Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD) header
Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD) profile picture

Dermatopathologist (Derm trained Dermpath) It was love at first slide. Data analysis, Debates, Philosophy. https://xitter.cf/t.co/jJQcOXJykn

Joined December 2019
Photo by Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD)Photo by Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD)Photo by Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD)Photo by Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD)Photo by Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD)Photo by Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD)Photo by Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD)Photo by Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD)Photo by Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD)Photo by Avi Bitterman, MD (@AviBittMD)
Hey so remember when I was getting shit for opposing Mamdani on this because they didn't believe my prediction that he would actually release criminals back on the streets couched in "alternative-to-incarceration" programs? Welp, his new Rikers plan is out. And not only does it not meet the promised 2027 deadline (pushed out to 2032), it STILL calls for releasing hundreds charged with class B felonies with alternative-to-incarceration programs. Also of note, no where in the plan does it mention that those released will only those with non-violent class B charges, or that whether the crime was violent or not would even serve as the basis of risk assessment. Furthermore when the plan parenthetically lists examples of such class B felonies that it suggests may be for targeted reduction (as opposed to diversion at the point of arraignment), they are explicitly listed as "attempted murder and first-degree: robbery, rape, burglary, and assault". 🙃
The closure of Rikers Island by 2027 is probably the most important issue of the entire debate yet it was only covered for a few minutes. So let me be clear: We currently have NO alternative to Rikers ready to handle its prisoner/detainee population. If it does close, in practice approximately 3,700–4,300 individuals would need to be diverted from incarceration (up to 7,669 if replacements delayed) through mechanisms like bail reform, expedited court processing, "alternative-to-incarceration" programs, or releases, effectively reducing the detained population by more than half. About half of this population are being held for violent crimes including murder, rape, and assault. Do not let anyone (including Zohran) tell you that it's not their position to blanket release these prisoners. This is technically true in theory but misleading because these alternative-to-incarceration programs are not considered blanket releases, but in practice, they basically are in the sense that these people will ultimately be back on the streets as we have no other practical way to handle such a population in the current timeframe that Zohran is insisting on.
2
4
33
1,222
The full story behind this retraction is wild. Just an incomprehensible degree of consistent fraud that harmed so many people. We need to have laws on the books for things like this. newyorker.com/magazine/2026/…
The Lancet is retracting a 2006 Case Report by Koren et al, following the outcome of a formal investigation. The investigation found that important results from the infant’s toxicology reports were omitted from the paper, including the infant’s blood codeine and acetaminophen levels, and the finding that codeine was present in the baby's stomach contents. The report concluded that these omissions amounted to falsification. Read more: spkl.io/60177jReH
2
7
90
5,516
This was the "Baby Boy Blue" case (Rieder & Koren, Paediatrics & Child Health, 2010) This was a different publication but by the same author, as the now retracted Lancet case the 2006 paper ("Pharmacogenetics of morphine poisoning in a breastfed neonate of a codeine-prescribed mother"), which reported the 2005 death of a real infant, but omitted key details that changed the interpretation of the cause of death.
1
31
3,252
If we lived in a world where humans were bred by the billions into factory farms and slaughtered for their flesh, with no plausible future ban in sight, then making lab grown human meat would be at the top of my priorities. Hopefully it would be at the top of yours too.
Replying to @ryxtopia
You don't replace human slavery and cannibalism with lab grown human meat, you simply ban cannibalism/slavery because you recognise humans are not meat and their bodies shouldn't be objectified. That's the mindset we need to actually save animals and abolish animal slavery too.
