Eric Levitz retweeted
Replying to @theojaffee
"Easier" is too loaded because it conflates easy for humans with easy for AIs. But something like this should be your base case I think.
One heuristic that may be helpful is the question: how easy is it to take other fields and make them as 1) verifiable / objective / well-defined and 2) non-empirical / simulatable / solvable in silico as math? This would amount to cutting out a lot of the major bottlenecks to AI progress in research.
One reason to think this is really hard is that every field has been trying to do this since its inception. That is, every field has at one or another point attempted to reduce itself to theoretical formalisms (i.e. pure theories of biology, econ, etc.), and for the most part either failed, or succeeded only narrowly, and double-downed on empirical, experimental, or informal methods as a partial result.
IMO that very strongly implies we should see math as a special case, while acknowledging that AI will probably speed up our efforts to make other fields more math-like due to creating new incentives to come up with hill-climbable metrics. Your base case should be that this will be a very slow and inconsistent process, though.
xitter.cf/NateWitkin/status/2123…
Would've been hard to invent a more elegant microcosm of the clashing worldviews of Silicon Valley and Wall Street than the Riemann Hypothesis getting solved just as the AI trade is beginning to falter.
Cutting deep deductive pathways through the jungles of well-defined theoretical and digital systems is great. If only those systems were more akin to the ill-defined empirico-inductive ones in which we actually live.
BAAJA is good for data centers only in the sense that it will make electricity cheaper and more plentiful.
If you bombed 50% of America's transmission lines - causing a giant, indefinite power shortage - you would slow data center development. That doesn't make it a good idea!
BAAJA IS NOT A PRO-DATA CENTER BILL. States can ban them! The federal government can ban them!
Right now, data centers are often powered by inefficient, polluting gas because it is the fastest way to get power. What BAAJA *does* is fix our grid so communities aren't stuck with dozens of gas turbines with no air permits a half mile from their homes. That’s what happens when data centers can’t get on the grid fast. BAAJA also enable a tens-of-billions-of dollars per year wealth transfer from data center developers to the public (gridstrategiesllc.com/grid-f…).
Eric Levitz retweeted
BAAJA IS NOT A PRO-DATA CENTER BILL. States can ban them! The federal government can ban them!
Right now, data centers are often powered by inefficient, polluting gas because it is the fastest way to get power. What BAAJA *does* is fix our grid so communities aren't stuck with dozens of gas turbines with no air permits a half mile from their homes. That’s what happens when data centers can’t get on the grid fast. BAAJA also enable a tens-of-billions-of dollars per year wealth transfer from data center developers to the public (gridstrategiesllc.com/grid-f…).
Eric Levitz retweeted
this anecdote has nothing to do with permitting infrastructure. BAAJA does not abolish all federal environmental protections. It does not change any rules around EPA permits for demolition of materials like this.
Ok, but have you considered that my chatbot is very annoying
Katherine Dee says being mean to your chatbot is bad for you and calls it a form of "spiritual pollution":
Ruby: "Because I'm a decent person, I'm not going to yell at the machine. I'm not going to insult the machine. And then that possibility starts slowly to extend to other things in your life: the computer, the chair, the microphone."
Katherine: "It's so bad for you. You should be nice to everything. Even if it can’t feel anything, it's like spiritual pollution to treat anything with disrespect."
Ruby: "You heard it here first. Katherine Dee says be nice to your chatbots, not because they're conscious, but because it is good for your soul."
"Stop insulting Chat or Claude, not because they're conscious, but because you're a good person, and good people treat the world with kindness."
@being_on_line @default_friend
1
14
2,171
Eric Levitz retweeted
Debt, Democrats, and adultery...
Eric Levitz - @EricLevitz - on the perfect storm descending on #AI.
vox.com/politics/511132/anth…
Eric Levitz retweeted
Just to say that @rcobooth has been pumping out excellent content the last few weeks.
Both she and @EricLevitz are indispensable reading for those of us who like well thought out and reported policy reporting and why I subscribed to @voxdotcom.
Eric Levitz retweeted
great read from @EricLevitz on the end of AI's "charmed childhood"
vox.com/politics/511132/anth…
Eric Levitz retweeted
Hey, it's me, again. I want to zoom out on BAAJA for a second, because it’s easy to get lost in the weeds & debates about edge cases. I care *a lot* about this bill. Wanted to remind myself why.
The status quo is *terrible* for both climate and affordability. We built 888 miles of high-voltage transmission in 2024; we need 5,000 a year. More clean capacity is waiting in interconnection queues than the entire existing grid. Residential power prices are up about a third since 2019. Demand is surging, and bc clean power can’t connect, we're building a bunch of gas. If this current trend continues, gas could supply half of US power by 2040. The administration is using permitting as a weapon to stop wind and solar projects, including ones already approved. And local restrictions on wind and solar now cover twice as much of the country as in 2022.
I worked in the White House when we passed the IRA. As @BrianCDeese noted, if we had a bill like this in place first, it would have been game-changing. We invested hundreds of billions to put clean energy on sale, then watched projects get stuck in interconnection queues, permitting delays, and fights over who pays for transmission. The money was not the binding constraint; the ability to build was. Let’s not make the next Democratic administration learn that lesson twice!
