
Technologist, researcher & consultant; IoT, privacy & data protection, information policy, IDM & e-ID, US & EU policy analysis; founder of @IoTPrivacyForum
Barcelona, Spain
Joined December 2013
- Tweets2.9K
- Following1.5K
- Followers1.4K
- Likes1.4K
Pinned Tweet
I am proud to announce the publication of Clearly Opaque - Privacy Risks of the IoT, written by me & Erin Kenneally. It’s new empirical research on #IoTprivacy & governance, including emerging strategies to address the privacy challenges. Please share! iotprivacyforum.org/clearlyo…
Gilad Rosner retweeted
"Companies worth billions of dollars are, without permission, training generative AI models on creators’ works, which are then being used to create new content that in many cases can compete with the original works." – at Central Region, Singapore
I’ve resigned from my role leading the Audio team at Stability AI, because I don’t agree with the company’s opinion that training generative AI models on copyrighted works is ‘fair use’.
First off, I want to say that there are lots of people at Stability who are deeply thoughtful about these issues. I’m proud that we were able to launch a state-of-the-art AI music generation product trained on licensed training data, sharing the revenue from the model with rights-holders. I’m grateful to my many colleagues who worked on this with me and who supported our team, and particularly to Emad for giving us the opportunity to build and ship it. I’m thankful for my time at Stability, and in many ways I think they take a more nuanced view on this topic than some of their competitors.
But, despite this, I wasn’t able to change the prevailing opinion on fair use at the company.
This was made clear when the US Copyright Office recently invited public comments on generative AI and copyright, and Stability was one of many AI companies to respond. Stability’s 23-page submission included this on its opening page:
“We believe that Al development is an acceptable, transformative, and socially-beneficial use of existing content that is protected by fair use”.
For those unfamiliar with ‘fair use’, this claims that training an AI model on copyrighted works doesn’t infringe the copyright in those works, so it can be done without permission, and without payment. This is a position that is fairly standard across many of the large generative AI companies, and other big tech companies building these models — it’s far from a view that is unique to Stability. But it’s a position I disagree with.
I disagree because one of the factors affecting whether the act of copying is fair use, according to Congress, is “the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work”. Today’s generative AI models can clearly be used to create works that compete with the copyrighted works they are trained on. So I don’t see how using copyrighted works to train generative AI models of this nature can be considered fair use.
But setting aside the fair use argument for a moment — since ‘fair use’ wasn’t designed with generative AI in mind — training generative AI models in this way is, to me, wrong. Companies worth billions of dollars are, without permission, training generative AI models on creators’ works, which are then being used to create new content that in many cases can compete with the original works. I don’t see how this can be acceptable in a society that has set up the economics of the creative arts such that creators rely on copyright.
To be clear, I’m a supporter of generative AI. It will have many benefits — that’s why I’ve worked on it for 13 years. But I can only support generative AI that doesn’t exploit creators by training models — which may replace them — on their work without permission.
I’m sure I’m not the only person inside these generative AI companies who doesn’t think the claim of ‘fair use’ is fair to creators. I hope others will speak up, either internally or in public, so that companies realise that exploiting creators can’t be the long-term solution in generative AI.
I’m very happy to be chairing today’s @WhitehallMedia IDM Nordics conference in Stockholm! #wmidm #digitalidentity #biometrics
Gilad Rosner retweeted
A while back, I stumbled upon a file I consider the largest piece of evidence revealing how hundreds of data brokers trade personal data on everyone, including very sensitive data, globally.
Massive investigation by @themarkup and German @netzpolitik_org:
themarkup.org/privacy/2023/0…
Gilad Rosner retweeted
A Court in Argentina recently declared unconstitutional the Facial Recognition system used by the city of Buenos Aires to "identify" fugitives. One fascinating aspect of the decision? Privacy as a collective right! Read @MariaJoseBJ's analysis at the link below!
In our latest FPF Global blog, FPF's @MariaJoseBJ analyzes #BuenosAires’ Fugitive Facial Recognition System, a technology that was deemed unconstitutional by an administrative judge in #Argentina for its risks to #privacy and other fundamental rights. fpf.org/blog/judge-declares-…
Gilad Rosner retweeted
Replying to @hypervisible
Algorithm: there will be crime in this city.
Media: Really? When? Where?
Algorithm: next week. In the city.
Media: is this algorithm sentient?
Gilad Rosner retweeted
Cryptocurrency titan Coinbase providing “geo tracking data” to ICE interc.pt/3ys5pra by @samfbiddle
Gilad Rosner retweeted
this and other recent reversals of FRT bans are a reminder that regulatory wins aren't permanent. We need sustained organizing and pressure to expand these policies and prevent retraction.
Today, a new law in Virginia allowing local police to use face recognition goes into effect. This law, which reverses a previous ban on face recognition, does not adequately protect Virginians against the threat the technology poses.
wtvr.com/news/local-news/vir…
Gilad Rosner retweeted
Right now, and I mean this instant, delete every digital trace of any menstrual tracking. Please.
Gilad Rosner retweeted
Few interested in emo-tech will have missed Microsoft's announcement on Tuesday and the 'retiring' of emotion recognition due to the "Responsible AI Standard". Here's the Lab's take, authored by Andy:
emotionalai.org/news/2022/6/…
Gilad Rosner retweeted
🚨WE ARE HIRING! Do you want to work on #Law, #Diversity, #Robots, & #AI at @eLaw_Leiden @LeidenLaw at @UniLeiden? We have a #postdoc vacancy for 4 years in our group, please help us spread the word. Apply before 15 July following this link: universiteitleiden.nl/en/vac…
Gilad Rosner retweeted
Only a few weeks to go till this opportunity closes for a fees paid PhD studentship with the Law and Futures group at @NCLLawSchool whose work covers data, privacy, AI, IP, robots and more! Opportunities will also be there for paid tutoring. RT! ncl.ac.uk/postgraduate/fees-…
Amazing opportunities at America’s first DPA/ICO! Please share far and wide!
The CPPA is hiring!
We are looking for Attorneys, Legal Analysts, Legislative Specialists, Law Clerks, and Technologists!
Check out our Career Opportunities page for information and details on how to apply: cppa.ca.gov/about_us/jobs.ht…
1
Gilad Rosner retweeted
Verdict tomorrow.
Win or lose, it's a dark day for press freedom in the UK.
Singling out a journalist from their news organisation and putting them on trial is not what happens in healthy, functioning democracies.
theguardian.com/media/2022/j…
Gilad Rosner retweeted
Surveillance firm Palantir is set to become the ‘underlying operating system’ for the UK’s National Health Service. Given how valued NHS is by British public, this is getting precious little coverage. ft.com/content/3f6f24f8-9e5c…



