11
19
1
210
3,370
Now imagine when the ICJ rules on the Israel v South Africa genocide case if virtually 100% of the discourse ends up being about meticulously dissecting every detail solely for the purpose of figuring out how the court will likely rule on a further case down the line 🙃
4
3
53
2,755
The ICJ ruled Myanmar guilty of genocide against the Rohingya. This is the first time the ICJ has held a state responsible for committing genocide under the Genocide Convention. Previously the ICJ ruled that genocide occurred at Srebrenica, but it did not attribute the genocidal acts to Serbia under the rules of state responsibility (it held that Serbia was responsible only for violating its obligations to prevent the genocide and to punish the perpetrators). In this case the ICJ ruled that Myanmar as a state was guilty of committing the act of genocide itself. The vote: 9-6 on the core finding that Myanmar committed genocide (also 9-6 on the finding that Myanmar failed to prevent genocide). This is a closer vote than I was expecting. It's also an unusually close ICJ vote on the merits of these sorts of claims. Other things of note that some were keeping an eye out for: 1) Whether the ICJ would change the "only reasonable inference" requirement in order to come to the Genocide conclusion. It didn't. The ICJ maintained its jurisprudence. 2) Whether the ICJ would re-evaluate killings in the mere service of ethnic cleansing to be sufficient for concluding genocide. Here too, it didn't. The ICJ maintained its previous "both can co-exist but mere ethnic cleansing is not genocide" approach and still found Myanmar guilty. Why? The ICJ noted several observations that were not reasonably compatible with killings that were merely in service of ethnic cleansing. Here are the strongest ones, in my view: 1) The ICJ noted that security forces attacked Rohingya as they were fleeing toward Bangladesh, which is inconsistent with simply driving them out. If a group is fleeing and will end up away from the land you seek to ethnically cleanse anyway, why go out of your way to kill them? 2) The ICJ noted summary executions, which are also challenging to explain with mere ethnic cleansing motivations alone. If they already surrendered to you, posed no threat, and you have full control of them and the power to expel them, why execute them instead? For those noticing a pattern, summary executions (such as when an person surrenders and they are under control, yet are executed anyway) are a generalizably strong observation to appeal to as evidence for genocide, as alternative inferences tend to have a more challenging time reasonably accommodating them (without co-existing special intent) compared to many other types of killing. Of note, the systematic summary executions of Bosnian Muslim men and boys after the fall of Srebrenica were central to the ICJ’s conclusion in the 2007 judgment that those events constituted genocide. Here too, the summary executions of Rohingya were one of the factors that made genocidal intent viewed as the only reasonable inference.
5
18
2
118
6,436
I will never understand people who seem to be rooting against lab made meat technological advancements. Not just being skeptical of it, but actually rooting against it and hoping that it never happens. This will never make sense to me. If technology could progress and offer meat that's healthier, tastier, less expensive, and without the slaughter, why in the world would that be a bad thing? Is it because of some naturalistic aesthetic of being one with nature (by which in most cases we really mean dragging a crated animal through its own shit and piss from a factory farm to a slaughterhouse)? Is it just to own the vegans? Or is it just to keep torturing animals, because we can? The whole thing just seems downright psychotic. This has got to be one the most evil positions I've ever come across here. And there's no shortage of evil positions on this platform.
62
57
7
490
9,751
Re: You can't say issue X is a confounder to the performance of different healthcare systems because it's at least SOMEWHAT of a health related issue 💡🤡 I am begging people to understand that not all "healthcare related issues" are equally easy to be treated or prevented by a healthcare system. No matter how good any healthcare system is, there are certain "healthcare related issues" that are much more difficult to change from the efforts of any healthcare system, and are ultimately still largely influenced by factors outside of the healthcare system. So yes. If one country has a bunch of such issues, they're still plausible confounding factors despite also being "healthcare related issues". That can change over time though! For example, with GLP-1 drugs gaining traction, obesity related diseases will become a much more healthcare amenable condition than it was before. But of course, for observations prior to the GLP-1 era, the reality was that obesity related conditions were much harder to prevent and were more heavily influenced by factors outside of the healthcare system than they are with such a drug class. So if you have a high impact healthcare system lever to pull that will likely make a big difference (GLP-1s), then yes, you should pull it! But if you don't, it might be better to spend that money outside of the healthcare system if there's a better non-healthcare related lever that might change what we are labeling as a "healthcare related issue".
3
1
8
1,348
OK so WoW or GTA6?
12
11
2,310
When I was in medical school, a professor lectured the class and proudly displayed the famous "Life expectancy vs healthcare expenditure" graph as evidence that the US healthcare system spends so much and yet the healthcare system performs worse than other OECD countries. Of course, back then I didn't know all the different ways in which this graph is nothing short of one of the most misleading pieces of slop propaganda that should be disqualifying to anyone who cites it...but I did think of at least one potential issue at the time. After the lecture, I walked up to the professor and asked just one question: "Were these different life-expectancies adjusted for confounding factors (beyond mere age/sex standardization)?" The lecturer froze for several seconds. Then said "Uhh...yes. They were...Yes." I politely nodded and thanked him for his time. But I suspect he didn't know, and I suspect he knew I suspected that he didn't know too. Of course, he was wrong. Zero of such confounders are adjusted for in this graph. So why did a professional of such respected standing tell me otherwise and mislead a trainee? Believe it or not, I suspect he didn't even mean to lie. I think what happened is no one bothered to ask the question before, he never bothered to think of it before, and when it was finally first presented to him, he simply assumed that whoever was behind this graph must have done at least some sort of causally informed adjustment modeling for baseline risk factors or else such a graph would be ridiculous. So he just figured such a thing must have surely happened. But of course, it never did. And across the numerous well-cited professional working papers smearing the US for its poor quality healthcare by comparing outcomes to other countries, it has basically never happened. Not back then, and not now. Of course, that's just the tip of the iceberg of insane issues with this graph, but for me, this was the beginning. It was the point when I realized that so much of the anti-US healthcare propaganda work might just be slop motivated by policy driven ideology rather than any genuine interest in how the US healthcare system actually performs in reality. And incidentally, it's my view now that when all the basic level 0 issues are corrected, the evidence indicates that the US actually delivers the highest quality of healthcare over and above the other countries listed here. But that's a post for another time.
