winston smith (@ChanceStarkin) header
winston smith (@ChanceStarkin) profile picture

Not a stranger in a strange land.

Ottawa, Canada
Joined June 2009
The problem was that we didn't respect the ecosystems and plowed up the land without considering consequences.
In 1883 a Sioux man watched a settler in Dakota turn over the prairie with a plough, looked at the furrow and said, wrong side up. It took fifty years and the worst man-made disaster in American history to prove him right. The grass he was looking at had held the plains together for 10,000 years. Its roots went deeper than a man is tall. Around 30 million bison had grazed it, and it had come through droughts far worse than anything the settlers would see. Then wheat hit $2 a bushel in the First World War. Washington told farmers that wheat would win the war, and speculators told them that rain follows the plough. Millions of acres of sod were ripped up in a decade. When the price collapsed, they ploughed more to make up the difference. The rain stopped in 1931. There was nothing left to hold the soil down. On 14 April 1935 a black wall two miles high rolled across Oklahoma and turned the afternoon into night. Cattle suffocated standing up. Children died of dust in the lungs. An earlier storm had dropped the Great Plains on Chicago and New York, and on ships 300 miles out in the Atlantic. That spring a soil scientist called Hugh Bennett was giving evidence to senators when the sky over Washington went dark. He told them it was Oklahoma arriving. It has been taught as a drought ever since. The government knew better. It bought back nearly four million acres of the ruined farms and sowed them with grass. They are called the National Grasslands now, and they have never blown since. The government keeps cattle on them.
1
I think there is confusion because we assume there is something outside the universe that observes shape. But the universe is all; by definition there is no outside. What Grok says:
What is the actual shape of the Universe? Is it spherical, flat like a disk, or something entirely different?
5
Not all humans lived on blocks of ice during the ice ages. That tends to be ignored by carnivore promoters. We are omnivores and as such we do eat meat. From Grok:
Long before farms or cities, small bands of humans moved across the landscape following herds. They left behind bones, scraps, and the lingering scent of cooked or raw meat around their camps. Wolves, already skilled hunters and scavengers, began lingering at the edges—not as enemies, but as opportunistic neighbors. The boldest or least fearful of those wolves stayed closer. Over generations, the ones that tolerated human presence better gained a reliable source of leftover meat and fat. Humans, in turn, gained something useful: animals that could help track game, warn of predators, and, in some cases, assist in the hunt. What began as scavenging gradually became a partnership. The wolves that thrived nearest humans slowly became dogs. Both species were built for animal foods. Early humans were adept hunters and scavengers of large game, relying heavily on meat, organs, and fat for energy and nutrition. Wolves were pure carnivores by nature. In those early days of domestication, the overlap was clear—dogs ate what humans left behind or shared from successful hunts. The relationship formed around the same core resource: animal protein and fat from the landscape. Only much later, after agriculture spread, did some dog lineages develop a greater ability to digest starch. The original bond, however, was forged in a world of hunting and scavenging, where humans and their emerging canine companions thrived on a diet centered on meat. That ancient overlap still shows in how many dogs prefer and perform well on animal-based foods, and in the enduring partnership between the two species.
9
Don't take medical advice from a grumpy carnivore who needs to be reminded daily about multifactorial realities. Maybe someone can help him understand?
Cancer used to be something a doctor could go looking for and fail to find, and the doctors who looked wrote it down. A mission doctor spent 11 years among the Labrador Inuit and found no cancer. A hospital doctor spent 36 years among the Alaskan natives living the old way and found no cancer. A British army surgeon spent 7 years among 11,000 Hunza and found no cancer. A district surgeon spent 6 years among 14,000 people in the Orange Free State and found no cancer. A physician spent 25 years examining 60,000 people in Brazil and Ecuador and found no cancer. Albert Schweitzer spent his first years in Gabon examining thousands of patients and found no cancer. Six doctors on four continents, and not one of them was short of patients. Every one of them wrote the second half too. The trading post arrived, with flour, sugar and tinned fat, and within a generation there was cancer on the ward. Schweitzer watched it walk into his own hospital and put it down to his patients living like Europeans. The grandchildren of those Inuit now have some of the highest cancer rates measured anywhere. Medicine files it under bad luck and old age. It arrived by boat.
