@HadasThier

Author of People’s Guide to Capitalism + writing @TheNation @HammerandHope @Jacobin etc + unrepentant Berner + mom to aspiring Major League Baseball player ⚾️

New York, NY
Joined June 2009
DSA is Zohran Mamdani's Special Sauce. I wrote for the Nation about the politics and the electoral machine behind Mamdani's campaign. Look out for it in their October print edition as well. (And with gorgeous illustrations from @mollycrabapple!) thenation.com/article/politi…
21
20
1
70
18,819
Hadas Thier retweeted
Hundreds of Jewish protesters gathered at Grand Central Station in New York City. United in one powerful call: “LET GAZA LIVE.”
173
2,333
137
5,026
141,171
Hear me out: What if we pressured progressive politicians from the left, but did that without smearing them as genocidal child murderers? This way we make sure: 1) Words have meaning 2) We remain serious people worth engaging with 3) Our movement can grow
61
116
12
791
31,947
Hadas Thier retweeted
Across the country, working-class and poor families are losing an essential benefit that allowed them to keep their heads above water. For Issue No. 12, @HadasThier went behind the headlines and statistics about the economy. hammerandhope.org/article/me…
1
10
16
941
Before running, Darializa worked as a criminal defense investigator and immigrant rights organizer. This is what it looks like when someone brings years of frontline organizing experience into elected office.
Two federal agents are going door to door near the crime scene “trying to get evidence.” Darializa Avila Chevalier and state Sen. Gustavo Rivera are following them to tell people they don’t have to answer or speak with the agents.
38
439
4
2,833
49,272
Hadas Thier retweeted
Our tax dollars are used to terrorize our people. Abolish ICE. Abolish SRG.
Darializa Avila Chevalier is on the front lines and got knocked down as NYPD and protestors shoved and fought over police barricades
156
139
20
625
29,186
As a Palestinian, I want more people to understand our history, our dispossession, our pain, and our right to live in freedom. Mamdani and Abdul are breaking stereotypes, shifting the conversation, and making Palestine impossible to ignore in American politics. We can criticize him. We can push him. We can disagree with him. But calling him a traitor because he doesn’t meet everyone’s ideological expectations? That’s not strategy. That’s shooting ourselves in the foot. We need to start asking ourselves: are we trying to win arguments, or win people?
A little outside my usual lane, but this needs to be said. 1/2 Since Abdul’s interview with Ezra Klein, I’ve watched parts of our movement go after him. On Wednesday, protesters chanted “traitor” at Zohran. I know I’ll be attacked for saying this, but I can’t stay quiet anymore while we turn on two of the most powerful advocates for Palestine in US politics. I think we’re missing the bigger picture. Zohran and Abdul are not only reaching millions of Americans outside our bubble, they're changing the way those Americans see Arabs and Muslims. For decades, Hollywood portrayed us as terrorists and religious extremists, a threat to the West. In Reel Bad Arabs, Jack Shaheen documented how Hollywood systematically depicted Arabs as villains across more than 900 films, and that was even before 9/11. I have no doubt that this dehumanization contributed enormously to the lack of empathy Palestinians received for decades. Now look at Abdul and Zohran. They're putting Arabs and Muslims in the middle of American political life as competent, principled American politicians, talking about healthcare, housing and the things that affect Americans' daily lives, without abandoning Palestine. A perfect example of that is Abdul's interviews on Fox. If you haven't seen them, I urge you to watch them before passing any further judgment. He was so compelling and so eloquent that even Jesse Watters, the Fox host, said afterward: “I like him. I don’t want to like him. I like him for some stupid reason.” And it's not just that. Zohran warned that Gaza was on the brink of genocide on October 13, 2023, and Abdul was calling it a genocide by October 21. Long before they became prominent political figures, they took enormous risks by challenging the boundaries of acceptable political discourse. And look how much those boundaries have shifted since. Without a doubt, Zohran taking that stance and winning in New York home to the largest Jewish community outside Israel was one of the biggest drivers of the broader shift we’re seeing within the Democratic Party. Kamala Harris, who many hate for denying and enabling the genocide in Gaza is now endorsing Abdul, who calls Gaza a genocide and wants to stop arms sales to Israel. If that isn't a win for the movement, what is? And yet instead of celebrating it, we're angry at Abdul for receiving her endorsement. Abdul did all this while also acknowledging the Jewish trauma from the Holocaust in his interview with Ezra Klein. Isn't that exactly what we've always wished politicians would do: represent all their constituents, including Jewish people, while refusing to compromise their moral principles? And that trauma is real for Jewish people. What we Palestinians hate is how Israel has used that trauma to justify our oppression and dispossession. Just to clarify: I don’t agree with everything they both say either. In the Ezra Klein interview, I wish Abdul had talked more about Palestinian trauma and what happened in 1948 as people don't understand it in the same way we all understand the trauma of the Holocaust. But why does the responsibility of explaining that fall solely on him? Yes, he could have done better, but so could we as a movement.
