Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
Who exactly was Voldemort referring to here was it ever explained? #HarryPotter
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
Voldemort’s speech in the graveyard reveals something interesting about the Death Eaters who were missing when he returned.
When he talks about the one “too cowardly to return,” he means Igor Karkaroff. The one he believes has “left me forever” is Severus Snape, while his “most faithful servant” is Barty Crouch Jr., who is already at Hogwarts disguised as Mad-Eye Moody.
But the most interesting part is the three Death Eaters Voldemort says died in his service: Regulus Black, Evan Rosier and Wilkes. Their names aren’t all revealed in that speech, but later books and the surrounding context help fill in the gaps.
Imagine standing in that graveyard, hearing Voldemort call out his missing followers. How many of them do you think he genuinely believed were dead, and how many did he suspect had betrayed him?
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
He survived the Games, but never survived losing them. Oh, Haymitch, you’ll never be drunk enough.☹️
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
That line breaks me every time because it is literally true.
Haymitch won the 50th Hunger Games at 16 and the Capitol made sure he never won anything ever again.
He lost Maysilee in the arena, holding her while she died. He lost Lenore Dove because Snow poisoned her for loving him. He came home and lost his mother and his little brother because Snow had them killed as punishment for that stunt with the force field.
So what was he supposed to do with that? He was 16, a victor, rich, famous, and completely alone in a house in Victors' Village with no one left to protect.
The drinking was never about being drunk. It was about being numb enough to get through one more day without hearing their voices. Without remembering Lenore Dove's song. Without remembering Maysilee telling him not to let the Capitol change him.
And the saddest part is in Sunrise, you see he was not always like that. He was funny. He was clever. He was kind. He was a kid who tried to save everyone, even the girl from District 1 who tried to kill him.
The Capitol did not kill Haymitch in the arena because they wanted him to live as a warning. This is what happens when you are clever. This is what happens when you fight back. We will let you live, but we will take everything you love.
So yeah. He survived the Games. He just never survived what came after them.
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
Yeah, they do, but you have to catch it in the prequel, not the original trilogy.
Before Snow was President Maximinius Ravinstill.
He was already president before the Dark Days, he was the one who created the Hunger Games after the First Rebellion as punishment for the districts, and he was still president during the 10th Hunger Games when Snow was just an 18-year-old mentor.
Collins never gives us a full list of presidents before him. Ravinstill is the only one we actually meet.
How Snow took over is never shown on-page, but the how is laid out for us:
Snow did not win an election and become a good leader. He poisoned his way up.
Finnick tells Katniss this in Mockingjay. Snow would poison his rivals, but to avoid suspicion he would drink from the same cup himself, then take the antidote. The antidote left him with mouth sores that bled for the rest of his life, which is why he always wore that white rose. To cover the smell of his own blood.
But the poison was just the last step. The real rise was:
1. He impressed Dr. Gaul as a Gamemaker by turning the Games from a boring punishment into a spectacle with sponsors, betting, and Victors' Village
2. He made himself useful to the Capitol elite while quietly removing anyone who was in his way, including Dean Highbottom, who actually invented the Games
3. He survived District 12, survived Sejanus, survived Lucy Gray, and came back with no witnesses left who could ruin him
By the time we get to Haymitch's Games, the 50th, Snow is already president. So somewhere in that 40-year gap between Ballad and Sunrise, Ravinstill is gone and Snow is on top. Collins leaves that gap blank on purpose. We are not meant to see a coronation. We are meant to understand that he just kept eliminating people until there was no one left above him.
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
Why do you think Katniss's feelings for Gale weakened over time, especially considering their history?
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
I think over time she started to see how selfish Gale really was. Not selfish in a small way, but in the way he was willing to win the war at any cost. That clashed with her moral compass, because she was never willing to treat people like pawns on a battlefield the way he was.
Peeta was different. Peeta was someone who needed to be saved. That gave her a reason to justify the hard, questionable choices she made, because she could tell herself she was doing it to protect him. It gave her moral cover.
Gale did not have that cover. He was just there, making those same brutal calls without an excuse.
