
Journalist, author @BloomsburyBooks. Currently @TRPForJustice, previously @thetimes. Use Mastodon more: https://xitter.cf/t.co/fTfAMLBa3O Views own. RT/like≠endorsement
水
Joined August 2012
- Tweets4.2K
- Following2.4K
- Followers1.6K
- Likes7.8K
Pinned Tweet
OUT TODAY! Thank you to all those who pre-ordered 🖤 it's now fully available via @BloomsburyAcad, Amazon, @Foyles, and possibly one or two other places 📚
bloomsbury.com/uk/the-shadow…
amazon.co.uk/Shadow-East-Vla…
Thank you @peterpomeranzev and @EllenBarryNYT for such lovely blurbs, too
Aliide retweeted
Moscow’s offer of separate “non-aggression” pacts is a naked attempt to divide NATO by making each member wonder whether abandoning its allies might buy it safety. Describing this as an offer of “additional security guarantees” accepts the Kremlin’s premise: that Russia is entitled to threaten European countries and then offer selected governments exemption from its aggression.
Russia has no right to attack any of them in the first place. Peaceful coexistence is an obligation, not a favour Moscow can sell in exchange for political obedience.
The proposal targets the foundation of NATO: the certainty that an attack on one ally will bring assistance from the others. Separate bargains would introduce doubt about who would help, who would stand aside and whose cooperation Moscow had already secured. That uncertainty would weaken deterrence before a single shot was fired.
The Washington Treaty expressly guards against this. Article 8 requires every ally “not to enter into any international engagement in conflict with this Treaty.” Article 5 requires assistance to an attacked ally, while Article 3 requires members to maintain and develop their individual and collective capacity to resist attack. A pact requiring an ally to withhold assistance, obstruct collective defence or accept restrictions incompatible with those duties would violate the Treaty. Calling it “non-aggression” would change nothing.
The proposals reported so far distinguish non-aggression pacts from commitments not to assist another party’s adversaries. We should not pretend that an unpublished treaty already contains the latter. But that is precisely the test any actual agreement must face: does it preserve allied obligations in full, or purchase Russian promises by compromising them?
For NATO, accepting security based on separate accommodations with Moscow would be strategic suicide. For individual members, it would mean weakening the collective protection on which their own security depends and replacing it with a promise from the power threatening them. A government might imagine it had purchased an exception. It would have helped dismantle the protection it would need when that exception expired.
The moral failure would be equally stark. While Russia occupies Ukrainian territory and attacks European security, bargaining for personal exemption would reward coercion and leave others to bear its costs. No European government should purchase apparent safety by making its neighbours less safe.
If Moscow wants to demonstrate non-aggression, it can withdraw from Ukraine, end its threats and hostile operations against Europe, and respect the sovereignty of its neighbours. It does not need separate treaties to stop doing what it has no right to do.
Europe’s security cannot depend on which countries Russia, famous for breaking all treaties and every promise, temporarily promises to spare.
🇷🇺 Moscow floats non-aggression pacts with individual NATO members, as Medinsky says Europe's security order was the real topic in Abu Dhabi
Russia has started to put its own vision for Europe's security on paper, and it works country by country.
Alexey Drobinin, head of foreign policy planning at the Russian Foreign Ministry, told a security forum on Wednesday that Moscow sees three models. The first is a defensive alliance or bilateral mutual assistance treaties, like those Russia has with Belarus and North Korea. The second is a political pledge not to help each other's adversaries in case of aggression, like Moscow's pact with Iran. The third is bilateral non-aggression pacts.
"For example, agreements of this kind could be reached, among other things, with individual NATO member states, which would then receive, for instance, additional individual security guarantees from the Russian Federation," Drobinin said, according to video of the speech reported by Reuters. TASS quoted him as framing it under the principle of "equal and indivisible security," the same language Moscow used in its December 2021 treaty drafts before the full-scale invasion.
The timing is deliberate. Vladimir Medinsky said a new security framework for Europe had been the central theme of the two days of talks in Abu Dhabi, according to Reuters, though he gave no details. US officials have said they are open to discussing Europe's overall security architecture. Some European politicians reject that, arguing a ceasefire in Ukraine must come first.
The appeal for Moscow is obvious. Separate deals with individual allies would offer each capital a private Russian guarantee and quietly weaken NATO's collective commitment under Article 5. No NATO government had publicly responded in the reports reviewed, and Drobinin's remarks are a proposal from a Foreign Ministry official, not an offer tabled in the talks as far as is known.
For the US, the question is how far the Abu Dhabi track drifts into redesigning European security while Washington is also floating an "Article 5-like" guarantee for Ukraine. For Europeans, it is whether they can shape that conversation before others do it for them.
What to watch: whether Kushner and Witkoff hear the same menu from Putin in Moscow on Thursday, and how NATO capitals respond in Dublin.