43
168
15
884
39,182
Hadas Thier retweeted
Victor Wembanyama, interrogé sur le mouvement lycéen en France (via @MaximeAubin1) : "Ce qui me touche, c'est que ce n'est pas quelque chose de totalement inconnu pour moi. J'étais au lycée à Nanterre, qui était déjà un bastion des blocus à l'époque. J'étais lycéen il n'y a pas si longtemps. J'ai eu la chance de m'extraire, c'est une situation que j'ai la chance de ne plus vivre. Ce sont des inégalités systémiques, des problèmes tellement profonds... Je suis content que les lycéens, les jeunes en général se fassent entendre, car je les entends et je les soutiens. Et j'espère que les gens qui sont tout là-haut en feront de même".
340
6,028
461
39,892
1,891,688
I am angry tonight. Because today ICE shot a New Yorker. They shot a New Yorker while his five year old child was in the car. ICE makes this city less safe. We want them out. Now.
33,927
59,971
2,457
394,961
8,157,426
I don’t understand what those protesters aim to accomplish! If Mamdani hangs a Sinwar poster at city hall, then what? What impact would that have? Was Nelson Mandela a “sellout” for acknowledging the suffering white Afrikaaners endured in concentration camps in the 2nd Boer War? Was Mandela a “traitor” for saying Afrikaners as a collective group were not put "in the accused dock" or held collectively guilty for the sins of apartheid? Attending a vigil for Israelis & Palestinians doesn’t mean capitulating, throwing Gaza under the bus, drawing false symmetries or covering up the genocide! Mamdani is still consistently speaking up about Israel's crimes & atrocities, & is trying to build a broad coalition to do something about those crimes. In coalition building, there's a difference between a comrade (with whom you agree 100%) & an ally (with whom you may agree on one or two issues & work together towards them). Saying "I would only work with comrades who fully agree with me" is the recipe for dooming your movement to remaining a tiny ineffective minority. The goal is to unite the many against the few, not the few against the many.
At an Oct. 7 vigil for Israelis and Palestinians organized by Israelis, a testimony from a Palestinian victim is read. Mamdani watches on as pro-Palestine protestors hold photos of Sinwar and scream “Mamdani you can’t hide, you’re committing genocide.”
118
213
47
1,238
82,749
If you’re a Mamdani booster, there’s nothing to be mad about here; if anything this helps cement his broad appeal as normal/relatable, vs “crazy” leftists. If you’re a leftist antizionist, though, this is frustrating and disappointing. Not because they’re being unfair to Zohran or whatever—but because there’s still so many on the left who clearly have no theory of power or change beyond “petition those who have power.” The archetype of The Radical that they hold in their minds—and which they seek to emulate—is the permanent outsider, the externalized (shaming, haranguing) conscience of those who can actually make decisions. Never the decision makers! Never the ones with power, but solely the beggar to power. Except the begging is disguised through performative hostility as if it were something else, a demand with real force behind it. But of course, there is no force, no leverage. It’s all kabuki—but the audience for the performance is, more than anyone, the performers themselves. If you think Zohran is a genocidaire, I think that’s nonsense, but honestly that doesn’t bother me *nearly* as much as that *this* kind of empty gesture is your response to something as profoundly horrifying as genocide. Can’t you build something better, bigger, stronger? At the minimum, you could primary him from the left in 2029! But if not, please come up with *something* other than these kinds of powerless acts of prostration, of begging, masquerading as demands. You can’t demand anything without power—if not electoral power, then find something else. But without power, it’s not a demand, but a plea. A whimper.
