Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston) header
Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston) profile picture

Orthopaedic Sports Surgeon. Sports, Sports Science, Healthcare Politics. IHS/UCI/UCICOM/NYU/USC Posts are my own and not reflective of anyone but me. 🙂

Walnut Creek, CA
Joined July 2011
Photo by Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston)Photo by Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston)Photo by Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston)Photo by Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston)Photo by Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston)Photo by Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston)Photo by Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston)Photo by Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston)Photo by Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston)Photo by Charles Preston, MD (@DocPreston)
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
Fix It Friday: how Congress can engage on the 2027 fee schedule CMS has made its changes and now it is time for Congress to weigh in. Government funding runs out December 11 so Congress has a short window to coalesce around solutions to attach to a likely Continuing Resolution end of year bill. 1. Pass an inflationary update. The Patients First Act is the vehicle. The medical association ask is to extend the 2.5% update through 2027, but a one-year extension of a one-year patch is how we got here in the first place. The 2026 update expired, so we started in a 2.5% hold, and the statutory 0.25% update does nothing against practice costs CMS projects to grow about 2.5%. Physicians are the only Medicare provider type with no annual update tied to their actual costs. Hospitals have one. Skilled nursing facilities have one. Home health has one. Physicians have a budgetary number that is a political hot potato. H.R. 9693, the Patients First Act, introduced by Reps. John Joyce, MD, Greg Murphy, MD, and Kim Schrier, MD, (the Republican and Democrat chairs of their respective doctors caucuses) with 65 bipartisan cosponsors as of mid-October and a House Energy and Commerce Health Subcommittee hearing, fixes that. It ties the annual update to the Medicare Economic Index minus one point, with MEI minus half a point for advanced APM participants, builds it into the baseline, and limits year-to-year swings. That is the only proposal on the table that grows the pie instead of re-slicing it, and it is the most direct response to everything the issues raised this week. Inflationary updates prevent us from having to constantly rob Peter (specialists) to pay Paul (primary care). This fix won’t be cheap. The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget has estimated MEI indexing at roughly $65 billion over ten years relative to current law. I believe the number will come back substantially higher from the CBO. 2. Block the modifier 25 cut in statute and exempt the fix from budget neutrality. MGMA has asked Congress to fix modifier 25 alongside the conversion factor. They have asked Congress to prohibit CMS from applying a payment reduction to a separately identifiable E/M service billed with modifier 25 for 2027, and direct CMS to collect observed intra-visit time and cost data before revisiting the question. That being said, if Congress blocks the cut without exempting the change from budget neutrality, CMS simply lowers the conversion factor to recover the money. 3. Keep sequestration off the table. The 2% Budget Control Act sequester has reduced every Medicare payment since 2013, but Congress has been diligent in extending it every year. Then there is statutory PAYGO. Last November Congress wiped the PAYGO scorecard that the 2025 reconciliation law had loaded with roughly $3.4 trillion in deficits, which is the only reason a 4% Medicare sequester did not happen in January 2026. Any year-end package that spends money, on physicians or anything else, will trigger PAYGO. The package must carry its own PAYGO waiver. 4. Raise and index the budget neutrality threshold. Earlier this week, we looked at how good CMS decisions can produce a worse conversion factor, which is a function of a $20 million threshold that has not changed since 1992. H.R. 8163, the Provider Reimbursement Stability Act, passed the House Ways and Means Committee on May 21. Its Senate companion, S. 5180 (Boozman, Welch, Marshall, King, Tillis, Shaheen), has similar language, and the Patients First Act incorporates the changes. The bill raises the threshold into the mid-$50 million range, indexes it to MEI every five years, requires CMS to correct utilization estimates that prove wrong, and puts practice expense data on a regular update schedule. 5. Put guardrails on how CMS values codes. This year CMS proposed to override a RUC survey value for the two highest-volume procedures in orthopaedics with a crosswalk to unrelated codes, then reversed based on overwhelming response from the physician community. Last year it applied a 2.5% efficiency adjustment to thousands of codes using a productivity proxy. Congress should require that any CMS departure from a survey-based work value be supported by published, observed time data, and that any proposed revaluation above a defined threshold come with a specialty-level impact analysis in the proposed rule, not the final one. The statute already phases in RVU cuts of 20% or more over two years. Lowering that trigger would end the whole-number cliffs that hit joint replacement two years in a row. 6. Require evidence before service-line cuts. The same-day 25 modifier policy is propped up on a theory of duplicate payment that CMS never quantified against its own practice of removing overlap time during valuation. The Patients First Act requires notice and comment before CMS introduces or changes a mandatory payment model. I would extend that concept to other aspects of payment. Before CMS reduces payment for a service on the ground that it duplicates another, it should have to publish the evidence of duplication and the specialty-level effect, and give the public a full comment cycle. 7. Fix the data problem. CMS's argument on both modifier 25 and practice expense is that the data is old. Congress should direct and pay for independent, observed collection of practice cost and physician time across independent practices, not only hospital-affiliated ones, so the next revaluation is argued over facts rather than crosswalks and theories. CMS cannot build an accurate fee schedule on 2007 surveys and claims data, but it should not be allowed to build one on assumptions either.