Video: "WE ACHIEVED FULL MUTUAL UNDERSTANDING", Putin on CSTO security talks.
I remember around 3 years ago when schools across Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania had to cancel classes because of hundreds of bomb threats. Important to watch the Baltics, which are often used as a testing ground for these things...
theguardian.com/education/20…
Aliide retweeted
Anyone who thinks russia is afraid for its security needs to be relentlessly mocked. It's like believing a rapist is afraid of short skirts.
Aliide retweeted
“Kremlin-backed news site RRN approached hundreds of Russia-friendly commentators to take part in its disinformation campaigns. Now a data hack has exposed their identities – and the methods used to entice them.” thenerve.news/p/lembit-opik-…
Aliide retweeted
Russians conduct double-tap strikes against SCHOOLS, and how does the West respond?
- The US is calling for more business deals and sanctions relief with and for Russia
- AfD is calling for the re-opening of the Nord Stream and diplomatic relations
- Le Pen is threatening on pulling all military support for Ukraine
- Fico is holding meetings with high-ranking Russian officials
- France, Spain, Italy and Greece continue giving tourist visas to Russians
- CAS allows Russians to play ice hockey in international tournaments
- Russian disinformation is rampant on social media sites because everyone is too afraid to do anything about it
Aliide retweeted
When Putin seized Crimea, both Europe and America were quite openly making calls, holding meetings, and sending signals to the Ukrainians who were in power at the time that there should be no escalation – let's just keep things friendly and leave things as they are for now. And we lost Crimea. After that, we lost part of Donbas. But the shooting in the east continued. There was no peace.
People think we were always helped. That is not true. Help started coming after the full-scale invasion, but that was after eight years of Russia occupying our territory. That is a long time to figure things out and understand that Putin has no intention of giving anything back to us.
At one point, some Europeans asked me: “Why do you think that if you withdraw from Donbas, he will go further?” And I answered: “Because at the beginning of the war, he wasn't seizing Donbas. He came to the capital. He seized parts of Zaporizhzhia and Kherson regions, Kherson itself, and Kharkiv region.” We have retaken a lot of territory, but he had seized different parts of our country. And now they want us to give them something because they are unable to seize it. We may have a smaller territory, less money, and fewer weapons, but we still have more dignity than many others. We will do everything we can to end this war, but it must end in a way that preserves our dignity.
From an interview with ZDF. (2/3)
Aliide retweeted
This.
All of this.
35 years of Baltic history in a single tweet.
Since 1991: Baltics to Europe: "watch out, Russia's a problem, for us now, for you soon."
Europe: (patronisingly) "stop scaremongering"
[Baltics invest in vigilance, resilience, deterrence]
After 2022:
Europe: "You guys were right! And you're doomed, [commentariat drones on]...fragile, tiny, ex-Soviet frontline states... Little Green Men!! Red arrows on map!."
Baltics: "Actually, no imminent threat of invasion here. But you guys need to up your game"
The United States to Baltics: "STOP SCAREMONGERING!!"
Aliide retweeted
"The siege, we hope, is ending — but the assault on truth and perception is just beginning," write Peter Pomerantsev, executive editor of The Reckoning Project, and Aliide Naylor, a British-Estonian journalist and author, in this op-ed.
⠀
kyivindependent.com/starving…
Aliide retweeted
The humanitarian crisis in Russian-occupied #Oleshky is worsening, with civilians facing starvation and their suffering exploited for propaganda.
TRP co-Founder and Executive Editor @peterpomeranzev and @Aliide_N write in @KyivIndependent on why their plight cannot be ignored.
Read here: kyivindependent.com/starving…
Aliide retweeted
Russia backed Brexit, Trump & the truckers’ blockade. As today’s disrupted bot activity shows, Moscow supports the GOP ahead of mid-terms; the AfD, Farage, Le Pen & others in Europe; & Alberta’s separatists.
Allied democracies must end Russian malign influence for good.
Aliide retweeted
When the Guardian went on strike to protest the Observer sale, I became a de facto spokesperson. Later a Tortoise employee I’d never met wrote to me to cancel my 20-year contract. No goodbye & no pay-off. This is how they now take credit for my work..but write me out of the story
Aliide retweeted
The story is this: Trump’s Iran war has backfired so badly that he’s humiliated into unsanctionig Russian diesel while Iran proxies are pummelling the capital of Saudi, one of America’s key allies.
The U.S. is powerless in both cases. And it’s lost its leverage over Ukraine
Aliide retweeted
Europe feels rightly abandoned by the US. But this must be our wake-up call, not a moment of mourning. Arm Ukraine to the teeth. Tighten sanctions. Rebuild our military capabilities. Scale up Ukraine’s defence industry.
Europe must act faster — all it takes is political will.