Chill bro, I had a migraine yesterday, so this is my best guess lol
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
Collins actually answers this in Katniss's own head, right in that moment on the stage.
When Peeta's name is called, Katniss thinks:
He has two older brothers, but one is probably too old now to volunteer and the other won't. This is standard. Family devotion only goes so far for most people on reaping day. What I did was the radical thing.
So it breaks down like this:
1. One brother literally couldn't
Reaping age is 12 to 18. Once you turn 19, you are out. Katniss guesses the oldest Mellark brother had already aged out. He was not an option even if he wanted to be.
2. The other brother chose not to
The middle brother was still eligible, probably 17 or 18. He just did not step forward. And Katniss is not judging him for it, she is saying that is normal. Most people do not volunteer. Volunteering means you are choosing almost certain death for yourself to save someone else. That is not a normal family decision, even if you love your brother.
3. Katniss was not normal in that moment
That is why her volunteer feels so shocking to everyone in District 12. She was not just a big sister. After her dad died and her mom shut down, Katniss basically _became_ Prim's parent. She hunted for her, she fed her, she sang to her, she kept her alive when she was 11 and starving. Prim was not just her sister, Prim was the one person Katniss had managed to protect in a world that took everything else.
Peeta's brothers did not have that bond. They grew up in the merchant part of District 12, in a bakery run by a cruel, abusive mother. Peeta even says later that his mother thought he was expendable, that District 12 could survive without another baker's son. That family was not built on sacrifice. It was built on survival and keeping your head down.
Katniss volunteering was not what families do in Panem. It was the first crack in the system. That is why everyone gasped, why Effie did not know what to do, and why the Capitol immediately saw her as a threat.
Peeta's brothers did what most people would do. Katniss did what almost no one would do.
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
Okay, longer version because this one deserves it.
My favorite horror movie is The Hunger Games. And I mean the actual horror part, not just the arena.
Everyone talks about the Games as horror. Kids killing kids. Mutts. The Careers. That is horror, yes. But the real horror is quieter. It is in the Capitol. It is in the interviews. It is in the dresses.
Cinna is the best example of that.
Think about what he was asked to do. Snow had already decided Katniss was a problem. The whole wedding was a punishment. It was Snow saying, "You will smile, you will wear white, you will pretend you are happy to marry Peeta, and you will show Panem that I own you."
Cinna was supposed to make that dress perfect. He was supposed to make her look like a Capitol doll. Instead, he made a trap.
He sewed that dress to burn away on live television. White to black. Bride to Mockingjay. Innocent girl to symbol of rebellion. He knew the cameras would catch every second of it. He knew millions of people in the districts would see it. He knew Snow would see it.
And he knew what Snow does to people who embarrass him.
Cinna was not naive. He had seen what Snow did to Haymitch. He had seen what the Capitol did to anyone who got too clever. He had watched the Games for years. He knew there was no version of this where he walked away. If he did the dress, Snow would kill him. If he did not do the dress, he would be betraying everything he believed in.
So he chose to die on his own terms.
That is what makes that scene so horrifying when you rewatch it. Katniss is spinning, the audience is gasping, the dress is transforming, and Cinna is just standing there smiling. He is not smiling because he is proud of the design. He is smiling because he knows he just did it. He just lit the match.
He walks her to the elevator. He kisses her forehead. He says something calm. And then the Peacekeepers drag him away and beat him to death right there while Katniss is screaming and banging on the glass. She has to go into the arena with the sound of him dying still in her ears.
That is why I say The Hunger Games is horror. It is not a monster jumping out. It is a system where a kind, gentle, brilliant man has to sew his own death into a wedding dress just to give a 17 year old girl a chance to fight back.
Cinna knew. He knew from the first stitch. And he still finished the dress.
“What’s your favorite horror movie?”
The fact that cinna already knew he would be killed by the capitol when he made katniss’s wedding dress transform into a mockingjay
#Hungergames
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
And the scariest part of his intelligence is that he actually learns.
Most villains repeat the same mistake. Snow doesn't.
In Ballad, he loses Lucy Gray because he tries to control her completely. He learns from that. He spends the next 65 years making sure no one can ever leave him like that again. That's why he poisons people who get too close. That's why he kills anyone who knows too much. He would rather kill his own allies than be betrayed again.