3
15
1
36
1,954
Congress must intervene to protect Medicare patients from the 2027 CMS physician reimbursement cuts. Reductions in work RVUs for total joint arthroplasty and decreased reimbursement for Modifier 25 evaluation and management services place additional financial pressure on orthopedic practices already facing rising costs. This is not simply about physician reimbursement. It is about PATIENT ACCESS. When reimbursement fails to reflect the complexity and resources required to deliver high-quality orthopedic care, practices face difficult decisions about their ability to continue providing those services. Medicare beneficiaries deserve timely access to joint replacement surgery, appropriate evaluations, and comprehensive musculoskeletal care. I urge Congress to address these cuts before they compromise access to care. @RepDeSaulnier @GoldStateOrtho #Medicare #PatientAccess #Orthopedics
1
2
54
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
Breaking: CMS finalized the 2027 physician fee schedule. Most physicians face a 2.31% conversion factor cut Jan. 1, while the modifier -25 same-day cut drops to 20% and traditional MIPS reporting now ends in 2031. #Medicare #PhysicianFeeSchedule #CMS 🔗 hubs.li/Q04DnBVm0
9
22
8
58
68,049
Time will tell but this may be the time the Titanic hits the iceberg for independent orthopedic practices. Arthroplasty practices will no longer be able to care for Medicare patients. Independent practices do not have the facility fees or concomitant commercial contracts to absorb this hit from CMS.
Physician voices helped influence the final Medicare Physician Fee Schedule and mitigate some of the more significant concerns in the proposed rule. That matters, but meaningful challenges remain. AAOS will keep pushing for a fair, data-driven reimbursement system that values physician services, preserves physician-led decision-making and protects patient access to care.
61
"If [patients] can't get in to see us, they will lose the ability to be independent in their lives — and that is one thing we all need" Orthopaedic advocates from California traded the coast for the Capitol during #NOLC2026 as they met with legislators to protect access to high quality musculoskeletal care. How are you standing up for orthopaedic surgeons in your state? @COA_Ortho @UCDavisOrtho @shrinershosp
2
3
162
The CY 2027 MPFS final rule is expected by Nov. 6. Have you spoken out yet? Share how declining Medicare reimbursement has impacted your patients and orthopaedic practice by visiting our CMS Payment Resource Center: bit.ly/3SxWTnk The countdown is on. ⏳
2
2
168
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
25 Yrs Ago: 1st-ever No. 1 vs No. 2 in US. Hard to believe it's been 25 years since legendary 2001 De La Salle vs Long Beach Poly showdown. A 116-game win streak was on the line vs the top CIFSS program at the time. We were there. @RonMFlores @HaroldAbend calhisports.com/2026/10/04/2…
1
15
1
110
5,544
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
DE LA SALLE HOLDS ON 4TH DOWN AGAIN THE SPARTANS ARE GONNA SEE OUT A THRILLER WOW
5
1
38
11,338
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
De La Salle’s @Duecejd2 after he rushed for 211 yards, three TDs in epic win over Centennial-Corona at Cal’s Memorial Stadium. @dlsfootball17 @dlsathletics @DavidKiefer987 @CB_Journalist @GReeves23 @leftwich
1
10
1
38
6,350
Exciting evening looking after the San Jose Earthquakes @ Levi tonight. @GoldStateOrtho
1
10
376
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
We’re proud to stand with CATA & athletic trainers advocating for meaningful regulation & accountability of athletic trainers as certified health care professionals. Accurate representation & licensure help protect student-athletes & athletes everywhere. This is #AdvocacyInAction
The lack of regulation/licensure for certified athletic trainers in CA creates an environment where employers can change job titles & responsibilities to work around protections intended to ensure qualified professionals are providing athletic training services.