228
64
12
987
142,990
For an in-depth breakdown of the attributable and non-attributable causes that contribute to the illusion of the life-expectancy gap being due to differences in the US healthcare system (and yes, lots of more graphs!), see the following analysis: cremieux.xyz/p/america-rich-… This was solid, but even this is not a full PICO style comparison of the healthcare system's intervention on given health conditions adjusted for confounders beyond age/sex and reporting at the individual patient level. For that analysis, it is my view that the US healthcare quality doesn't just reach equality, but it comes out on top. Stay tuned, because that's a big write-up and will be a very data heavy post. Oh and for an in-depth explanation of the healthcare cost differences between countries being explained not by quality of care or lifespan, but by wealth of the various countries, see the following: randomcriticalanalysis.com/w…
7
2
1
78
10,386
Over 99.9% of broiler chickens are factory farmed. If you're against this, you're a monster.
I'm vegan, but I went to a steakhouse tonight and got the chicken. It was real chicken, grown from cells in big stainless steel tanks by @UPSIDEFoods instead of cut from a slaughtered animal. It went on restaurant menus today. It was amazing. We're living in the future!
78
65
2
1,332
26,392
I suspect the main reason behind why some people don't like @pangram is because unlike other AI detectors, Pangram actually works.
4
1
39
2,158
This is all JD has. Blame Israel while pushing for surrender and blame transwomen while caking up his face in full makeup. Dems could probably run any DSA lunatic against this clown and win at this point.
Vance on new FAA Funding: We could absolutely do this with Democrats in the new congress if they set aside their ridiculous obsession with men in women’s sports.
3
1
41
1,768
That said, if they want to really secure the win they should probably run Ossoff.
1
6
605
No neocon wants there to be a "forever war", or for it to go on "indefinitely". What they want is to win the war. JD could argue that isn't realistic, or that we've somehow already won (lol) as he dreams up his next MOU surrender deal, but this characterization is just nonsense.
Vance rips neocons on Iran: "The people who want it to become a forever war can attack me all they want. We signed up to not do this. We told the American people we would do no more forever wars. We are NOT going to stay there forever. We promised we wouldn't."
3
1
25
1,244
It's concerning that such a large part of the case for Medicare for All (M4A) involves people straight up helping themselves to cartoonishly fictional numbers that almost certainly do not even remotely represent reality. Presenting the Galvani (2020) figure of 68,000 people based on a poorly adjusted comparison of mortality rates, a biased exclusion of Medicare, Medicaid, and VA/CHAMPUS recipients that increased the mortality gap, and with the entirety of the effect attributed to insurance coverage status instead of the numerous confounders that come along for the ride is incredibly misleading and should give people reason to be cautious about taking what you say about this topic seriously (and if these issues are corrected, the result is essentially null btw). Of note, the causally informed randomized interventional data available do not even remotely show anything close to this figure on an intention-to-treat analysis, and even when taking the most extreme upper limit of the 95% CI (Re: hurr but the OHIE trial was underpowered 4 mortality) we still don't get such a figure. Bernie continues to live in a fantasy world. As do the rest of the Medicare for All (M4A) advocates who cite the Yale slop study (or anything from Galvani really), Data for Progress polling, or just their intuitions about administrative burdens and how low-value care partitioning will pan out. It is already incredibly challenging to have serious good faith discussions with intellectually honest interlocutors about M4A who are willing to be forthcoming about the very real drawbacks and why they think the case for the benefits M4A offers outweighs them when anti-vaxxers are more willing to acknowledge the risks of going unvaccinated than these lunatics are willing to acknowledge just about any drawback of the system they are insisting we subject the entire nation to. It's even more challenging when they feel entitled to help themselves to any comical figures as established empirical fact on top of that.
At a time when 68,000 people a year die unnecessarily because they can’t afford to get to a doctor on time, we need to develop a sense of urgency. Healthcare is a human right. We must pass Medicare for All.
17
31
150
11,396