Stuart (SSRI taperer) (@FarewellSSRI) header
Stuart (SSRI taperer) (@FarewellSSRI) profile picture

I recovered from acute SSRI withdrawal. I'm here for the people who haven't - yet. Tapering slowly, for people who like to compare notes. DMs welcome.

Dublin, Ireland
Joined June 2025
Stuart (SSRI taperer) retweeted
"When You Can’t Win on the Science, Attack the Scientist - Jack Goulder, @joannamoncrieff and the politics of personality." Out now 👇
🤖 Made with AI
1
4
6
196
When Awais says "it's embarrassing" he's expressing his own discomfort with what other people are saying. That he wishes others felt embarrassment at what they're saying - when they don't - is a curious admission, especially for a mental health professional.
2
8
238
In any case, if this is what passes for professional discourse in the field of psychiatry, well ... good luck, patients.
3
26
Stuart (SSRI taperer) retweeted
Replying to @awaisaftab
“In 2026, to publicly doubt that antidepressants work at all is, frankly, embarrassing.” What exactly do you mean by ‘work’ in this context? That’s a rather important distinction. Do you mean they reduce scores on depression questionnaires, suppress certain emotional responses or make someone feel less distressed? Or do you mean they genuinely restore someone’s ability to experience happiness, love, connection, motivation and a fulfilling life? If someone takes an antidepressant and becomes so emotionally blunted that they struggle to feel love for their own family, lose their ability to experience joy from music, nature and relationships and feel disconnected from their own identity (arguably some of the most fundamental parts of being human) but simultaneously find themselves less emotionally affected by losing their job or experiencing personal hardship, would you consider that a successful outcome? We need to move beyond the simplistic argument that because a drug produces a measurable change in certain symptoms it must therefore be working in any meaningful sense. There’s a world of difference between a statistical improvement on a clinical rating scale and a genuine improvement in someone’s quality of life. We should also be asking how much benefit is attributable to the drug itself, how durable that benefit is, how many people experience little or no meaningful improvement and what adverse effects they’re expected to tolerate. In 2026, surely the embarrassing position is psychiatry refusing to have a more honest and nuanced discussion about what ‘working’ actually means, who these drugs help, who they harm and what people are expected to sacrifice in the process.
7
15
4
61
1,917
Stuart (SSRI taperer) retweeted
"I don’t just think antidepressants are overprescribed, I’m not convinced they’re useful at all. Antidepressants don’t rectify a chemical imbalance or any other biological process, as people were led to believe; they numb emotions" "The question is, is this useful, and how harmful are they?" 👇 telegraph.co.uk/health-fitne…
43
111
26
360
48,611
Stuart (SSRI taperer) retweeted
The Chemical Imbalance Myth: What Jack Goulder Gets Wrong I've read the recent Substack article by Jack Goulder entitled Merchants of Psychiatric Doubt and the subsequent exchanges with Dr Horowitz. First of all, I think it was poor judgment of Goulder to misquote Horowitz and Moncrieff, particularly when that quotation was central to his accusation that they had misrepresented their research. More fundamentally, though I think his dismissal of Horowitz's argument as "semantic somersaults" overlooks an important historical distinction. Contrary to the impression given in the article, the chemical imbalance theory was not simply a marketing narrative seized upon by drug companies. It was actively promoted and legitimised by influential figures within institutional medicine, particularly psychiatry. Until relatively recently, the NHS reproduced versions of this explanation on its websites, and as recently as 2025, Rebecca Brendel, a former president of the American Psychiatric Association, was publicly linking low serotonin with depression in the Washington Post. Psychiatry itself helped establish the credibility of this narrative, and the profession's role in promoting it deserves serious historical scrutiny. This matters because the chemical imbalance theory was not merely an abstract scientific hypothesis. It fundamentally shaped how depression was understood by the public, how SSRIs were presented to patients, and potentially how people made decisions about treatment. Millions of people were given the impression, by psychiatrists, GPs and medical journalism, that SSRIs corrected an underlying chemical deficiency. That is a very different proposition from telling patients that these drugs alter brain chemistry in ways we do not fully understand, that their average benefits over placebo are relatively modest, and that they carry risks. The chemical imbalance narrative also had important implications for long term prescribing. If patients believed they had an underlying serotonin deficiency, it was entirely reasonable for them to conclude that they might need medication indefinitely, just as someone with diabetes might require insulin. Whether and to what extent that belief contributed to long term prescribing deserves investigation, but it is hardly