9
OMG! We bred the sheep to have to be sheered. We bred the cow to be a milk machine. Controlling and abusing animal lives is a peculiar kind of love. It's selfishness with no gratitude. And a reminder too, we "loved" the aurochs out of existence. It's carnivore cockamamy!
The vegan plan for the cow, the sheep and the pig is that there should not be any. Nobody puts it that way, but it follows. If nobody eats them, milks them or shears them, nobody keeps them. A dairy cow costs thousands a year to feed, house and treat. A flock needs a shepherd, a vet, fencing and a winter of hay. Nobody is going to fund a billion and a half cattle as a hobby. So in the world where the campaign succeeds, the last generation is simply not bred. The Hereford, the Herdwick, the Gloucester Old Spot and every other breed your ancestors spent a thousand years making go the way of the dodo, humanely, on a spreadsheet. A few hundred see out their days in sanctuaries until the donations dry up. They cannot be turned loose. A sheep that is not shorn dies under its own fleece. A dairy cow that is not milked is in agony by the second day. They are our animals. We made them and they made us, and neither side can walk away. That is the compassionate outcome: an empty hill. It is a peculiar kind of love that wants its object never to be born. A lamb in April, up on its back legs, bouncing for no reason at all, exists because somebody is going to eat it. That is the bargain, and the lamb's side of it is being alive. The alternative on offer is that it never bounced.
18
Carnivore Commandment # 9: Don't bore people with the whole truth.
People in the past were tall until somebody took their animals away, and the skeletons give the dates. 30,000 years ago the mammoth hunters of Ice Age Europe averaged about 175cm, near enough the height of a European man today. By the end of the Ice Age, with the great herds thinning, their descendants were down to about 165cm, and the first farmers who came after them never won it back. Around AD 900, in a thinly peopled northern Europe with land to spare and cattle on it, men were back up to 173cm. By the 1700s the same northern Europe, crowded and living on bread and pottage, was down to 167cm, the shortest it had been in a thousand years. In Japan the tallest men in the record lived in the Kofun era, before Buddhism took hold. After a thousand years of bans on eating livestock, late Edo men stood about 155cm, the shortest Japanese ever measured. In Korea, men of the Joseon dynasty stood at 161cm from 1400 to 1900 and barely moved. Then the money came, and meat and milk with it, and Koreans added 13cm in a single century. Northern Europe only got back to its medieval height in the first half of the twentieth century, when meat and milk reached the working man's table. Every time the height went missing, the animal had gone missing first.
13
Grok has serious concerns about a carnivore absolutist diet. Better hope it's not just a cult thing, which believers and their gleeful attacks on harmless plants would suggest.