Lander is now speaking at the vigil while Mamdani looks on. The anti-Zionist protesters are chanting “Traitor”
111
263
45
2,926
149,387
Hadas Thier retweeted
Zohran Mamdani: “I believe there must be room to mourn every single life. There must be room to mourn the lives of the more than 1,100 Israelis that Hamas killed three years ago. There must be room to mourn the 74K Palestinians the Israeli government had killed since. What I so appreciated about being at the vigil yesterday evening, as I had been the year before, is that it was a vigil that brought together New Yorkers to read testimonies of their own family members, of others who’ve been killed either on the day or in the genocide since and ends with a shared vision for peace and for an end to the genocide”
697
4,433
890
46,650
3,430,734
100% agree. They’re not scaring mamdani away from Palestine, his politics are very clear. But they are scaring a lot of regular people who sympathize with Palestine and could have made up a broad and effective movement
He is JUST the fucking mayor. How much the hell do u expect him to do?! Stop this madness, ffs. He could’ve easily said NOTHING about Palestine or Israel, stuck to NYC issues, and honestly, nobody could blame him. That’s what a fucking mayor is supposed to focus on. But instead, he’s doing something almost NO American politician is willing to do: saying it loud, saying it clearly, and putting Palestine right at the fucking center of American political discussion. And this is how you respond?! WTF ARE u DOING? You’re attacking one of the very few politicians actually bringing Palestine into the mainstream and you’re making other politicians who might even consider speaking up think twice. At this rate, I honestly wouldn’t blame him if he woke up tomorrow and said, “Fuck this. I’m done with Palestine.” You’re not helping Palestine. You’re fucking scaring people away from it.
25
18
1
219
6,560
Hadas Thier retweeted
Something to note: This isn't the mayor's base turning on him. This is a faction of the left who have never believed in electoral politics, and who do not participate in Democratic Party politics. nitter.cf/C_Sommerfeldt/status/2…
Pro-Palestinian protesters gather outside City Hall to call out Mayor Zohran Mamdani for what they see as his betrayal of the movement. "Mayor Mamdani, you can't hide we charge you with genocide" was a chant that just rang out.
164
192
58
1,968
110,298
The stoic face of a man standing on the outrageous discipline that every innocent life is equal. Angering both the architects of Israeli genocide of Palestinians and the sub faction of the sub faction of activists who celebrate Iranian and Syrian dictators.
Mamdani is stone-faced as the protesters call him a traitor and sellout.
69
105
12
749
50,566
This day is profoundly painful for so many New Yorkers. It marks three years since the horrific war crimes of October 7. On that day, Hamas killed more than 1,100 Israelis and abducted 251 others. We grieve alongside our many friends and neighbors who still carry that unthinkable loss. The suffering did not begin nor end that day. It instead continued through the Israeli government’s devastating, ongoing genocide in Gaza, in which it has killed more than 74,000 Palestinians—including more than 21,000 children. Even since the so-called ceasefire, more than 1,400 Palestinians have been killed. That suffering has intensified with every Israeli bomb dropped on ambulances waiting outside hospitals, every drone strike targeting a residential building or journalist, and every shipment of food aid turned away at a border crossing. Many New Yorkers are reckoning with this unbearable grief, and we mourn alongside them – all while knowing that our tax dollars fund these war crimes. Three years later, we must refuse to accept a world in which occupation and apartheid continue, where war crimes are met with impunity, and our federal government continues its complicity with every arms shipment. To honor the dead, we must fight for a world in which every person can live with freedom, safety, and dignity.
27,011
16,242
7,740
175,093
23,951,172
Hadas Thier retweeted
One way these polls are gamed is, when Mamdani first ran, they asked respondents if they were Jewish. Now they ask if they are *religious* and if so what their religion is, and if they answer Jewish they are counted. This conveniently removes secular Jews from the polling sample
12
400
11
4,275
91,691
“I don’t know how families are making it right now.” Brooke Floyd told me, “It does make me think when I’m lying in bed at night, What are these babies eating?” In the fall issue of @HammerandHope with support from the @EconHardship Reporting Project. hammerandhope.org/article/me…
2
5
231
Hadas Thier retweeted
Issue 12 is LIVE! The American fascist front is — and has always been — on Black streets. But the plans are big enough to encompass almost everyone. Read here: hammerandhope.org
1
32
2
44
2,399
Hadas Thier retweeted
I’m sorry but this rhetoric is so ridiculous, toxic and harmful to the Palestinians.. Abdul and Zohran have both faced enormous political pressure over their positions on Israel and Palestine. Yet both have continued to articulate positions that have generated significant controversy rather than simply retreating from the subject That doesn’t make them infallible. It doesn’t mean Palestinians should stop scrutinising them. It means we should be capable of recognising what is happening without immediately turning on people who are standing in a difficult political arena and saying things many American politicians still refuse to say.
34
31
5
186
10,903
I'm a proud supporter of EWOC and you should be too! @organizeworkers is built by workers for workers. They're an amazing organization, and their annual donor drive is happening now. Help them reach their goal to raise another $2k per month! secure.actblue.com/donate/ew…
1
3
304