a trivial question. In other words, the theory that depression results from low serotonin played an important role in legitimising the widespread use of SSRIs, including their long term use. We now know that this explanation was not supported by the evidence. It is therefore entirely reasonable to say that research challenging the serotonin hypothesis also calls into question one of the principal historical rationales offered for prescribing these drugs. It is true that this is not the same as claiming that SSRIs have been demonstrated to be ineffective. Whether a drug produces a clinically meaningful benefit is a separate empirical question from whether it corrects the biological abnormality it was purportedly prescribed to treat. The is a substantive difference not a semantic one. It also raises important questions about informed consent. Patients are entitled to accurate explanations of why a treatment is being recommended, not simply evidence that it may produce some benefit. What I find particularly striking about the article is that Goulder devotes considerable attention to the philosophical commitments of psychiatry's critics, while giving comparatively little scrutiny to the professional and institutional commitments that helped sustain the chemical imbalance narrative for decades. If his concern is how prior beliefs and institutional interests shape the interpretation and communication of scientific evidence, surely that scrutiny should apply equally to mainstream psychiatry. One can reasonably argue that the serotonin hypothesis has no direct bearing on the evidence from antidepressant efficacy trials. But it does not follow that discrediting the hypothesis has no bearing on the historical justification for prescribing these medications, or on the decisions patients made after being told they suffered from a chemical imbalance. To characterise that distinction as "semantic" is, I think, to fundamentally miss the point of why setting the record straight about the chemical imbalance story matters so much.
5
22
3
59
4,890
Rhetorical question. How can you “eliminate” an illness discovered through research and diagnosed through scientifically valid tests?
I wanted to eliminate Antisocial Personality Disorder from DSM-IV because it confuses being a terrible person with being mentally ill. Most mentally ill are very nice people who suffer/dont cause suffering. Other reasons: l)Untreatable 2)Used as excuse 3)Medicalizes cruelty
4
4
1
12
482
Millions of people who have already run this study on themselves would be happy to share their findings.
A new study funded by the Wellcome Trust will take people off antidepressants over 4 weeks and will measure serotonin levels (using a brain scan following tryptophan depletion) to predict who will relapse. There are 9 measures of relapse or mood symptoms. There are no measures of withdrawal. pradam.org
4
7
37
1,269
The prosecution says he knew what he was doing was wrong. The defence says he did not, so he’s not guilty. The two psychiatrists agree on the diagnosis but disagree on what it means. Why aren’t they following the science instead of giving opinions? (2/3)
1
7
170
If there’s no scientific backing to whether he knew what he was doing, why are they claiming to know? Thought experiment: which one is spreading stigma, the prosecution’s psychiatrist or the defence’s? (3/3)
1
6
86
He claims 37k clinical hours, or an average of 44 minutes per patient. So the question might be has he kept up with ANY of them.
Have you kept up with all 50K people to see if they are still "cured"? You are aware that when a person killed themselves during medical trials, it was regularly reported as "did not finish trial", right?
13
548
Another of these “I’ve treated 50k patients” types. Even if he’s been practicing 30 years, he would have seen each of these patients for minutes. Some admission.
Severe depression can be a terminal illness and SSRIs can offer a cure and prevent suicide. I’ve only treated over 50k patients but sure listen to random people on X
3
4
42
1,575
It’s only 18 months since an actual practicing medical doctor suggested my “belief” that SSRIs can be harmful as well as helpful may be an indicator of psychosis.
The MHRA is introducing a series of new measures to strengthen how risks associated with antidepressant medicines are communicated to patients, carers and healthcare professionals. Read the full drug safety update here: brnw.ch/21x6qlr
8
26
3
125
4,372
Stuart (SSRI taperer) retweeted
If people weren’t led to believe that the mental health field was vastly more scientific and technically robust than it really is, they would probably navigate their challenges VERY differently. This is part of why the dishonesty here is so problematic.
6
13
58
1,125
In spite of all advice to the contrary, I'm having a beer before going out for dinner (I probably won't have any more alcohol at dinner). In the first 6 months of withdrawal, I cold-turkeyed coffee (a very significant action) and alcohol (less significant) (1/2)
3
8
895
When I was 80-90% 'stable' (one month before starting tapering) I restarted coffee and even the odd beer. Wine and whiskey used to be a hobby - I haven't gone back to these. The appeal is just gone. Just want to be transparent about my tapering. Definitely not advice! (2/2)
1
5
193