So…AI promised all this productivity boost locally, but what we got was acceleration for offshoring.
1
28
Esh retweeted
There was a time in the ancient past when the breeding population of human beings was something like 1000 people worldwide.
We are as perfectly capable of wiping ourselves out with sharpened rocks as we are with AI or nukes, because the real weapon is mankind himself.
Esh retweeted
let's not forget that nearly 30% of respondents in this infamous poll said nightclubs should be permanently closed down regardless of covid-19 and nearly 20% supported a permanent 10pm curfew. "the public" should be ignored.
Esh retweeted
Many years ago, while researching a paper on U.S. monetary policy, I read the testimony before Congress of several extremely prominent economists during the 1960s and 1970s.
I was somewhat saddened to discover that they did not follow standard stabilization principles. When the economy was weak, they recommended expansionary fiscal and monetary policy (the right advice in that scenario). But when the economy was booming, they never supported contractionary fiscal and monetary policy (also the right advice in that situation) because they did not want to “kill the expansion.”
No, sorry. If you want to manage aggregate demand (and I believe we should), you need to understand that this is a balancing act and, even more importantly, that fiscal policy has to be sustainable. Keynes himself was extremely clear about this. Gösta Rehn (1913–1996) and Rudolf Meidner (1914–2005) were even clearer: the government should run a surplus on average to have enough fiscal space to respond to large shocks (wars, financial crises, etc.). It is precisely because we care about those most vulnerable in society that you want to run a surplus. The cries against “austerity” are nearly always a mix of demagoguery and irresponsibility.
I suspect that many of those who defend Keynes most ardently in the public debate are the ones who least appreciate how good an economist he was.
I went to see last night “The Standard of Living”, the play now in London about John Maynard Keynes’s life, and I really enjoyed it. It captures well his life and the times. However I disagree with an important part of the economics, a confusion that is behind the entire economic policy debate in Britain and the rest of Europe today: the confusion between Beveridge and Keynes.
The report by William Beveridge (an LSE economist and ex-director) led to an enormous expansion of the welfare state. That is often confused (also in the play) with Keynes’s views, as if the large and continuously growing post-war welfare state had anything to do with demand stabilization.
Keynesian demand management is what Andrés Velasco (also an LSE prof), as Finance Minister in Chile, did during the 2000s copper boom: he ran surpluses of 7% of GDP and more in 2006 and 2007 and put the money in a stabilization fund abroad. This was 12% of GDP by the end of 2008, when public debt was 4% of GDP. Public sector workers burned his effigy in Santiago asking for it to be spent. When the copper price collapsed along with the global economy, this surplus allowed him to introduce a massive stimulus package worth 2.8% of GDP, larger relative to the economy than the American one, which allowed him to stabilize Chile’s economy through the financial crisis. “Being a Keynesian means being one in both parts of the cycle,” he told The Economist. Today, very few governments are doing this. It is “whatever it takes” in crisis, and “welfare is untouchable” when the crisis finishes. This leads to a continuous ratchet up of spending that strangles any productive activity.
Keynes was in favour of using debt to stimulate demand, but under no circumnstances to finance permanent welfare spending. He wanted an ordinary budget for the state and then a capital budget that would be used for the demand management and that would be invested only in productive capacity. While Beveridge was about social redistribution, an issue of social policy, Keynes was about stabilization. The play and a lot of commentary seem to conflate both things and use demand management to justify permanent structural social policy.
I think this is pretty instructive for what’s happening in the UK and in the rest of Europe today. There is a widespread confusion that it’s neoliberalism which is hollowing out the state, when in fact the UK’s public spending burden is at around 45.6% of GDP this year, and the OBR expects it to stay around 45% for ten years running, the longest sustained period of spending this high since the Second World War; EU governments spend 49.5% of GDP (Eurostat, 2025). Outside wartime and the pandemic, the state has never been this large for this long. Neither neoliberalism nor austerity is at fault for the lack of investment.
Governments cannot hit the fiscal rules without touching the triple lock, and other welfare entitlements (free transport for the over 60s here in London!) that most MPs consider untouchable. What gets cut all the time to make the numbers add up is infrastructure, energy, grids, R&D, innovation, etc. The UK’s gross fixed capital formation is at 18-19% of GDP, which is the lowest in the G7, and the general government investment is also behind the OECD average.
The debate misunderstands the risk of pension sustainability. It is not that at some point in the future pensions become unsustainable. It is that today, their relentless growth eliminates the space to invest in infrastructure, innovation and the rest. Sadly, no party dares to make this argument. And even economists who defend the entrepreneurial or innovative state cannot bring themselves to state the obvious: that there is a huge opportunity cost in having one of every 5 new cars sold in the UK being paid by the state as a disability benefit, or in having free transport for all over 60 year olds.
This was me at university.
Conciseness was replaced with word minimums and elaboration of concept.
