Pinned Tweet
Finally saw the Odyssey.
It’s not Homer’s odyssey. It’s “the Odyssey as filtered and retold by the whole Western canon.”
Everything’s in there. The original core, then the Latin dark Ulysses, then a Christian moral message.
And finally, modern historiography about the Bronze Age collapse.
And it’s arguably necessary. I’m currently spending a lot of time with Homer’s story, and I think it’s extraordinary.
But Homer’s Odysseus doesn’t have to have much guilt over Troy. if modern audiences are going to be asked to process the sack of Troy, you kind of have to make it problematic, which immediately starts pushing you to Virgil’s interpretation.
So, Nolan’s Odyssey actually manages to make you feel the moral impact of every major crime in Greek mythology that touches on the story, and also resolve it at the end with Odysseus staying the hero.
Also, something I haven’t seen talked about much…he’s chaste. Nothing sexual with Circe (although she reverses the dagger moment and keeps it at his throat), and there’s no sex scene with Calypso. Calypso falls in love with him, but it’s implied he’d forgotten everything, including his family. So if they had sex, you can read Odysseus as remaining faithful to Penelope.
Telemachus was fine-to-good. His ending royal costume is really stupid. But his arc is handled well, and he’s portrayed with a lot of intelligence. He does in fact learn quickly, and he learns the key lessons Homer wants him to learn.
I’ve heard a complaint that Telemachus is demoted and doesn’t do anything in the fight, but that’s not true. He plays a key role physically, while also being deliberately kept clean from spilling the blood of any suitors.
This is important, and also solves the exile problem. Odysseus leaves, ending the blood guilt-cycle. In the poem, Homer can solve it with Athena’s direct intervention, which isn’t possible here.
That all worked to good satisfaction. And it gives you Odysseus sailing off again beyond Gibraltar.
Only thing which really didn’t work was the finale fight. Which was just awfully choreographed. Just absolutely lame, and does not give Odysseus a grand heroic reveal. He staggers around still wearing his beggar outfit awkwardly, and the suitors take way too long to gang up on him. Totally lame.
Penelope was excellent. And her “why can’t I be king speech” was not a simple feminist rage complaint. She literally ends by saying she wants Odysseus.
The Sea Peoples and Bronze Age collapse was occasionally clunky. Too much was given to dialogue here. It really needed a random group of pirates somewhere that wasn’t just Odysseus’ crew. This was a “show don’t tell” moment.
But, history nerds shouldn’t complain. We got the Bronze Age systematic collapse! Aegean trade routes, war bands, material collapse, loss of literacy and oral poetry. You can say it was a little too-telegraphed, but it was also Nolan really wanting to jam it in for the historical context. He might as well have dated the flashbacks to Troy as “back in 1177 BC.” Don’t complain!
Sets and armor. Some really bad. Annoyingly so. Circe tells Odysseus he looks like a lord. Sure couldn’t tell myself.
But I think the movie is deliberately doing a rehashing/genre mashup with callbacks to golden age Hollywood costumes and movies. It also fits the “there is no one set aesthetic, because the Odysseus is inherently something that gets retold.”
Oh. Helen and Clytemnestra are from Egypt. It’s fine. And Aegean maritime peoples would have more genetic diversity than we might assume.
Only final complaints are that we didn’t get “Nobody,” and we didn’t get the bed test.
Oh, Pylos was awesome. Whole scene.l was really cool. More weird ancient religion please.
1
8
591
This is a really good tweet.
This just looks ridiculous because if you want to LARP you need to go all in.
Putin talks about "Third Rome" but is dressed like some random Western politician.
If he really believed all of this he should have appeared dressed as a 16th century boyar, or maybe as a Romanov tsar, put on a lavish feast and invoke deep religious Orthodox Christian mysticism in his conversation with the journalist.
Instead he looks and talks like a modern Westerner and just inserts some random local historic curiosity that people in the West might not be familiar with. He is not actually challenging the West on some cultural level or trying to make a case why Russia is supposed to be on some different spiritual path.