And he understands something Coin never did: people don't actually want freedom. They want to feel safe and entertained.
That's why he never just rules with soldiers. He rules with the Games, with the love stories, with the fashion, with the feasts. He gives the Capitol something to watch so they don't have to think about what they're watching. He gives the districts a Victor to celebrate so they don't have to think about why their children are dying.
His real genius is that he makes oppression look like a gift.
He doesn't say "obey me or die." He says "watch this beautiful girl fall in love, watch this brave boy win, cheer for them." And while you're cheering, you forget you're in a cage.
That's why Katniss is the only person who ever truly scares him. Because she doesn't want power. She doesn't want fame. She doesn't want to play his game at all. And you can't manipulate someone who doesn't want what you're offering.
He's smart enough to control everyone who wants something. He's not smart enough to control someone who just wants to be left alone.
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
Paul Atreides now has the ability to see and select whichever possible future he wants to, and there is in fact only one possible future in which the human race survives. It’s not a brilliant future - it involves, for example, a galactic jihad and the brutal suppression of any dissent - but it does actually preserve the species.
There is no way to beat Paul at this point or to prevent the future he’s chosen from happening. The stuff that we’ve been reading about up to his awakening - spies, assassins, warfare, treachery, plots within plots - none of that will work against him any more, because he is basically God. There’s no possible conflict from which to generate story.
Now: obviously, there are multiple sequels to Dune. But really the story of these sequels is people struggling against the end of stories. Paul decides he no longer wants to be part of this universe, and hands off the responsibility of steering humanity through the story that he’s written to his son Leto; other factions like the Guild and the Ixians do their best to overthrow prescience and return free will to humanity; but it feels a lot like a bleak cautionary tale about what life feels like after God shows up, and I don’t think anyone feels that any of the sequels are as much fun as the first book.
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
No.
The Time-Turner whilst powerful, was limited to five hours. So if we’re comparing like for like, to revisit the past and save someone from death would require you to have it at hand… and even then, you’re running a big risk and might end up failing and doing irreparable damage to your own existence…
“Don’t you see? Professor McGonagall told me what awful things have happened when wizards have meddled with time… Loads of them ended up killing their past or future selves by mistake!” - Hermione Granger, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
The Ministry did experiments on the effects of going back further than five hours and the results were catastrophic:
“Eloise Mintumble became trapped, for a period of five days, in the year 1402. Now we understand that her body had aged five centuries in its return to the present and, irreparably damaged, she died in St Mungo’s Hospital for Magical Maladies and Injuries shortly after we managed to retrieve her. What is more, her five days in the distant past caused great disturbance to the life paths of all those she met, changing the course of their lives so dramatically that no fewer than twenty-five of their descendants vanished in the present, having been “un-born”.
‘Finally, there were alarming signs, during the days following Madam Mintumble’s recovery, that time itself had been disturbed by such a serious breach of its laws. Tuesday following her reappearance lasted two and a half full days, whereas Thursday shot by in the space of four hours.” - JKR, Pottermore
The Resurrection Stone on the other hand, does not come with those risks or limitations. Whilst it cannot fully revive a person (at least, if Grindelwald’s theory was wrong), it can summon forth their soul from the afterlife as less than living, but more than a ghost being.
I consider the lack of dangers and the sheer power to call forth souls from the afterlife as being more basically powerful than the Time-Reversal Charm. It’s special and unique.
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
In Harry Potter, is the Time-Turner more powerful than the Resurrection Stone?
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
The Resurrection Stone is practically useless, at least based on what we're told in the books. And while the Time-Turner was an interesting addition to Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, I honestly think it's so overpowered that its existence creates some of the biggest problems in the entire Harry Potter universe.
Think about it. If Time-Turners could be used freely to change past events, just imagine the possibilities:
- Dumbledore could have gone back in time and prevented himself from putting on Marvolo Gaunt's ring, avoiding the curse that eventually led to his death.
- Voldemort could have attempted to prevent Harry from escaping the graveyard in Goblet of Fire.