6
26
2,011
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
cbsnews.com/losangeles/video… CATA has been working alongside the ATs directly impacted by this issue for some time & we will continue to stand with them. We are committed to advocating for the protections & recognition our profession deserves.
9
1
14
3,283
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
Gaels on the Hill! Yesterday, Sydney Wilson visited Washington, DC to represent the Gaels & @wccsports in efforts to lobby for the Protect College Sports Act! Way to go Sydney!
2
6
1
16
4,986
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
The lack of regulation/licensure for certified athletic trainers in CA creates an environment where employers can change job titles & responsibilities to work around protections intended to ensure qualified professionals are providing athletic training services.
CA is the only state w/o regulations for Certified Athletic Trainers A recent bill tried to solve the issue, but some districts are changing the job title to circumvent the bill Tonite at 10:40p @chrishayre visits Chaffey Joint Union HS District to find out more @CBSLosAngeles
13
1
26
4,060
"Medicare is a budgetary number that is disconnected from anything that resembles value or cost." #Truth
Fully agree. Medicare is a budgetary number that is disconnected from anything that resembles value or cost. And yet insurers want us to force arbitrators to use a multiple of a fake number to determine what is fair
2
139
On my 3rd round exec physical @MayoClinic got surprise billed, level four coded during a telehealth to set up an executive physical for changing a cholesterol med. While I hope they keep saving many lives, I kindly walked. They are part of the healthcare problem, not the solution
This is what “preventive care” looks like in America in 2026. A patient goes in for the annual physical her insurance promised would be covered. She mentions anxiety and bloating. The clinic later bills her $216 because, and I quote the billing office: “Insurances pay once a year for a physical—which is just that. A physical, no problems can be discussed.” Read that again. No problems can be discussed. What, exactly, is the point of a “preventative physical” if the patient is not allowed to mention the conditions she is trying to prevent? There is no healthy adult walking around with zero medical concerns. Anxiety. Bloating. Fatigue. Sleep. Weight. Blood pressure that is starting to creep. A family history that suddenly feels relevant. These are not “problem visits.” These are the exact conversations that turn a checkbox exam into actual prevention. The current coding and payment rules punish that conversation. The moment a physician documents a concern and uses clinical judgment, the visit can be reclassified from a no-cost preventive service into an evaluation-and-management visit subject to deductible and copay. Clinics know this. Insurers know this. Hospital systems that own those clinics know this. The patient is the last person told. The result is predictable: • Patients learn to stay silent so they do not get a surprise bill. • Early, cheap problems become late, expensive ones. • Physicians are trained by RVUs and modifier-25 rules to treat humans as either “well” or “sick,” never as people who need both screening and counsel in the same 20 minutes. • Insurers keep the premium and deny the claim. Hospital systems bill the higher code. The patient pays twice—once in premiums, again at the window. This is a billing product dressed up as wellness, and it has nothing to do with medicine. @SecKennedy @RobertKennedyJr @DrOz @DrOzCMS @CMSGov @POTUS — you have the authority to end this farce. Require that a covered annual preventive visit include the discussion of common symptoms and risk factors without automatically converting the encounter into a separately billed problem visit. Mandate clear, written notice before the visit if any conversation may trigger cost-sharing. Stop letting the CPT codebook decide whether a doctor is allowed to listen. Prevention that forbids the patient from speaking is not remotely close to prevention. It is a trap that makes Americans sicker and the people who run the billing departments richer. Fix the rule. Do it now. Every adult who has ever sat in that exam room already knows this is broken. They are waiting for someone in Washington to admit it.
