Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD) profile picture

Intersection of law & politics, especially the nomination, confirmation, & departure of Article III judges. Business of U.S. legal ed. & some other stuff too.

Joined December 2024
Photo by Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD)Photo by Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD)Photo by Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD)Photo by Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD)Photo by Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD)Photo by Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD)Photo by Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD)Photo by Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD)Photo by Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD)Photo by Joshua Alter (@BeyondNonJD)
The Biden administration got cocky on circuits in 2023-24. The result? The Great Circuit Crashout of 2024. The Park to the 4th as a giant middle finger to @SenThomTillis looks harder to justify as time goes on. Voted in favor of (~)9 Biden circuit picks. youtube.com/watch?v=0tXDvnfu…
1
6
18,173
Looking pretty good for Reardon (no AFJ banner either). Given Coons, Durbin, and Klobuchar voted for him in committee, should slot into at least fourth place on the Trump 2.0 AIII bipartisan index when they vote to confirm (assuming no attendance issues). King too?
By a vote of 55-31, the Senate invoked cloture on Kyle Reardon to be a District Judge for the District of Alaska. Democrats voting aye: Cortez Masto, Fetterman, Hirono, Kaine, Rosen, and Shaheen. Senators not voting: Booker, Britt, Cassidy, Coons, Cornyn, Durbin, Hickenlooper, King, Klobuchar, Murphy, Padilla, Sanders, Tuberville, and Warner.
189
10 Senators already gone (?) & cloture votes, but curious to see how many @SenateDems vote for Reardon (16-6 in Judiciary Committee) & Mansfield (14-8).
NOW VOTING: Motion to invoke cloture on Executive Calendar #970, Kyle Frederick Reardon to be United States District Judge for the District of Alaska.
101
After Coker, I think this is how it looks for red state district court seats in Trump 2.0 (+ CIT). Still curious if the third NC seat is a Tillis problem, a Budd problem, a WH problem, or a Schroeder problem. Missouri & a couple other states restocked for potential long winter.
NOW VOTING: Confirmation of Executive Calendar #969, Courtney Leigh Coker to be United States District Judge for the Northern District of Texas.
2
2
883
And curious if we'll see some deals on the blue/purple side in the 120th or a two-year freeze. Circuits on the bottom which Trump 2.0 was firing on all cylinders for (given the availability) until this summer.
1
105
Joshua Alter retweeted
Update from a RARE Friday Senate session at the Capitol: The Senate GOP is grinding through four district judges today. Thune could file cloture today on three more, which would set up Sunday votes. This seems unlikely but hasn’t been completely taken off the table It feels like Republicans have given up on another reconciliation bill for now but Dems are still wary of a last-ditch GOP attempt before Thanksgiving
1
8
2
44
12,169
It's now riskier for Rs than Ds (and Texas will be purple), but maybe they'll all come together and try again to get more district judgeships? Bonus points to get those two extra Ninth Circuit seats! uscourts.gov/data-news/judic…
98
Where did the 59 AIII confirmations so far in Trump 2.0 (double counting St. John) get their J.D.s from? Yale will take first place after Adkisson, Axt, and Falvey get confirmed. A couple other schools will move up with the final batch of 2026 confirmations. Via the FJC.
4
11
5
70
38,018
SMU Law on the board with Bennett. If they get to Coker today, he's the first of two for Mississippi College School of Law. Butler next. A little confusing because Chamberlin and Maxwell were University of Mississippi School of Law (different law schools).
140
Lifetime appointments mean you can say GTFO when anyone tells you about strategic retirement. And that cuts both ways. The Reagan/G.H.W. Bush crowd? Only 4/20 used 2025-2026 to go senior (or plan to in Boyle's case). And one was in a district court blue state so seat stays open.
1
179
Now, @scott_colom will have a say in who succeeds Wingate and @AnnieAndrewsMD for Norton if either departs before 2033 (assuming blue slips stick around). Especially poetic for Colom given his own experience.
88
One of the remaining pre-Trump 2.0 inauguration seats gets cleared today. Wonder if they'll knock out Reardon (cloture also already filed) this afternoon or save that one until next week.
Votes scheduled: At 11:00am, on Friday, November 20th, the Senate will proceed to two roll call votes on the following: 1. Confirmation of Executive Calendar #968, Richard Wesley Bennett to be United States District Judge for the Southern District of Texas. 2. Motion to invoke cloture on Executive Calendar #969, Courtney Leigh Coker to be United States District Judge for the Northern District of Texas.
1
203
Forgot they're gone the full week. Before Thanksgiving or after they get back.
40
Kennedy back in the headlines. On the circuits under Biden, his Mathis vote is one of the most interesting/talked about at the time (not even Collins). Nathan vote also turned some heads. I think he voted for 8 of the circuit picks & missed the Childs vote.
263
It may not be Article III, but there's also a federal judgeship available in Guam! CJ Tydingco-Gatewood still holding things down since the 2016 expiration. gud.uscourts.gov/content/hon… (time to update the bio for post-2016 developments in 2020 & 2024!).
1
905
Was fun to be back at ECNU Law after 9.5 years (P3 during the St. John’s years in Spring 2017!) as part of a split semester in Shanghai. In hindsight? Should’ve stayed an extra week and swung down to Shenzhen. 🤷🏻‍♂️ Still holding out hope Sanya Law School wants a winter lecturer!
250
Just ask Judge Adams to take one for the team (he’s 70) and give his seat to Gaiser in Ohio. Cornyn gets his guy in Texas. Trump nominates me to the final MDNC seat. Win-win-win. 🤷🏻‍♂️
1
4
2,674
Shoutout to the person who updated the Wiki for MDNC (teach me?)! Another one that's ready for an update is the ED Wisconsin (CJ Pepper -> CJ Ludwig). ED Wisconsin also home to Adelman ~87 & Stadtmueller ~84. Blue slip fun times with RonJon & Baldwin on W.D. w/ Peterson TBD?
Was wondering when this was going to happen but missed it! Senior Chief Judge Eagles makes way for now Chief Judge Bragdon. FWIW (absolutely nothing)? ~1 year of transitioning seemed perfect in this situation. ncmd.uscourts.gov/news/chief…
202
Unlikely any Indiana* circuit seats open anytime soon, but I’ll be curious how Banks strategizes district vacancies over the next 2-6 years. E.g., if Pratt goes senior. FWIW I feel like Young & Braun got decent value on all 5 picks under Biden given the complexities/realities.
One of the best parts about working for @SenatorBanks has been helping him identify & support great judicial nominees in Indiana. Judges who love the country are going to be a bright spot in what’s to come. Joe Falvey will be one of those bright spots. Long may he serve!
177
Just ask him if he wants to move to Greensboro, Winston Salem, or Durham instead. Just need @SenThomTillis sign off. 🤷🏻‍♂️
Elliott Gaiser is one of the greatest legal minds of his generation He belongs on the federal bench The Senate should confirm him
1
6
2,585
In all seriousness, another downside for Rs of not having any D.D.C. openings in Trump 2.0.
2
155