Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy) header
Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy) profile picture

Assoc Prof @mcgillu @schulichmusic / Musician, writer, lecturer / Thoughts on art, aesthetics, epistemology / author, MOZART THE PERFORMER @UChicagoPress

Montréal
Joined November 2015
Photo by Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy)Photo by Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy)Photo by Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy)Photo by Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy)Photo by Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy)Photo by Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy)Photo by Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy)Photo by Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy)Photo by Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy)Photo by Dorian K Bandy (@DorianKBandy)
I'm so happy to see this CD out in the world, just in time for Mozart's birthday. An experimental take on his String Duos inspired by my book. Featuring ornaments, historical arrangements, and @catherinecosbey Link below! @MozartCircleCN @schulichmusic @UChicagoPress @mcgillu
4
4
2
24
2,223
Martin Amis: "Money" In my early 20s it seemed like pure slapstick and farce; in my mid 30s I discovered that after the first hundred or so pages it becomes one of the most profound, poetic, redemptive artworks I've ever encountered.
What’s a book you love that was even better at second reading?
1
1
5
703
It's true in theory that if Beethoven can be wrong, there must be objective aesthetic criteria of some kind. I love @ernsterlanson 's argument. But in practice it's complicated Finding a 'mistake' in Beethoven could just mean that we misunderstood what he's up to. 1/
In Beethoven's sonata, opus 2 no. 1, there is a mistake in most editions in bar 76. The first note should be a Bb flat instead of Db flat. Otherwise, it violates the sequence that is set up starting from bar 73.
1
3
301
Yes, if his goal is to do a simple sequence, a deviation is wrong. But what if his goal is to set up a sequence and then deviate? Empiricism is false; the artwork doesn't give an answer itself. 2/
1
105
Otherwise known as...chess?
2
9
359
Academic writing was livelier and so much more fun half a century ago. A hilarious (and true) paragraph by Robin Winks, c.1969, on evidence, observation, and the philosophy of history:
4
191
Delighted that @strohltopia 's new book has made it to Montreal. Can't wait to dig in!
4
191
The text is structured like a theme and variations, with each chapter examining a different way in which Mozart's experience and priorities as a performer helped shape his written music.
2
8
555
Other random Smith observations from today: 1) True to form given his interest in science, in Wealth of Nations Ch 1 he repeatedly emphasizes that appearances and intuition are misleading. Also, despite his empiricism, he invokes the unseen in his explanations right from page 1.
1
294
2) He seems pretty Cartesian in his assumptions about animals in Chapter 2. I don't think he's wrong...! 3) He ascribes agent-like properties to our intuitions about other people's needs and desires. (cf. the opening of Chapter 3).
198
Today I mused a bit about the role of sympathy and imagination in book 1, chapters 1-3 of Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations, ahead of next week's grad seminar session. dorianbandy.blogspot.com/202…
1
219
I'm obviously not the first person to take a swipe at the supposed "Adam Smith Problem" (i.e. the apparent gap between the sympathy-loving Smith of the Theory of Moral Sentiments and the pro-self-interest Smith of WN). But from what I can tell...
1
187
Favorite books I've read or reread in 2023. A thread. 📖🧵 (My go-to genres are literary fiction, poetry, and a blend of academic and trade nonfiction, some for work and some not.) The books I post here are those that stood out as exceptionally good - all highly recommended.
1
4
934
Started in late 2022, finished early 2023: a reread of Elizabeth Bowen, "The House in Paris". I'm on a Bowen kick, and every time I read her I like her even more. Lovely prose and amazing psychological portraiture.
1
237
After hearing many academics talk about trying to prevent the use of #ChatGPT in their classes (often, I'll add, for reasons that seem totally immoral to me), it's refreshing to see this creative, subtle, even optimistic take on the possibilities:
Funny the @nytimes covered this today, but I had an honest conversation with my students today about #chatGPT. 🧵
2
5
839
Among the ideas Smith anticipated by 200+ years: EA and Singer's child-in-the-pond thought experiment, both of which he pokes in The Theory of Moral Sentiments, part 3 ch3:
1
1
353
Great to see Mark Strand poetry adorning a random building here in New Orleans!
8
Hard to believe we lost Richard Taruskin and Peter Brook in a single weekend: two giants whose writings I encountered at exactly the right age, and without whom I couldn't have become the academic or musician I now am. R.I.P.
1
2
Taruskin in particular, via 'Text and Act' and then 'The Ox', really taught me as a late teen what it means to think deeply and creatively about music and performance. I've moved on from some of the arguments he furthers, but I'll always be indebted to his mind and prose.
1
2
Oh Proust. First he was doing Adam Smith on fictions and sympathies; now he's making me think of Popper on the reality of 'World 3' objects. (Plus a bit of Plato, Kant, etc)
1
6
It was especially fun to write something outside my normal area of musicology (or philosophy-adjacent musicology). Also, it was my first 'real' book review. And although many colleagues and mentors have described review-writing as being onerous, I really enjoyed doing it.
1
3
Two hours later and the concert is still going! One more short intermission, and then Mendelssohn's Octet - a piece as philosophical as an instrumental composition can possibly be. In case anyone wants to listen 'with' me: youtu.be/4E6RkWEKpVQ
1
Mendelssohn composed the Octet while actively reading Hegel's writings on time and cyclicity, and he tried to incorporate some of these philosophical ideas into the structure of the piece.
1
2