Aliide retweeted
I just turned on @CNN and you would never know that diesel prices are high because of Trump’s war with Iran. They literally repeated Trump’s bullshit that farmers are paying high prices because of Ukraine. No mention of Russia’s mass murder, invasion, and U.S. betrayal
So gross
Aliide retweeted
We need way more diesel than what they're offering and what they're offering they cannot satisfy. That seems to be a consensus view among energy experts. So Russia gets immediate sanctions relief while gas prices remain more or less the same. If I were a cynic I might conclude this is a sneaky attempt at rapprochement with Moscow couched in the language of affordability, with a decisive election less than a month away. All it does in the short term is provide more money for Russia to wage war on Ukraine.
Aliide retweeted
Oh, yes. I do agree with Trump here. These attacks are not equal.
russia commits genocide by trying to freeze Ukrainians in winter, causing millions of civilian deaths.
Ukraine attacks a russian war machine to make this war end.
So why does Trump side with the perpetrator?
Aliide retweeted
A Russian attack with a glide bomb on an apartment building in the city of Zaporizhzhia killed at least eight people including three children overnight, reports Ukraine's human rights ombudsman. This adds to a grim tally of now more than 70 people in Ukraine slaughtered this week by Russian missiles, drones and bombs. Meanwhile, Donald Trump cuts a deal for diesel with Vladimir Putin.
Zaporozhzhia endured a hellish night. Five adults and three children were killed. This is a devastating tragedy. Eight lives cut short. Another 16 people were injured, including children. Two are in serious condition. The fate of another 12 people remains unknown. Russian strikes are once again bringing death to Ukrainian homes. My deepest condolences to everyone who has lost loved ones. No words can ease this pain. Evil must be punished. Those responsible must be held accountable for every life lost.
Aliide retweeted
Trump's latest betrayal of Ukraine is extraordinary. The same question arises: if he were a Russian asset what would he do differently?
Peace never comes through weakness. Today, representatives of the U.S. Congress were in Kyiv – a bipartisan delegation – and I am grateful to them for visiting Ukraine at such a difficult time. They asked: what is needed to end the war? The answer must be strong. There must be sanctions under the Lindsey Graham bill, there must be support for Ukraine in protecting lives, and there must be pressure on Russia for its war. And today, there was a conversation between the leaders of America and Russia. A conversation that leads to something different.
Recently, there was a European decision to lift sanctions on Russian oligarchs. Since then, Russian strikes and the torment of people have only increased. This past week alone, there was a brutal Russian missile strike on a residential building in Pryluky, aerial bombs were dropped on Kramatorsk – on ordinary city buses – and there have been constant attacks on Kyiv’s energy infrastructure and on the life-sustaining infrastructure in Dnipro, Kharkiv, Odesa, and our other cities. Dozens of people have been killed and hundreds wounded.
The Russians are compensating for their inability to achieve their objectives on the battlefield with this kind of terror. This year, Russia is weaker on the battlefield than at any other point in the war. That is why Putin is relying on terror. That is why he is relying on attempts to strike backroom deals to secure some form of pressure relief for Russia, in order to buy more time and more opportunities for war.
Any easing of sanctions against Russia without a clear and lasting de-escalation agreement with Russia is an obvious weakness. It plays into Russia’s hands – allowing it to kill more, wage war for longer, have even less respect for America, and inflict even greater losses and damage on the world.
Ukraine is ready to take symmetrical de-escalatory steps, and the American team knows our position. Our strikes on Russian oil refineries and other oil facilities are a response to Russia’s years-long campaign of terror against Ukraine’s energy sector. Ukraine will not set Russian oil refineries on fire if Russia does not destroy our energy infrastructure. This is the kind of agreement we are proposing to America, and we believe the United States has enough power to achieve such a compromise.
Gifts to Putin will not bring peace or any benefit to the civilized world. Russia will “repay” the diesel with further terror and perfidy. Allowing Russia to sell petroleum products is an investment in a war that must be ended, not prolonged. What is needed is real de-escalation with Russia on a reciprocal basis.
We count on America’s fair support for our defense of life, for our defense of people in Ukraine – and on the United States having a correspondingly strong conversation with Russia. A strong one, not a weak one.
Part three of our @TRPforJustice podcast for @BylineTimes. This episode explores the international pursuit of justice in the case of torture, looking at Latin America, Syria, and Russia-occupied Ukraine. Listen here (or wherever you get your podcasts)
bylinesupplement.com/p/no-hi…
Aliide retweeted
The EU is lifting sanctions on Russian billionaires and Putin’s friends.
Spain and Greece are refusing to hand over Patriot missiles to Ukraine, even though they’re about to expire.
Trump is negotiating with Putin to buy Russian diesel, lifting sanctions on it while imposing sanctions instead on... the International Criminal Court, which issued an arrest warrant for Putin over one of the most shameful war crimes: the deportation of children.
Presumably, this is exactly what Secretary Rubio had in mind when he spoke about Western civilization against the backdrop of the Acropolis.





