Every superfood in the shop got its halo from a single nutrient, and most of them can't even deliver that one. Spinach is sold on iron. You absorb about 2% of it. The carrot is sold on vitamin A. It contains none. The banana is sold on potassium. A 300g ribeye carries more than twice as much, without the three teaspoons of sugar. Kale is sold on vitamin K. It is K1, the clotting kind. The K2 that sends calcium to your bones lives in cheese, butter and yolk. The walnut is sold on omega-3. It is the plant kind your body barely converts, with four times as much omega-6 along for the ride. The avocado is sold on oleic acid, the fat that made olive oil respectable. Beef fat is about 40% oleic, and you were told to cut it off. The lentil is sold on protein. It carries twice as much carbohydrate, and runs so short of methionine that the vegetarian cookbooks tell you to pair it with rice. Porridge is sold on beta-glucan, for your cholesterol. The claim was granted on Quaker's own petition in 1997, and the oats are two thirds carbohydrate. The mushroom is sold on vitamin D. A UV lamp in the packing shed put it there, and it is D2, the weaker kind. The blueberry is sold on antioxidants. The USDA withdrew its antioxidant scores in 2012, on the grounds that they meant nothing inside a human body. Brown rice is sold on the minerals in its bran. The bran also carries the phytate that locks them away, and about 80% more arsenic than white. Almond milk is sold on calcium. It is about 2% almonds, and the calcium is powdered chalk. Breakfast cereal is sold on iron. It is metal powder mixed in at the factory, and you can pull it out of the bowl with a magnet. Every halo on that list is one nutrient wide. An egg yolk hands over the vitamin A, the vitamin D, the K2, the DHA and the oleic acid, finished and ready to use. In 1968 the American Heart Association rationed it to three a week. One nutrient buys a plant a halo. Five bought the yolk a ration.
19
Homo sapiens have only existed for 300,000 or 400,000 years. This is a repeat and you keep trying to mislead us.
Squeeze the 2.6 million years of the human diet into one calendar year and the dietary guidelines turn up at ten to midnight on New Year's Eve. 1 January: a stone flake cuts meat off a bone. January to October: the same menu. Meat, marrow and fat, with whatever else was lying about. Nobody writes it down, because nobody has been born who thinks it needs explaining. 5 November: the fire is lit and kept lit. 19 November: people who look exactly like you. 26 December: the cave paintings. Every one of them is an animal. 30 December, 7.40am: somebody plants wheat. 30 December, 5.40pm: somebody milks a cow, and things improve. 31 December, 10.54pm: sugar reaches ordinary tables. 11.37pm: a soap company turns cottonseed into cooking fat. 11.50pm: a government publishes the first instructions for eating. 11.53pm: the pyramid. 11.59pm: the weekly injection. For 364 days of that year nobody counted anything, weighed anything or needed telling. The advice is ten minutes old, and it has spent nine of them explaining why the rest of the year was a mistake.
19
Hopefully nobody else is as ignorant as Theo Fleury. Of course it's likely just an act. Give us a second example Theo. Meanwhile Grok it.
Skidmark Carney says Canada wasn't founded on a single faith. Funny — the Charter opens with "Canada is founded upon principles that recognize the supremacy of God and the rule of law." That's not a suggestion. That's the founding document. The clown wants to rewrite history and hopes you never read it.
19
Grumpy carnivore's constant feeding us with misleading tidbits hoping we'll swallow them whole hog. Carnivore Commandment # 9: Don't bore people with the whole truth.
In 1957 New York's most famous diet doctor signed up 1,100 men to prove that swapping butter for corn oil prevents heart attacks. He was dead of a blood clot within four years, and the men on his diet died faster than the men who ignored it. Norman Jolliffe ran nutrition for the city's health department and had written the bestselling diet book in America. He called his recruits the Anti-Coronary Club. They were businessmen in their forties and fifties, and they pledged themselves to what he named the Prudent Diet: beef, lamb and pork cut to four small meals a week, butter out, margarine in, eggs rationed, and at least an ounce of corn oil every day, taken off a spoon if necessary. The newspapers loved it. The club's cholesterol fell. Its blood pressure fell. Its waistlines fell. The city published the numbers at intervals, and each time the headline said that diet had been linked to fewer heart attacks. Jolliffe himself did not see the end. He died in 1961, aged 59, of a thrombosis. The final count came out in 1966. Among the men on the Prudent Diet there had been 26 deaths. Among the control group, eating as New Yorkers ate, there had been 6. Eight of the club had died of heart attacks. Of the controls, none. The authors noted these figures in the body of the paper and concluded that the diet had successfully improved the men's risk factors. It was adopted, more or less whole, as the advice for the nation. They called it the Prudent Diet. The prudent ones were in the control group.
15