- Voldemort could have tried to stop Harry from finding and destroying his Horcruxes.
- Voldemort could have attempted to prevent the prophecy from being destroyed during the battle at the Department of Mysteries.
- Any wizard who survived a duel could theoretically travel back in time, prepare for the encounter, and try to change its outcome.
And those are only a few examples. The possibilities seem almost endless.
Now, to be fair, the books provide some explanations for why Time-Turners aren't used to solve every problem.
The first argument is that Time-Turners are heavily regulated by the Ministry of Magic and extremely difficult to obtain.
But here's my problem with that explanation: the Ministry allowed a thirteen-year-old Hermione Granger to use one simply so she could attend additional classes.
Yes, Professor McGonagall personally arranged it and Hermione was an exceptionally responsible student. But the fact that the Ministry was willing to entrust such a powerful magical object to a third-year student makes me question just how strict those regulations really were.
And if Hermione could obtain one for academic purposes, are we really supposed to believe that someone as influential and powerful as Dumbledore couldn't have accessed one when the stakes were considerably higher?
Then there's Voldemort. Once he took control of the Ministry in Deathly Hallows, wouldn't he have had access to whatever remained of its magical resources?
Of course, there's an important detail here: the Ministry's entire known stock of Time-Turners was destroyed during the battle in the Department of Mysteries in Order of the Phoenix. That explains why the characters couldn't simply retrieve one later.
But even then, I find myself wondering why nobody attempted to manufacture replacements. Given how extraordinary their abilities were, surely recreating them would have been worth investigating.
The second argument concerns the dangers of time travel, particularly the possibility of encountering your past self.
In Prisoner of Azkaban, Hermione explains that terrible things have happened to witches and wizards who interfered with time, including people accidentally killing their past or future selves.
But I struggle with the idea that someone as knowledgeable as Dumbledore or as calculating as Voldemort would automatically lose control simply because they encountered another version of themselves.
These aren't inexperienced students who have never heard of time travel. They're two of the most powerful and knowledgeable wizards of their generation.
Surely, if anyone could understand the risks and attempt to navigate them, it would be them.
However, there's another complication that makes this debate even more interesting.
The time travel we actually witness in Prisoner of Azkaban operates as a consistent timeline rather than allowing Harry and Hermione to freely rewrite events.
Harry doesn't change the past when he saves himself and Sirius from the Dementors. He eventually realizes that he was always the person who cast the Patronus he had witnessed earlier.
Likewise, Buckbeak's apparent execution never actually occurs in the version of events we see. Harry and Hermione's intervention was already part of that timeline.
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
In Dune: Part One, how did Paul defeat Jamis when he is a Fremen? Fremen are more powerful than regular humans.
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
I think Slytherin has been given an unfair reputation over the years, partly because we’ve spent most of the Harry Potter series seeing the house through Harry’s eyes.
Let’s be honest, Salazar Slytherin himself gave people plenty of reasons to distrust his legacy. He believed Hogwarts should only admit pure-blood students, and he secretly built the Chamber of Secrets with a Basilisk inside, intending for his heir to use it against Muggle-born students. That’s not exactly a flattering history for a house to inherit.
But does that mean everyone sorted into Slytherin shares those beliefs? Absolutely not.
The house values ambition, cunning, determination and resourcefulness. None of those qualities automatically make someone a bad person. Wanting power or success isn’t evil. It’s what someone is willing to do to achieve those things that matters.
We’ve actually seen several Slytherins who challenge the house’s reputation. Merlin himself was a Slytherin. Horace Slughorn was ambitious and loved associating with powerful and talented people, but he wasn’t a follower of Voldemort. Regulus Black risked his life to steal one of Voldemort’s Horcruxes after realising what his master truly was. Andromeda Tonks rejected her family’s obsession with blood purity and married Ted Tonks, a Muggle-born wizard.
Even Slughorn eventually returned to Hogwarts with reinforcements to fight Voldemort during the Battle of Hogwarts.