Watching my sons learn to write has explained a lot about why good writing is rare. They're both convinced they have to produce bloated word salad when writing essays in school, and that if they wrote simply and clearly they'd get bad grades. The sad thing is they may be right.
25
Esh retweeted
Quite possibly the best app I’ve created yet, create drainage and profile views anywhere there is data using USGS Lidar. Try it: senterfarms.com/programs/csr…
This but also any conversation about climate.
There was a time the scientists f’ed it up. Now we have degrees in science communication.
It was marketed as:
- 2 years until permanent underclass
- you’ll all lose your jobs
- your skills will be worthless
- we’re going to replace you
- your entire career is now a $20/month subscription
All in an already terrible job market btw. Possibly the most important technology humanity has ever built, with some of the worst marketing imaginable. The labs completely failed communicating the tech, miserably bad and only improved just end of last year. How did anyone expect that to make people excited?
82
Looking backwards, policy packages seemed to be wrapped up in giving organisations money via ‘grant’ rather than legitimate reform.
This biases towards incumbents who have the resources to navigate.
18
Esh retweeted
remember how i was telling you alienation from labor, materials, how things are made in a purely service economy swirling with fake images would make people question even recently built objects, yeah:
Golden gate bridge.
Main cable weighs 3100 pounds per foot.
How could they have possibly handled that?
Total length of galvanized steel wire used in both main cables is 80,000 mi (129,000 km).
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Golden Gate Bridge main cables were spun in place wire-by-wire from thin strands over catwalks, not lifted or handled as complete heavy units. The cited specs match official bridge records.
goldengate.org/exhibits/spinn…
goldengate.org/exhibits/cross…
goldengate.org/exhibits/facts…
People probably have a reasonable understanding of how things work.
The ‘talking heads’ come in with authoritative voices and make grandiose statements with low accuracy and thus pull our perception off.
17
Esh retweeted
The problem is not just that these hired managers are from outside. They're also a different kind of person. As one founder put it, "their loyalty is to their career, not to the company."
There’s a certain frustration, I need to find a word for it, where the tax office calls you and says “we don’t believe your company exists”
“What research led you to that conclusion?”
“I googled you and information was thin”
“Sure. Did you check ASIC records?”
“No”
🤬
25
We never truly created structural restoration after 2008
what’s shocking is how few ppl realize how much of modern culture & behavior was almost entirely shaped by zirp, debt, & basically free money.
when that fully unwinds the adjustment is going to be brutal. ppl have to go from an abundance mindset to suddenly realizing oh shit a lot of this was never actually sustainable. & now this might happen before ai super growth.
imagine austerity in america, there would be riots because american pain tolerance below zero.
1
58
“Primate social intelligence is self-serving and unconstrained by moral scruples. Monkeys and apes often attempt to deceive each other, while constantly on guard against deception themselves. It’s theorised that resistance blocks the evolution of their signalling systems”
29
Esh retweeted
real tragedy for a capable 9to5 employee is that they never get to experience a thriving environment where intelligence and the ability to produce above ordinary output are cherished and rewarded. there is something tragic about spending your life working with incompetent people
Esh retweeted
🚨 At the U20 Mayors Summit, Mamdani Says the Left Has Ceded “Quality of Life,” “Efficiency,” and “Fraud and Waste” to the Right
This was one of the more interesting arguments Zohran Mamdani made today at the U20 Mayors Summit, and a reminder that he can be genuinely sharp when he drops the “central casting” routine.
“In New York City, there are certain words that have taken on ideological associations.”
“Quality of life has come to be seen as somehow a right-wing concern. Efficiency… has been taken on as a right-wing concern, rooting out fraud and waste, a right-wing concern.”
Mamdani’s argument is that refusing to engage those issues actually helps the Right.
“If you are staring at an example of social disorder or social inefficiency, and the left refuses to explain either why it has happened or how they will fix it, then the right gets to point at someone in the immediate area and say, ‘That’s who did it.’”
The harder question is how much of the broader Left is actually prepared to follow the advice.
Esh retweeted
99% of people would agree to be sedated and stacked like cordwood if they could save 25% on a flight, this is all the consumer’s fault
Legitimately astounded by airline companies’ greed at this point. It’s getting ridiculous — declining quality in every department and increasing costs across the board. (It has been proven that they deliberately decrease seat size, legroom, & overhead space year-to-year).
@AmericanAir — What is this? I’m not 8 feet tall. I’m 6’5 & 192lbs and I can no longer fit in an economy seat or your lavaratories.
We need a nationalized or publicly-owned airline, modeled after Amtrak, to introduce competition back into the market in quality and pricing. It’s the only way to incentivize these greedy executives to stop bleeding customers, who have no choice but to rely on these corporations for travel, dry for objectively awful experiences.





























