Alex Onay retweeted
I typically avoid hot takes, but here are the reasons why the “comments/likes-instead-of-views” experiment on YouTube is terrible.
For context, in the past week, YouTube has launched an experiment where it shows the total number of comments and likes a video has instead of the total views.
Reasons why this is terrible
Reason 1: Content that sparks strong emotions, like controversy and drama, tends to get more comments and likes, which skews recommendations toward a drama-filled YouTube.
Insight: Coffeezilla, a respected creator known for his scam-related expose content, receives 46% more comments per view and 88% more likes per view than Ryan Trahan, who focuses on challenge-based content and has a broad appeal.
Reason 2: YouTube would force creators to encourage likes and spammy or even irrelevant comments, which would give those who don’t a disadvantage over those who do. This would also clutter the platform with low-value engagement.
Insight: By asking viewers to like your content, you can increase your likes by up to 100%.
Reason 3: Viewers use views as a form of social proof to decide which videos to watch because we trust it to accurately reflect how good a video is. However, when this accuracy decreases due to easily manipulated likes and comments, we will see a decline in long-term satisfaction, which will hurt not just the platform but also the creators.
Insight: Social proof is the concept that people are influenced in their decision-making by others, leading them to act based on others' actions.
Reason 4: Viewers, especially ‘passive’ viewers, may not always want to watch videos with high engagement; some prefer content that is simply entertaining or informative.
Insight: Educational or documentary-style content doesn’t always achieve the same comment-to-view or like-to-view ratio as entertainment content, where viewers are more engaged with the main character.
I understand that other platforms are starting to optimize for engagement since they are social platforms focused on sharing; however, this doesn’t mean that YouTube needs to follow suit. Even if these experiments show positive short-term signals, which I’m worried about, they could have very negative long-term consequences for many creators.
YouTube doesn’t need change; YouTube needs optimization.
Alex Onay retweeted
Today I turn 28.
I have dedicated over 50% of my life to obsessing over YouTube strategy and audience growth.
100s of channels, millions of revenue, billions of views later…
Here are 28 lessons for YouTubers:
Alex Onay retweeted
MY BRAND NEW SHOW IS FINALLY HERE!
After two years of development, we made it.
I present to you, Check This Out.
Link below!
Alex Onay retweeted
Every single one of these videos is AI-generated, and if this doesn't concern you at least a little bit, nothing will
The newest model: openai.com/sora
(Remember Will Smith eating spaghetti? I have so many questions)
Alex Onay retweeted
these plasma line ups might be the play
Forbidden CTF has been added to the Ranked Arena map rotation, along with additional updates to Extraction on Live Fire and Recharge!
Jump in and try it out now!
#HaloReckoning
Alex Onay retweeted
''The YouTube algorithm doesn't let you experiment''
We recently tried a completely new format with a client. It started slow. 6/10.
Now it's about to be our fastest ever video to hit 1 million views.
Some tips for experimenting with content on YouTube:
- Don't compare your experiment to your flagship videos (especially in the first few days).
- Experiment with your formats not your audience. Try new styles and ideas, but still keep your current viewer in mind.
- Try to ''bridge'' between your regular content and the experiment. Are there some elements from your regular content you can incorporate into the new format?
- Don't just look at view performance, also comment sentiment, retention curve behaviour. Views aren't the only way to deem if an experiment was a success.
- Make sure your next video after an experiment is an ''ol' reliable'' - don't do back to back experimental ideas, can churn viewers if they don't work out.
Go try something. Everyone gets 10/10s.
Alex Onay retweeted
Giveaway time ($4,000 value) 🎉
Want to learn directly from YouTube leaders like MrBeast and Michelle Khare? 🧠
We have got our hands on 4 VidSummit tickets to attend this years' event in Dallas!
To enter: Like, Repost and follow @yt_jobs 🚀
(Bonus entry for replies too!)
Alex Onay retweeted
You're not struggling as a YouTube because you're in a "saturated niche". (Bookmark this for later).
It's only saturated with low-effort content.
If anything, Small YouTubers struggle because of CONSOLIDATION, not Saturation.
CONSOLIDATION within a niche happens when a handful of players at the top monopolize views and have the resources to not only put out high-effort content but where enough of them can do it with consistency.
They will absorb most of the views for any given topic, be first to market on those topics, and will produce a better quality video in nearly every way, leaving very little room for Smaller channels that can't compete at that level.
SO HOW DO YOU COMPETE AND OVERCOME?
What should a small channel do?
HERE ARE SOME SIMPLE STEPS:
Identify the top 10 to 20 channels in your niche.
What makes them a top performer?
What makes them each unique in value?
What makes their content high effort?
Get your thumbnails on their level for one thing and any of your branding elements if possible.
(Stage your thumbnails with good photography and show effort at a glance, most big channels rely more on photography and photo manipulation than graphic design to make their thumbnails)
"Dress for the job you want". At a glance, you should look like you also deserve those views and attention.
Next, if and when possible, improve your production quality, it doesn't have to be extremely high or match theirs but get to the baseline of acceptable quality.
(Usually, shoot on a camera with an f/2.8 or f/1.8 lens, use a dedicated microphone for $100-$400, use decent lighting, and at least an $80 ring light)
Next, convey high effort through editing in the first 30-90 seconds of a video. People hover over a thumbnail to glance at the quality of the video production and editing now, so use that to your advantage.
(Edit every 1-2 seconds for the first 30-90 seconds of a video get and hold retention in the place it drops off the highest, TOP channels tend to get over 50-60% retention on videos under 12 minutes)
Doing these things will make you stand out from the bottom 90% of LOW-EFFORT CONTENT in your niche.
Beyond that, it will be now up to you to start putting more EFFORT INTO YOUR IDEAS.
If your niche has a group that has CONSOLIDATED attention and they also take similar points of view, but they get MILLIONS of VIEWS, there are likely HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS who are quietly dissatisfied with their approach or perspective...
If you can be equal or slightly below them in aesthetics, branding, and production value, but now you offer something to this UNDERSERVED AUDIENCE, then you now have UNIQUE VALUE to offer people who have a desire and a demand for something different.
No matter how large a channel's viewership is 10-20% of the viewers on any video or topic are unsatisfied.
You can use that math to understand the TOTAL ADDRESSABLE MARKET (TAM) that has demand for an alternative perspective.
This gives you key areas of improvement to focus on and how to stand out as a Smaller Channel.
Another thing you can do is BECOME the DAILY UPLOADER in your niche that also has "HIGH ENOUGH EFFORT".
As long as you can maintain a THRESHOLD OF ACCEPTABLE QUALITY, and you are hitting topics the community is already rallying around, this strategy does work (example: Tim Pool).
- Improve Your Branding and Aesthetics to COMPETE
- Improve Production Quality Overall
- Demonstrate HIGH EFFORT in Your Ideation
- Demonstrate HIGH EFFORT in THUMBNAILS
- Demonstrate HIGH EFFORT in First 30-90 Seconds
- Have UNIQUE VALUE PROPOSITION
- Find and UNDERSERVED VIEWERSHIP in the Niche
Alex Onay retweeted
Hollywood Studios reportedly are waiting for striking writers to go broke
“The endgame is to allow things to drag on until union members start losing their apartments and losing their houses,”








































