“If teams are undervaluing the old school type player then it would be relatively cheap to craft a team with the right guys and win. But it won’t happen because it’s not actually better” Your conclusion is contained in your premise in other words your begging the question(logical fallacy) it’s only true if we assume teams are evaluating correctly . Markets can misprice and organizations can become overly concentrated on certain metrics. Maybe what you’re saying is true but “teams aren’t doing X isn’t proof that X doesn’t work.” You’re also just appealing to popularity/consensus (another logical fallacy) “Every organization has adopted analytics therefore analytics must be superior” This isn’t necessarily true. The fact every organization has done something is only evidence they believe it works not that it is true.

Lol

Barry Bonds goes 4 for 4 with a homer off Greg Maddux. #Giants (8/31/93)

Miguel Cabrera launches 2 homers in 3 hit game. (9/18/12)

David Ortiz belts first #RedSox home run

Gary Sheffield goes yard twice in 4 hit game. #Marlins (4/10/94)

Manny Ramirez rockets 2 homers in 4 hit game. #RedSox (7/10/04)

Sammy Sosa belts 64th and 65th of 1998 #Cubs

7/6/11 Giancarlo Stanton drills first career walk off. #Marlins

4/8/15 Adrian González belts 3 homers in 4 hit game. #Dodgers

Miguel Cabrera vs Yankees (04/03/11) 2 homers and a single

.334/.461/.692 With 50 HR his last year in Japan 🔥

2021 Shohei Ohtani MVP

2011 Matt Kemp .324 39 126