This shows that even leaders who are politically anti-West are still culturally Westerners and adhere to specific modern Western concepts of "seriousness" in politics.
3
Watched this clip, and then watched the whole interview. Really excellent.
Palmer Luckey is just really impressive. And extremely lucid. Also steelmanned some of the best possible libertarian arguments along the way
You can literally see Andrew Ross Sorkin sink in his chair as he realizes Palmer Luckey is going to dismantle everything his political party believes about Ukraine, Elon Musk and Donald Trump
2
89
As a charter school teacher who happens to have a Master level TIA designation…
Vouchers seem likely to be the big political fight, along with teacher pay again. If they raise the basic allotment, charter teachers probably do ok.
Leadership turnover at the TEA probably means far fewer new charters, and a lot more strutting of existing ones.
Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa tells @TexasTribune she wants the state to "transition away" from the Teacher Incentive Allotment, which provides additional pay to teachers based on performance.
Instead, she wants "a compensation model that is really applying to all Texas teachers."
2
129
This is the way
"Did you actually make a Christian alternative to GTA?"
Yes. Yes we did. The trailer is out now and the game will be available tomorrow if the world doesn't end before then.
"Is it as good or as fun as the original?"
No, of course not. It's a Christian alternative. But it exists, and that's all God expects or requires of us -- to make Christian alternatives to things that lead with an obnoxiously strong message instead of a good story, graphics, or gameplay.
2
141
All true and valid. And yet at the same time:
The show is leaning into Gandalf as the servant of the Secret Fire.
Plus, holy Moses. Literally.
It’s weird how ROP is both often clumsy in its execution, while also simultaneously the most theologically serious adaptation of Tolkien ever put onscreen.
I wasn’t a huge fan of amnesia Gandalf, but since they went that route, it makes sense that he needs the lore dump.
I wish they’d bring Nienna in somehow though. She taught Olorin the virtue of pity.
People who know Tolkien's world understand why this is so absurd.
First of all, this never happened in the books. Secondly, Eru is incredibly hands off when it comes to the happenings in Arda.
Want to know how many times he's directly intervened in the affairs of Arda from the beginning of the 2nd age to the end of the 3rd age? Twice. In 6,462 years, he's been directly involved in events twice:
The first time when Numenor was drowned, due to Manwë calling upon Ilúvatar and the Valar temporarily relinquishing their governance of Arda.
The second time when Frodo failed at the Crack of Doom. Check out Tolkien letter 192.
Even during a grievous error (the Valar bringing the Elves to Valinor) Ilúvatar did not intervene. (Letter 211)
2
188
Caligula was a horrible tyrant to Rome’s senators, but if you were a random farmer in Gaul…Caligula would have a tough time oppressing you even if he knew you existed.
Very true
In the past it was informal, local, variegated, and idiosyncratic
Today it is formalized, global, uniform, and rote bureaucratic
1
15
455
I bet the worst centers started 1-2 years ago, and the next round being built this year mostly have mitigations and financial incentives for residents. But the positives will take time to work through the system.
Problem was probably most fixed before the election.
181
And the Vandal sack, which stripped the roof off the Temple to Jupiter Optimus Maximums, and carried off the treasure from the Jewish Temple taking in 70 AD…
Came from North Africa. From Carthage. And the loss of North Africa’s agriculture and tax revenue really crippled the empire.
Down in the afterlife, Hannibal probably laughed. He’d invaded Italy from the North, and now a people from the North attacked Rome from Carthage.
If the ghost of Hannibal was hovering over the scene, and had been granted a terrible boon by Apollo, he might have told his companion the shade of Scipio Africanus that his city’s victory was more total than any achieved in the world since the creation, and that Rome’s imperivm would hold the Mediterranean in its grasp for 6 centuries in an unbroken chain.
But then, when the Doom came for Rome, its people would be so dissipated that a foreign cult would extinguish the eternal flame and scatter the Vestal Virgins to the four winds in the name of the Roman people themselves, and that when a short generation later a savage host descended on the city from the northern wastes the city would fall without its men even trying to defend it.