3
134
💯"Spin the RUC out into its own independent nonprofit, governed separately from AMA leadership, with physician, patient and payer representation and full public disclosure of its recommendations and voting record. That removes the AMA's direct hand from the valuation process without handing valuation to a federal agency that answers to insurers and political appointees instead. " 💯
The AMA should keep its copyright over CPT. Trying to force that copyright open now, through litigation or legislation, raises a problem more serious than disruption. Copyright is property, and forcing a private organization to surrender ownership of a copyrighted work without compensation is a real legal question, separate from the government edicts doctrine argument now being litigated in the Patient Rights Advocate lawsuit. If a court or Congress did push CPT into the public domain, the result would not be a free version of the current system continuing to run as is. It would functionally require building new coding infrastructure from the ground up, since the codes, their valuations and every licensing relationship tied to them exist inside a copyright framework that would no longer apply. That means re-pricing every one of the more than eleven thousand CPT codes, retraining every biller and coder in the country, and rebuilding claims logic inside every electronic health record, clearinghouse and payer system that touches Medicare billing. Independent practices, which do not have in-house IT departments the way hospital systems do, would carry the heaviest share of that cost, and the outcome would be genuinely unpredictable rather than merely expensive. The conflict that actually deserves fixing is not code ownership. It is code valuation, and it lives inside the RVS Update Committee, the RUC. The AMA currently administers the RUC directly. The AMA Board of Trustees selects the RUC chair and the AMA's own representative to the committee, even though RUC recommendations to CMS on how Medicare should value physician work determine what independent practices actually get paid. That is the real structural conflict Cassidy and Harshbarger are pointing at, and it can be fixed without touching CPT copyright at all. Spin the RUC out into its own independent nonprofit, governed separately from AMA leadership, with physician, patient and payer representation and full public disclosure of its recommendations and voting record. That removes the AMA's direct hand from the valuation process without handing valuation to a federal agency that answers to insurers and political appointees instead. Submit a comment to CMS on the CY2027 Physician Fee Schedule RFI before September 14 supporting a structurally independent RUC while opposing any shift of CPT ownership or valuation authority to CMS itself. Ask Senator Cassidy and Representative Harshbarger to write that same distinction into any legislation they introduce. Separate the ownership question from the governance question. Fix that governance question and leave copyright alone.
1
77
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
For the first time in over 35 years, the historic programs of De La Salle and Cardinal Newman meet tonight. Links to our live stream coverage from Owen Owens Field are in the post below
2
7
2
19
4,322
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
The American Medical Association created the Current Procedural Terminology code set in 1966 to standardize how physicians described medical, surgical and diagnostic services. It did not become mandatory infrastructure through a free market. Congress and federal regulation made it mandatory. Under 45 CFR 162.1002, HIPAA transaction standards require physician and non-hospital services to be coded using CPT and HCPCS, a rule unchanged since 1996. That is the root of the current fight. The AMA holds copyright over a code set that federal law requires every physician, hospital, insurer and health IT vendor in the country to use, and it charges for that access. Licensing runs $82.50 annually plus an $18.50 per user royalty under one common model, with a physical codebook priced at $137.89. Senator Bill Cassidy, chairman of the Senate HELP Committee, documented in an October 2025 letter to AMA President Bobby Mukkamala that AMA royalty revenue from CPT licensing grew from $65.8 million in 2011 to $284.8 million in 2023, a fourfold increase in a decade. Total AMA revenue reached $513.2 million in 2024. Cassidy called this an abuse of a government backed monopoly. This scrutiny is not happening in a vacuum. Over the past year the AMA has moved from cautious diplomacy toward open confrontation with HHS. In June 2026 AMA delegates elected Sandra Fryhofer as president-elect over Michael Suk, a former board chair who had prioritized Medicare fee advocacy and pragmatic engagement with Secretary Kennedy. Fryhofer, the AMA's longtime liaison to the federal vaccine advisory committee, has called Kennedy the anti-vax HHS secretary and said physicians and patients can no longer trust the CDC under his leadership, pledging to call out the administration on vaccine policy, Medicaid cuts and physician payment once she takes office in June 2027. Her win over a more conciliatory rival was widely read inside organized medicine as AMA members choosing confrontation over pocketbook diplomacy. None of that makes Cassidy's numbers or the CMS RFI illegitimate, since the monopoly concerns are documented on their own terms. But escalating conflict between AMA leadership and HHS, culminating in the election of one of Kennedy's most outspoken physician critics to lead the organization next year, is presumably part of why the administration is moving on CPT now. Patient Rights Advocate has also sued the AMA, arguing under the government edicts doctrine from the Supreme Court's 2020 decision in Georgia v. Public.Resource.Org that a required code set cannot be copyrighted and sold, a serious legal theory, not a fringe one. Every organization named here has its own financial interest in how this resolves. But the revenue figures are documented, the political conflict is real, and the legal challenge is genuine. Tomorrow we look at what CMS actually proposed, because it differs somewhat from what Secretary Kennedy's video suggested.
2
8
15
759
Charles Preston, MD retweeted
Kroenke Sports & Entertainment is acquiring the Angels, as #Rams owner Stan Kroenke adds to his sports portfolio.
144
347
305
2,790
1,179,366