It's easy to oppose stuff. But BAAJA is a *really, really big deal.* This is the first real federal framework to plan, pay for, and permit big power lines: mandatory planning between regions, clear rules on who pays (based on who benefits), and federal backstop siting that actually works across most of the country. It also ends incumbent utilities’ automatic right to build every new regional line. It will also help actually get projects online, by requiring grid planning and interconnection be done together, and stopping speculative projects clogging the queue. It should protect from political sabotage. Approved projects can’t be yanked for political reasons, and developers can sue if an administration targets a technology like wind for unfair treatment. It's the strongest data center accountability legislation in the country to ensure they pay *more* than the costs they cause and that households don’t foot the bill for AI’s grid upgrades.
This is the most important thing Congress can do for clean energy and affordability right now. We can fight about the emissions and affordability modeling about this narrow bill. But the truth is that this is the necessary but insufficient foundation *every future climate and affordability policy will be built on.*
Past a certain point, AI progress could be bad for Anthropic and OpenAI.
Once being "six months behind the frontier" still gets you a super-intelligent machine, not clear how many companies will want to pay extra for a slightly more super-intelligent one vox.com/politics/511132/anth…
If the AI buildout stays on its current course, it will be larger than any of America's modern infrastructure booms.
(Granted, when companies have built anything at this pace historically, they've tended to get over their skies and crash for a bit) vox.com/politics/511132/anth…
Eric Levitz retweeted
NEWS: Wall Street execs and NSA have told Congress that outages were caused by patching vulnerabilities identified by AI models, sources say
AI did not cause outages but found so many issues that the rush to fix them before an attack overwhelmed systems
washingtonsun.com/technology…
Eric Levitz retweeted
Isn’t this just objectively true?
This is the fundamental reason why climate action is so hard to achieve, as a cause!
It’s the reason why climate organizers have utilized a strategy of trying to weld alliances with communities affected by more proximate harms like pollution, Labor rights, Tribal sovereignty, local environment conservation, even things like racial justice and anti-war politics where the connection is a bit tenuous! It’s why climate organizers have tried to build alliances with capitalist interests like renewable energy developers. So many of the tensions in the climate movement arise because many of those allies don’t necessarily care if we *decarbonize* as long as their proximate interests are served. This is the fundamental tension at the root of BAAJA discourse, on BOTH sides!
That isn’t to say that the USA experiences no impacts, or that the impacts within the USA don’t fall disproportionately on more marginalized Americans. And it isn’t to say that unchecked climate change won’t get increasingly severe for America.
But it is just the truth that climate change is/will have a greater impact on people in other countries, mostly poor people in poor countries in equatorial regions, sooner and more severely.
In fact, some of the people who work primarily on global issues were very mad at the parts of the Inflation Reduction Act that were ostensibly the “environmental justice” sections, precisely from a justice-oriented critique that they prioritized marginalized Americans over even more marginalized developing countries’ people, but this was accepted as a necessary compromise to US political coalition-building!
Eric Levitz retweeted
Surprise billing reform happened before the current affordability mania and it was bipartisan, but this Rogé Karma piece should serve as your perennial reminder that good intentions and moral outrage can be harnessed toward poorly designed policies that go badly wrong
Eric Levitz retweeted
Data centers aren't subject to most federal permitting requirements because they aren't on public lands and have little actionable federal nexus. Wind and solar are more land intensive and transmission dependent than natural gas and hence more vulnerable to environmental permitting challenges. Federally approved natural gas pipelines have had eminent domain since 1947 and can't be blocked by individual states or landowners, unlike transmission lines. Other than that, no discrimination at all.
Replying to @wmcintyre84
Explain how some projects are getting blocked but others are not, presumably by the same rules. Are you saying the permitting rules discriminate against clean energy projects? Do the data center guys just have better lobbyists?
Eric Levitz retweeted
I think there’s a case that the problem is we have too little nudge rather than too much. Phones and internet make it too easy to gamble, live off of delivery servants, and be anti-social. Now, more than ever, we need to put friction on easy, bad activities.
Trevor Jackson on the corporate push behind the “nudge mania” of behavioral economics go.nybooks.com/48U5IMG
I saw Joanna Newsom at McCarren Park Pool in the summer of 2006. Ys wasn't out yet but I believe she played it front to back. Not sure I've ever been in a crowd that rapturously silent or effortfully attentive, all trying to decode the little harpist's profusion of gorgeous, cryptic imagery. Felt like small children transfixed by storytime, staring with our heads cocked in the broad daylight at this thing: Joy landlocked in bodies that don't keep, dumbstruck with the sweetness of being till we don't be
Eric Levitz retweeted
Leo is not anti-AI and infact stresses the benefits esp re medical advances and alleviation of suffering. Suffering for the sake of suffering is not good. But pain and limits and death are inevitable. Immortality is an illusion just as AI is not considered human, never will be.
Eric Levitz retweeted
Replying to @EricLevitz @HeerJeet
If I may, I think the pope is referring more to your points 1) and 3). That is resonant with the encyclical he is quoting from Magnifica Humantas, whose meditation on human limitations/finitude are IMHO the most powerful and least noted elements.
vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/e…






