I also think our perception of Slytherin is heavily influenced by the characters we meet. Draco, Crabbe, Goyle and several other Slytherins constantly reinforce the idea that the house is full of bullies and blood supremacists. Meanwhile, we rarely get to spend time with ordinary Slytherin students who don’t share those beliefs.
There’s a difference between belonging to a house that values ambition and believing that everyone outside your bloodline is inferior.
Slytherin didn’t produce only evil wizards. It produced people with ambition, and some of them chose to use that ambition for terrible things.
Compass Man 🧭 retweeted
The 10 Most Dangerous Spells in Harry Potter Even Worse Than the Unforgivable Curses!
Harry Potter has exactly three officially Unforgivable Curses, and somehow a spell that opens your chest like an invisible sword is not one of them.
Use Avada Kedavra, Crucio, or Imperio on another human and you can earn life in Azkaban.
So you would think those three are the basement.
They are not.
Past them are teenage curses, living fire, corpse armies, lethal promises, and eventually magic that tears pieces off your own soul.
So let's get the famous three out of the way fast.
They are basically the front door.
No. 10 — The Three Unforgivable Curses
Avada Kedavra kills instantly with no normal counter-curse.
Crucio tortures and works properly only if you genuinely want the victim to suffer.
Imperio takes control of another person while they can feel almost completely calm.
Death. Torture. Free will.
Those are the three the Ministry calls Unforgivable.
Then Snape apparently decided that list needed competition.
No. 9 — Sectumsempra
Harry finds the spell in the Half-Blood Prince's textbook.
Beside it:
"For enemies."
That is the warning.
Harry tries it on Draco.
His face and chest split open as if invisible blades carved through him.
Blood covers the floor.
Snape reverses the damage.
Of course he knows what happened.
He invented it as a teenager.
Teenage Snape created a remote human-slicing spell, labeled it "for enemies," and apparently went back to homework.
Not Unforgivable.
At least Sectumsempra stops when the spell is over.
Fiendfyre can decide the entire room belongs to it now.
No. 8 — Fiendfyre
Fiendfyre is magical fire with the temperament of a starving dragon.
It multiplies into serpents, dragons, and birds of prey.
Water does nothing once it's loose.
Controlling it is brutally difficult.
Crabbe casts it inside the Room of Requirement.
Almost immediately, the spell becomes the boss fight.
The fire eats everything.
While Harry, Ron, and Hermione flee on broomsticks, Crabbe never makes it out.
And the fire destroys Ravenclaw's diadem, a Horcrux.
Hermione knew Fiendfyre could destroy one.
She refused to use it because she did not fancy summoning a flaming zoo she could not switch off.
And that changes the scale.
We are talking about magic powerful enough to destroy pieces of a soul.
Voldemort goes darker by removing the living person completely.
No. 7 — Inferi
Inferi are not resurrected people.
The person is gone. The corpse is equipment.
Voldemort fills the lake around Slytherin's locket with them.
Harry reaches into the water.
One hand grabs him.
And the lake starts moving.
Bodies rise everywhere.
That black water was not scenery. It was storage.
Inferi fear fire.
So Dumbledore surrounds the island with flames and drives them back.
Hidden cave.
Blood payment.
Torture potion.
Lake full of corpses for one necklace.
And this is where the ladder changes.
So far, the magic mostly attacks somebody else.
Kill them, cut them, burn them, control what is left.
From here, dark magic starts binding the person using it too, through names, promises, blood, the flesh, and eventually the soul itself.
No. 6 — The Taboo
Voldemort starts with his own name.
After he takes control of the Ministry, saying "Voldemort" can expose your location and break protective enchantments.
But look at who that catches.
Most of Britain already refuses to say his name.
The people resisting him are more likely to keep using it.
So Voldemort turns courage into a tracking system.
Harry forgets.
Once he says the name, the trio's protections collapse.
The Snatchers appear and take them to Malfoy Manor.
For years, Voldemort makes people afraid to speak his name.
Then he weaponizes the people who refuse to be afraid.
The next magic makes your own promise capable of killing you.
No. 5 — The Unbreakable Vow
Make an Unbreakable Vow.
Break it.
Die.




































