. 1. look at “1st.” Armitage wrote “first.” Huff wrote “1st.” Think about that for a second. He reproduces everything surrounding it (word for word) but“1st”, of all the things, is what changes. It does absolutely nothing to make the passage original, except, interrupt what would otherwise be an exact match. 2. ‘ethnarch’. Armitage uses single curly quotation marks (‘ ’), very commonly used in British typographic practice — where this article originates. Huff reproduces the same marks in his post. American and Canadian practice usually favor double quote marks (“ ”) for primary quotes. Now, it’s not a rule per se, styles vary, but it’s a tell. Also, these are not marks enclosing a direct quote (which is a rule); they’re functioning as scare quotes/quotes used to identify or distinguish a term. Armitage could have written ethnarch in italics, used double quotation marks (“ethnarch”), or simply left it unmarked; all of which preserve the meaning. But Huff? the same word, the same punctuation, the same surrounding language. That’s an example of reproduced editorial choices, which can corroborate textual dependence when considered alongside extensive matching prose. Both are singled out because it because forensic linguistic comparisons also evaluate cumulative pattern of choices: vocabulary, syntax, sequencing, substitutions, punctuation, and editorial conventions. If @ApologeticsCA is truly committed to investigating this thoroughly, I’d expect them to retain credible and reputable experts specializing in this work. And here, the correspondences extend well beyond the historical facts being discussed. Personally, this strikes harder than allegations involving decade-old academic coursework. This is contemporary, public-facing material presented to his audience that follows Huff because of his supposed scholarly expertise. All he had to do was link the article like I just did here. tyndalehouse.com/2022/12/21/… But then he doesn’t get the credit to build his image, does it? The entire value of a scholar’s credibility is that we can rely on him to identify his sources, represent them accurately, and evaluate whether they’re actually correct. What exactly are his qualifications supposed to validate? This is more about credibility and integrity over plagiarism. I would venture to guess EVERYTHING is cribbed in some form from someone else.
5
16
7
67
5,695