This debate is fascinating. Some extra context: Henry played for the Titans for 8 seasons. He scored 23.23% of their total points and made the playoffs 3 times. Hany has played for Nashville for 7 seasons. He's scored 27.36% of their total goals and made the playoffs 6 times.

Braden Gall@BradenGallOct 15

Who is the greatest professional athlete in Nashville history? These are likely the only four Hall of Famers we’ve had. McNair only other one worth considering and clearly not HOF.

1%Roman Josi

17%Pekka Rinne

41%Derrick Henry

40%Hany Mukhtar

1,047 votes • Final results

110

8,236

Ben Wright · Oct 15, 2026 · 12:53 AM UTC

Finn retweeted

Ben Wright@benwrightOct 15

I was reliably informed Hany Mukhtar was washed... 🤔

195

7,231

mls reactions · Oct 15, 2026 · 12:51 AM UTC

Finn retweeted

mls reactions

@mlsreactsOct 15

Customary Mukhtar is still good at soccering tweet.

1,784

Trav · Oct 13, 2026 · 9:00 PM UTC

Finn retweeted

Trav@effzehNSCOct 13

The Nashville SC community is probably the only reason I haven’t left this app completely. Nothing else beats it. #EveryoneN

117

2,472

EdgarNAGs 🇺🇲🇳🇮 · Oct 13, 2026 · 4:30 PM UTC

Finn retweeted

EdgarNAGs 🇺🇲🇳🇮@EdgarNAGsOct 13

A huge shout-out to @FinNSC_, who covers Nashville SC, for sharing stats about the nature of bookings across MLS--which players and teams get the most cards, and why. LA Galaxy fans will be surprised to see it's Jakob Glesnes--not Carlos Garcés--who leads LAG in total bookings.

4,821

mls reactions · Oct 12, 2026 · 7:54 PM UTC

Finn retweeted

🚨🗣 Olivier Giroud on the MLS: "On the football front, it wasn't really for me. For me, the United States is not a football country." Did Giroud expose the MLS? 🇺🇸😱

2,321

mls reactions · Oct 12, 2026 · 5:13 PM UTC

Finn retweeted

mls reactions

@mlsreactsOct 12

Personally, I don't think it's really up for debate. BJ Callaghan is coach of the year. Doesn't take anything away from Damet or Richter, but when you look at the season in its entirety I don't see how it's even debatable.

Denzell@Denzell_Of_NSHOct 12

We’ve been the best team for most of the season, we could break a season points record, beat CLUB AMERICA at the AZTECA. Eliminated MESSI from an INTERNATIONAL competition??? How is it not BJ Callaghan for Coach of the Year??

1,525