Thus even in death are entwined the two great rivals. The golden city pf trade which made of itself an economic zone would fight valiantly and to the last with every last scrap of steel and drop of blood, while the iron city of valour which conquered the world for its people would roll over and try to buy its safety in coin before meekly submitting.
lol, the second photo is definitely not highland park. Would’ve even have an above-ground pool for their dog
Smoked fish-sauce chicken breasts for my 3rd graders Roman party last week.
Marinade with asian fish-sauce, red vinegar, and olive oil. Honey, garlic, pepper, coriander.
Smoked with charcoal and cherry wood.
Vinegar makes the chicken incredibly tender.
The Romans used fermented fish sauce with every dish. There is a good chance that Roman cuisine resembled modern southeast Asian cuisine
1
98
Gruntled History Teacher retweeted
Tolstoy does him one better: Tolstoy depicts happiness.
This is extremely hard to do. It is very easy to draw false profundity from suffering and sorrow. It is very hard to depict ordinary goodness and happiness with any depth, insight, or grandeur.
Unfortunately, if you reflexively side against every modern historiographic innovation, you’ll end up wrong on the few key load-bearing points where modern academic history is probably right.
Not every historiographic innovation is the debunking of an old primary source.
Historians used to discount Procopius’ account of the Plague of Justinian, but he was probably telling the truth. But if 30-40% of the Mediterranean died in Late Antiquity, that probably significantly changes how we should think about the old Gibbonesque understanding of the Fall of Rome.
Wow, no one could have possibly predicted that late-20th century “historiography” would be less accurate than the ancient sources that they hate so much.
6
372
Great video with a hidden lesson about institutions iterating over time.
It’s not that the Romans were inherently smarter than modern Africans, as is being implied here. For centuries the Roman army took raw recruits with just as little (or less) education, and trained them to build the best bridges in the world.
And the video gives you an intuitive sense of how much institutional knowledge was built up over centuries, with each little improvement remember and passed on. No one engineer ever came close to figuring this all out.
You can take any illiterate peasant in world history and train them to make something great, but it requires a bunch of boring-but-necessary “upstream” (heh) conditions:
You need some sort of stable institutional coherence to learn, remember, and pass along lessons.
You need time to plan for the future and be sure you can reap the gains of your labor. You resort to floating a barrel when it’s just not worth it otherwise.
You either need a competent authority above you, or, paradoxically, no authority above you, so you can do it yourself.
A bad authority, or a nominal authority that doesn’t actually do anything, is probably what creates these failure-of-the-commons situation nine times out of ten.
Humans respond to incentives and institutional structure. Fix those, and a lot of things which people snidely label with insults will suddenly disappear.
This quoted post is unavailable.
2
173
Gruntled History Teacher retweeted
Replying to @pugnacious_polk @GarrettPetersen
“I think data centers will be capable of nuking my job, so I’m voting against them” doesn’t prevent a Chinese data center from nuking your job
Gruntled History Teacher retweeted
Hello I’ve committed voter fraud and I’d like to turn myself in.
I illegally voted for James Talarico dozens of time using fake identities.
My name is Brian Schottenheimer and I’m the head coach of the Dallas Cowboys. Please arrest me and force me to resign 🙏
Public execution is also an option.
Gruntled History Teacher retweeted
Replying to @StFrancisDallas
@StFrancisDallas as a newly constructed church, circa 1960.
Given how many people commute to or are otherwise dependent upon DC’s economy, the district already directly impacts the election of 4 senators.
You should actually quintuple the size of DC, in order to not warp the political representation of MD and VA.
As a 13-year resident of Washington, DC, I have just one question:
Why shouldn't Washington, DC, be a state?
Why should the 690,000 DC residents not have the same rights and representation as the rest of our fellow American citizens?
50




























